How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a versatile wired headset with a detachable mic and a genuinely comfortable over-ear fit, choose Redragon H510; if you need a lightweight, USB-A plug-and-play headset with a certified mic for clear team chat, choose ASUS TUF Gaming H1. Both are wired gaming headsets. They solve different problems, and the right call comes down to how you connect and what you value on your head for hours at a time.
• Redragon H510's biggest strength: 7.1 surround sound from 53mm drivers, memory foam ear pads, and a detachable noise-cancellation mic that you can pull off when you're not talking.
• Redragon H510's biggest trade-off: It's a heavier build at 700 g, and the 3.5mm connection means some older consoles may need an adapter that isn't included.
• ASUS TUF Gaming H1's biggest strength: A 297-gram metal suspension headband and a TeamSpeak-certified unidirectional mic, all over a simple USB-A connection.
• ASUS TUF Gaming H1's biggest trade-off: USB-A only, so it's tethered to PC and PlayStation rather than the wider spread of devices the H510 reaches.
• Redragon H510 is for you if: you want one headset that hops between PC, PlayStation, Xbox, Switch and mobile, and you like control right on the cable.
• ASUS TUF Gaming H1 is for you if: you play on PC or PS5/PS4 and want something light, clean and quick to set up.
The H510 leans into audio hardware. Its 53mm dynamic drivers cover a frequency range of 50–20000 Hz with an impedance of 64 ohm, and Redragon pairs that with 7.1 surround processing for positional cues. In practice, that's the kind of setup that helps you place footsteps behind you, hear a reload off to your left, or catch a distant callout in a squad shooter. The memory foam ear cushions and leatherette covering are the other half of the pitch — the pads are built thick and breathable so heat builds up slowly during long sessions.
Comfort is a mixed bag on paper. The free-adjustable headband is wrapped around a steel frame, which suggests it can take some abuse, and the over-ear design spreads clamp pressure across a wider area. But the listed weight is 700 g, so this is not a featherweight. In my opinion, that's the number to weigh carefully if you're sensitive to pressure on the crown of your head or you play in marathon stretches.
The detachable noise-cancellation microphone is the feature I'd point a buyer toward. You get the clearest comms when you need them and a plain music headset when you don't — useful if you also listen on the couch. Add the independent inline control (volume up/down, mic on/off, sound on/off) and you can mute and adjust with one hand without breaking focus. The trade-off is connectivity friction: the H510 runs on a 3.5mm jack with a braided cable and USB control box, but some older console models may need an adapter that isn't in the box. Buy it if you want flexibility and don't mind checking your port situation first.
The H1 Gen II takes the opposite approach: strip the setup down to nothing. It connects over USB Type-A, plugs in and works, and ASUS builds it around a 297-gram frame with a metal suspension headband. That's less than half the listed weight of the H510, and suspension bands are specifically designed to float the headset rather than press it flat — a real advantage if long raids leave you with a sore spot.
Audio comes from ASUS Essence drivers with virtual 7.1 surround and a frequency range of 20 Hz – 20,000 Hz at 32 ohm. That's an easier load to drive than the H510's 64 ohm, which matters if you're plugging straight into a PC or console without an amp. The unidirectional mic is TeamSpeak-certified — a concrete signal that ASUS tuned it for voice clarity, and unidirectional patterns pick up less room noise than an open mic.
The practical details are where the H1 earns its keep. The ear cushions are removable and resistant to alcohol and hypochlorous acid, meaning you can wipe them down regularly instead of watching them degrade. TUF white lighting adds a bit of desk presence. The honest trade-offs: the connection is USB-A only, so no mobile or Switch use, and the noise control field is listed as none — there's no active cancellation here, just the passive isolation of the faux leather, metal and plastic enclosure. Buy it if your setup is PC or PlayStation and you want light, simple and easy to maintain.
• Best for marathon comfort → ASUS TUF Gaming H1. At a listed 297 g versus 700 g, the suspension headband is the lighter, more forgiving option over hours.
• Best for positional audio hardware → Redragon H510. 53mm drivers and 7.1 surround give you the bigger, more immersive soundstage.
• Best for clear team chat → ASUS TUF Gaming H1. A TeamSpeak-certified unidirectional mic is built specifically for voice.
• Best for muting on the fly → Redragon H510. Inline volume and mic on/off controls are right on the cable.
• Best for multi-platform use → Redragon H510. 3.5mm reaches PC, PS4/3, Xbox One/Series X and Switch; the H1 is USB-A only.
• Best for plug-and-play simplicity → ASUS TUF Gaming H1. USB-A means no adapters, no splitter cables, no guesswork.
• Best for easy cleaning → ASUS TUF Gaming H1. Removable, alcohol-resistant ear cushions are made to be wiped down.
• Best if you want a detachable mic → Redragon H510. Pull the mic off and it becomes a plain listening headset.
If I were buying for myself, I'd take the ASUS TUF Gaming H1. The 297-gram weight and suspension headband matter more to me than a bigger driver, because discomfort is what actually ends a session early, and the TeamSpeak-certified mic covers the one job a gaming headset has to nail. I'd only switch to the Redragon H510 if I needed one headset to cover Xbox, Switch and mobile as well as PC — the 3.5mm flexibility and inline controls are genuinely useful, but I'd want to be sure the heavier build suited my head first. Either way, check the current price on Amazon before you commit, since your budget may settle the tie.
FAQ
how much gaming headphones
how to game with bluetooth headphones
Neither of these headsets is Bluetooth — the H510 uses a 3.5mm jack and the TUF Gaming H1 uses USB-A. For a Bluetooth headset you'd pair it in your device's settings menu, but be aware Bluetooth adds latency, which is exactly why wired connections like these two are still common for gaming.
is gaming better with headphones
For most players, yes — a headset gives you positional audio and a mic in one device. The H510's 7.1 surround and 53mm drivers are aimed at placing sound around you, while the H1's virtual 7.1 and Essence drivers do the same job at a lighter weight.
are gaming headphones good for calls
They can be. The H510's detachable noise-cancellation mic and the H1's TeamSpeak-certified unidirectional mic are both built for voice. Just remember the H1 needs a USB-A port, so it won't work on a phone without an adapter.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Generic Over Ear Headphones vs Xmenha Mini, PROTEAR Kids Ear Protection vs RCA Wave-55, Sony RF Headphones vs Generic Black Panther Kid: Non in Ear, zaoalife Retro Over-Ear Headphone vs Calsgkspray Black Retro Over-Ear