If you want a heavy-duty, fixed-mount solution for standard towing on specific SUVs like the Buick Enclave or Chevrolet Traverse, choose REESE 84184; if you need precise tongue weight measurement and adjustable height for tire maintenance and diverse trailer setups, choose Weigh Safe Aluminum. This isn't about guessing which brand has better marketing; it is about matching the hardware to your specific hauling reality. One of these is a robust piece of steel designed to stay put and handle maximum load, while the other is an engineered aluminum system built to give you data before you even hit the road.
• Best For: The REESE is for the driver who needs a simple, rugged connection for heavy, consistent loads on compatible vehicles, while the Weigh Safe is for the owner who prioritizes safety data, adjustability, and tire maintenance accuracy over raw static weight ratings.
The REESE 84184 is not trying to be everything to everyone; it is a precision-engineered Class 3 hitch designed for a very specific set of vehicles. If you own a 2018 through 2025 Buick Enclave, a 2018 through 2025 Chevrolet Traverse, or a 2018 through 2025 GMC Acadia, this unit fits perfectly because it is custom-built according to manufacturer specifications. That "custom design" aspect means you aren't dealing with generic brackets that might require modification. It slides into place as intended, providing a solid anchor point for your towing needs without the hassle of aftermarket fitting issues.
Strength is the primary selling point here, and the engineering reflects that. This mass isn't just for show; it contributes to the structural integrity required to withstand road abuse. The product undergoes rigorous fatigue and stress testing to meet and exceed V-5 and SAE J684 standards, ensuring that the welds hold firm under the strain of heavy travel.
However, this strength comes with trade-offs that define who should skip this option. The REESE 84184 is a fixed receiver with no ability to adjust the height of the hitch ball. If your truck sits lower than the trailer or if you are switching between different trailers with varying bumper heights, you will need separate leveling blocks or a different hitch entirely. Furthermore, there is no integrated way to measure how much weight is actually pressing down on the hitch. It is a workhorse, but it does not offer the diagnostic tools found in more modern, complex systems.
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-11-06 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
The Weigh Safe Aluminum model takes a completely different approach by focusing on versatility and safety through data. Instead of a static block of metal, this is an adjustable trailer hitch that allows for a 4-inch drop and a 5-inch rise in one-inch increments. This feature alone makes it incredibly valuable for owners who do not tow a single type of trailer every day. Whether you are pulling a low-profile utility trailer or a high-sided camper, you can dial in the exact angle needed to keep the vehicle level. This adjustability is crucial when you are performing tire maintenance or checking suspension geometry, as it ensures the vehicle is not being dragged down at an awkward angle.
The standout feature, however, is the built-in tongue weight scale. In an industry where many accidents happen due to improper loading, having the ability to weigh the tongue load right at the hitch is a game-changer. You can load your cargo, hook up the trailer, and see exactly how much weight is on the hitch before you leave the driveway. It also includes two stainless steel tow balls, sized at 2 inches and 2-5/16 inches, covering almost any standard trailer coupler you will encounter.
This product is ideal for the adventurer who values precision over brute force. The brushed aluminum finish offers a sleek look, and the inclusion of a keyed-alike dual pin lock and receiver pin lock adds a layer of security against theft. Because it is lighter and adjustable, it fits a broader range of vehicles and scenarios, provided the vehicle's frame can support the specific mounting requirements. It is perfect for someone who wants to ensure their tires are carrying the correct load distribution and who refuses to guess when it comes to safety. If you care about getting the numbers right before you drive, this is the tool for you.
• Best for Load Accuracy: If you need to verify your tongue weight to prevent sway and protect your vehicle's suspension, the Weigh Safe Aluminum's built-in scale is the only logical choice.
• Best for Vehicle Fitment: If you drive a 2018-2025 Buick Enclave, Chevy Traverse, or GMC Acadia and want a bolt-on solution that matches factory specs exactly, the REESE 84184 is the custom fit.
• Best for Adjustability: If you tow multiple types of trailers with different heights and need to fine-tune the ride height with 1-inch increments, the Weigh Safe Aluminum is superior.
• Best for Tire Maintenance: For maintaining proper tire pressure and wear patterns during towing, the Weigh Safe Aluminum allows you to balance the load precisely, whereas the REESE requires manual calculation.
• Best for Weight Reduction: If you prefer a lighter hitch that is easier to handle during installation, the 18-pound Weigh Safe Aluminum is significantly easier to manage than the 38-pound REESE.
• Best for Ball Variety: The Weigh Safe comes with both 2-inch and 2-5/16-inch stainless steel balls included, eliminating the need to buy separate hardware.
• Best for Corrosion Resistance: While both offer protection, the REESE relies on a two-part black powder coat on steel, whereas the Weigh Safe utilizes aluminum construction which naturally resists rust without a coating.
In my opinion, I would choose the Weigh Safe Aluminum for almost any scenario involving personal towing. The ability to know exactly how much weight is on the hitch changes the entire dynamic of safe driving. Towing is dangerous enough without guessing whether your tongue weight is too high or too low. The adjustability features make it adaptable to any situation, and the included stainless steel balls save money and hassle. However, if you strictly tow a specific heavy load on a compatible GM SUV and never need to adjust the height, the REESE 84184 remains a solid, no-nonsense choice for pure strength. Ultimately, for tire maintenance and overall safety, the data provided by the Weigh Safe system is worth the investment.
No, the REESE 84184 is specifically designed for 2018-2025 Buick Enclave, Chevrolet Traverse, and GMC Acadia SUVs. It is not listed as compatible with general pickup trucks or other vehicle classes.
No, the built-in scale mechanism on the Weigh Safe Aluminum hitch operates mechanically and does not require external power sources or batteries to function.
The REESE 84184 uses steel with a powder coat finish to resist rust, while the Weigh Safe Aluminum uses a natural aluminum alloy that does not rust, offering different long-term maintenance profiles depending on your environment.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.