How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want an open-ear neckband that keeps you aware of traffic and your surroundings while you run or ride, choose Purity Air Open Ear; if you need a soft fabric headband you can actually fall asleep in, choose Lavince Sleeping Headphones. These two look similar on a search page and solve completely different problems, so the right pick comes down to one question: do you want your ears open to the world, or do you want them wrapped in fabric on a pillow?
• Purity Air Open Ear — biggest strength: true open-ear air conduction with dual 15mm dynamic drivers and dual-mic noise cancellation for calls, so your ears stay unblocked while audio plays.
• Purity Air Open Ear — biggest trade-off: it's a rigid neckband, and that hard plastic band is not something you can roll onto a pillow in bed.
• Lavince Sleeping Headphones — biggest strength: a stretch-fabric headband with built-in speakers that doubles as a sleep mask-style band, plus up to 12 hours of playback versus 6.
• Lavince Sleeping Headphones — biggest trade-off: on-ear speakers inside fabric give you less isolation control and no active noise cancellation for calls, and it's not designed to keep you aware of your surroundings the way an open-ear set is.
• Who each is for: Purity Air Open Ear for runners, cyclists and gym-goers who need situational awareness; Lavince for side sleepers, nappers, meditators and travellers who want audio that disappears into a pillow.
The Purity Air Open Ear is built around one idea: get sound to your ears without ever plugging them. The neckband hangs behind your neck, the two speakers rest against the outside of your ears, and you push them gently toward the center of each ear until they sit comfortably. Nothing goes inside the ear canal. That's the entire point of air conduction, and it's why this design appeals to people who hate the pressure and heat of traditional earbuds.
What it does best is situational awareness. Because your ears stay open, you hear cars, other runners and your surroundings while the audio plays — which is the whole reason IPX5 water resistance and a secure fit matter here. Purity positions this as a fitness product, and the specs back that up: IPX5 handles sweat and light rain, Bluetooth 5.3 gives you a 10-metre wireless range, and the 2.8-ounce build is light enough that the brand leans hard on "long wearing comfort." For calls, a dual-microphone setup cancels ambient background noise while protecting your voice, and you get touch and button controls for call management. Two 15mm dynamic drivers cover a 20 Hz – 20,000 Hz range at 18 ohm impedance, which tells you Purity is chasing detail and clarity rather than thumping bass. Battery life is rated at 6 hours, and charging is done through a magnetic cable that connects to the charging points on the right speaker.
Buy it if you run outdoors, cycle, lift, or work in an environment where you need to hear what's happening around you while music or a podcast plays. Skip it if your main goal is falling asleep to audio. A neckband with a plastic band and speakers resting on your ears is not what you want pressed against a pillow, and 6 hours of playback won't cover a full night anyway.
The Lavince Sleeping Headphones take the opposite approach: instead of leaving your ears open, they wrap your whole head in a soft stretch-fabric band with speakers built in. Lavince calls it a 2-in-1 sleep and sports headband, and that framing is honest — it's one product trying to be two things. At 1.6 ounces and just 3.82 inches wide, it's notably lighter than the Purity neckband, and the construction is foam with a moisture-wicking inner layer and a hypoallergenic lining, which matters if you have sensitive skin or you're wearing it for hours at a time.
For sleep specifically, this is the right shape. There's no hard band digging into your temple when you roll onto your side — the fabric flexes with the pillow. Lavince also rates it for up to 12 hours of continuous playback or talk time on 1–2 hours of charging, which is roughly double the Purity's 6 hours and, crucially, enough to cover a night. Bluetooth 5.4 is the newer wireless standard here, and the brand claims high-performance drivers with deep bass and a rich midrange, which fits a product meant for music, meditation and white noise rather than calls in a noisy street. There's a built-in microphone for hands-free calls, and Lavince backs the headband with a 1-year manufacturer's warranty and a 30-day return policy.
Buy it if you want audio in bed without earbuds poking your ears, or if you want a headband that keeps hair and sweat in place during yoga, jogging or the gym. Skip it if calls in loud environments are your priority — there's no active noise cancellation for the mic here — or if you specifically need to stay aware of traffic, because a fabric band over your ears works against that.
• Best for situational awareness → Purity Air Open Ear. Open-ear air conduction leaves your ear canals free, so you hear traffic and surroundings while audio plays.
• Best for sleep → Lavince Sleeping Headphones. A soft fabric band is the only one of the two you can comfortably lie on, and 12 hours of playback covers a full night.
• Best for battery life → Lavince Sleeping Headphones. Up to 12 hours of playback or talk time versus 6 hours on the Purity.
• Best for calls → Purity Air Open Ear. Dual microphones with ambient noise cancellation are designed to protect your voice during calls.
• Best for workouts and sweat → either, with a caveat. Purity has IPX5 water resistance and a secure neckband fit; Lavince relies on a moisture-wicking fabric inner layer rather than a water-resistance rating.
• Best for bass-heavy music → Lavince Sleeping Headphones. Lavince's drivers are tuned for deep bass and a rich midrange, while Purity's 15mm drivers at 18 ohm lean toward clarity and detail.
• Best for the lightest possible wear → Lavince Sleeping Headphones. 1.6 ounces versus 2.8 ounces.
• Best for the newest Bluetooth → Lavince Sleeping Headphones. Bluetooth 5.4 versus Bluetooth 5.3 on the Purity.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the Lavince Sleeping Headphones — but only because I'd be buying it for sleep and everyday wear, which is where its 12-hour battery, 1.6-ounce fabric build and 5.4 Bluetooth genuinely pull ahead. In my opinion it's the more flexible product for the average buyer: bed, yoga, travel, the gym, all handled by one soft band. The Purity Air Open Ear is the better tool for one specific job — outdoor training with your ears open and reliable call audio — and if that's your job, buy the Purity instead. Just check the current price on Amazon for both before you commit, since value shifts over time.
Not really. It's a rigid neckband with speakers resting on your ears, and 6 hours of playback won't cover a night. The Lavince fabric headband is the better sleep choice.
The Lavince wins here — up to 12 hours of playback or talk time, charged in 1–2 hours. The Purity Air Open Ear is rated at 6 hours.
The Purity Air Open Ear has dual microphones with ambient noise cancellation for calls, but neither product has active noise cancellation for listening. The Lavince relies on its fabric padding instead.
Purity Air Open Ear. Open-ear air conduction keeps you aware of traffic, IPX5 handles sweat, and the neckband stays secure. The Lavince is fine for yoga and the gym, but it isn't built to keep you aware outdoors.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.