How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want soft protein-leather pads with reinforced stitching for straightforward replacement on Headphones 1 and Headphones 2, choose Qiilu Comfortable Replacement Ear; if you need thick, high-density memory foam cushions that fit a wider range of headsets and come with a 90-day manufacturer warranty, choose Sunxtzyl 2PCS.
• Qiilu Comfortable Replacement Ear — biggest strength: explicitly listed compatibility with Headphones 1 and Headphones 2, so you know before you order whether it fits. Biggest trade-off: it is a model-specific pad, so it is the wrong pick if you own anything else.
• Sunxtzyl 2PCS — biggest strength: high-density memory foam plus a 90-day manufacturer warranty, and the listing is written as a general-purpose replacement rather than tied to one model. Biggest trade-off: no specific headphone models are named, so you have to confirm your own fit.
• Qiilu Comfortable Replacement Ear is for you if you own Headphones 1 or Headphones 2 and want a like-for-like refresh with sound isolation from protein leather.
• Sunxtzyl 2PCS is for you if you want thicker memory-foam padding, reinforced stitching and a stated warranty, and you are comfortable matching the pads to your own headset.
• Quick call: exact model match → Qiilu. Thicker foam and a warranty → Sunxtzyl.
Qiilu's pitch is narrow and honest: these are replacement ear cushions for Headphones 1 and Headphones 2. That specificity is the whole point. If you already own one of those two models, you are not gambling on whether the pad will line up — the compatibility is stated up front. The pad itself is built from protein leather over sponge, sold as a pair, and the design leans on high-density protein leather to create sound isolation.
The comfort story here is about materials and construction rather than bulk. Qiilu uses upgraded protein leather with reinforced stitching, which is the part that matters over months of daily wear: stitching is usually what fails first on a cheap pad, not the foam. The pad is also described as flexible, which helps it seat around your ear without feeling stiff out of the box. For someone replacing flattened, flaking cushions on a pair of Headphones 1 or 2, that is exactly the job.
Who should buy it: owners of Headphones 1 or Headphones 2 who noticed their sound got thinner and their ears got sore, and who want a clean, model-matched swap. Who should skip it: anyone whose headphones are not Headphones 1 or Headphones 2. There is no universal sizing claim here, and I would not stretch it. Also skip it if you specifically want a thick memory-foam pillow feel — that is not what this pad is described as.
Sunxtzyl 2PCS: Who It's For
Sunxtzyl takes the opposite approach. Instead of naming two headphone models, it markets the 2PCS pads as a general replacement for worn-out cushions, built from soft protein leather over high-density memory foam, with reinforced stitching and a manufacturer warranty covering 90 days. That warranty is the standout detail on this data sheet — it is the only one of the two products that states any coverage at all.
The memory foam changes the feel. Where Qiilu emphasizes protein leather and a flexible, isolating fit, Sunxtzyl emphasizes thickness: dense foam that cushions the ear, blocks outside noise, and is described as staying comfortable and cool across long listening sessions. The listing also stresses that the pads won't squeeze your ears — a real concern with thicker foam, because a pad that is too plush can clamp down on the ear and get hot after an hour. Sunxtzyl claims to have designed around that.
Installation is the same idea as any replacement pad: remove the old cushion, attach the new one. The listing frames it as a fast upgrade, and there is nothing in the spec sheet suggesting tools or adhesives.
Who should buy it: anyone with a headset whose stock pads have gone flat, who wants thicker memory-foam padding than a basic sponge pad, and who values having a stated 90-day warranty behind the purchase. Who should skip it: anyone who wants a guaranteed, model-specific fit. Because no headphone models are named, you are the one who has to confirm the pads match your ear cup shape and mounting style. If you own Headphones 1 or 2 and want zero guesswork, Qiilu is the safer order.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for thicker padding and a memory-foam feel → Sunxtzyl 2PCS. High-density memory foam versus protein leather over sponge.
• Best for warranty coverage → Sunxtzyl 2PCS. It is the only one of the two with a stated 90-day manufacturer warranty.
• Best for a low-risk, model-matched replacement → Qiilu Comfortable Replacement Ear. No sizing judgment required if you own the listed models.
• Best for long listening sessions → Sunxtzyl 2PCS. Its design language centers on cushioning the ear and staying cool and comfortable over time.
• Best for noise isolation → either, with a caveat. Both use protein leather and both claim isolation; Qiilu leans on high-density leather, Sunxtzyl on dense foam. I would expect them to be comparable, and neither claims active noise cancellation.
• Best for durability-minded buyers → Qiilu Comfortable Replacement Ear for stitching, Sunxtzyl 2PCS for warranty. One invests in build, the other backs it in writing.
• Best for anyone who owns neither listed model → Sunxtzyl 2PCS, since it is not tied to specific headphone names — but verify your fit first.
In my opinion, the deciding question is whether your headphones are Headphones 1 or Headphones 2. If they are, I would buy the Qiilu Comfortable Replacement Ear — the stated compatibility removes the single biggest risk in buying replacement pads, and the reinforced stitching plus protein leather is a sensible, durable build for everyday use.
If your headphones are anything else, or if you want the plusher memory-foam feel and the reassurance of a 90-day manufacturer warranty, I would buy the Sunxtzyl 2PCS instead. It asks a little more of you at the fit-check stage, but it gives more back in comfort and coverage. Check the current price on Amazon for both before you commit.
FAQ
No. The listing is written as a general replacement pad and does not name specific headphone models, so it is not a universal fit. Measure your ear cups and check the mounting style before ordering, and note that the 90-day manufacturer warranty applies to defects, not to fit.
Both rely on protein leather and both claim noise isolation, but neither advertises active noise cancellation. Qiilu highlights high-density protein leather; Sunxtzyl highlights dense memory foam. Realistically, a well-sealed pad on the correct headphone will beat a loose pad on the wrong one, so fit matters more than the marketing wording.
Both are two-piece sets. Qiilu lists two headphone ear pads, and Sunxtzyl's package is listed as 2 x headphone ear pads — enough for one pair of headphones in each case.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GEVO Ear Cushions Replacement vs Qianjyvous 2PCS, GEEKRIA Replacement Ear Pads vs GEVO Ear Cushions Replacement, Prtukyt 6S vs Earrock Replacement Ear Cushions