How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• PINTAUR Silicone Air Fryer's biggest strength: food-grade silicone liners that fit a wide range of 8–10QT dual-basket fryers and pull double duty in ovens, steamers and fridges.
• PINTAUR Silicone Air Fryer's biggest trade-off: it's a soft liner, not a rigid rack, so it won't give you the raised, open-grid airflow of a steel accessory.
• GCQ Air Fryer Replacement's biggest strength: a food-grade steel drip tray plus three mesh baskets designed to fit one specific Chefman 10QT fryer, with a grid pattern that pushes hot air evenly around food.
• GCQ Air Fryer Replacement's biggest trade-off: compatibility is narrow — it's made for the Chefman 10L model, so it won't fit Ninja, COSORI or other brands the way PINTAUR does.
• Who each pick is for: PINTAUR if you own a dual-basket fryer and want easy cleanup plus multi-appliance use; GCQ if you own the Chefman 10QT and want a genuine rack-and-tray replacement.
PINTAUR's product is a two-pack of reusable silicone liners sized at 8.67 x 5.9 x 2.68 inches. They're built to drop into 8–10QT dual-basket air fryers, and the brand lists compatibility with Ninja Foodi DZ201, DZ401, DZ550 and DZ302, COSORI 9QT, Instant, and other 6-in-1 dual-basket models. The walls are thick enough to hold their shape, and the material is food-grade silicone rated to 450°F, which covers the vast majority of air-frying, baking and reheating tasks.
The flexibility is the real selling point. This isn't only an air fryer accessory: PINTAUR lists it for baking ovens, microwaves, steamers, stoves, refrigerators, and even as a serving dish for fruit or plated food. Because it's gray and rectangular, it looks neutral enough to bring to the table. If you own a dual-basket fryer and you're tired of soaking baskets after every meal, this is a sensible buy. I'd skip it if you specifically want a rigid replacement rack for a single-basket Chefman — that's a different job, and this liner isn't shaped for it.
GCQ Air Fryer Replacement: Who It's For
GCQ's kit is a true replacement-part set rather than a liner. You get one drip pan and three mesh baskets, sized 9.3 x 8.6 inches and designed for the Chefman 10QT / 10L Multifunctional Digital Air Fryer with 17 touch-screen presets. The material is food-grade steel, BPA-free, rust-resistant, heat-resistant and dishwasher safe, with a nonstick coating on the pan.
The grid design is the functional heart of it. Open mesh lets hot air circulate around food from multiple angles, which is what gives you that dry, crisp exterior on fries, wings, chicken and vegetables. Because the set includes three baskets, you can cook in stages without emptying and washing between batches — load one rack, pull it, drop in the next. The pan underneath catches drips so the fryer cavity stays cleaner. GCQ also describes it as useful for drying vegetables, fruits and meats, and as a shelf for baking, so it's more of a workhorse tray system than a single-purpose accessory. A cleaning cloth is included in the box.
The catch is compatibility. GCQ built this for one specific machine — the Chefman 10L — and the size reflects that. If you own that fryer and your original rack or tray has worn out, warped or gone missing, this is exactly the kind of part you want. If you own a Ninja, COSORI or Instant dual-basket model, this set simply isn't meant for you.
• Best for dual-basket fryer owners (Ninja, COSORI, Instant) → PINTAUR Silicone Air Fryer, thanks to its listed 8–10QT dual-basket compatibility.
• Best for Chefman 10QT owners → GCQ Air Fryer Replacement, which is dimensioned for that exact model.
• Best for easiest cleanup → PINTAUR. The liner isolates food from the basket, and the striped base is designed for hand or dishwasher washing.
• Best for maximum air circulation and crisping → GCQ. Steel mesh racks let hot air reach food from more sides than a solid-bottom liner.
• Best for multi-appliance and serving use → PINTAUR. Ovens, microwaves, steamers, fridges and table service are all in play.
• Best for replacing a lost or worn part → GCQ. It's a genuine drip pan plus three racks, not an add-on liner.
• Best for lower-fat cooking → PINTAUR, since the raised strips separate food from collected oil.
• Best for cooking several batches in one session → GCQ, because the three mesh baskets let you rotate food without a full wash in between.
In my opinion, which one you should buy comes down to the fryer on your counter, not to the accessories themselves. If you own a dual-basket Ninja, COSORI or Instant model and want less scrubbing plus a liner you can also use in the oven, microwave or fridge, I'd buy the PINTAUR Silicone Air Fryer two-pack. If you own the Chefman 10QT and you need a steel drip tray and mesh racks that fit it, the GCQ Air Fryer Replacement is the one I'd pick — it's the only one of the two designed for that machine. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
PINTAUR. It's listed as compatible with Ninja Foodi DZ201, DZ401, DZ550 and DZ302, plus COSORI 9QT, Instant and other 8–10QT dual-basket fryers. GCQ is built for the Chefman 10L instead.
Steel mesh racks generally win on airflow, because the open grid lets hot air reach food from several directions — that's the GCQ design. PINTAUR's raised silicone strips still lift food off the base and keep air moving, which helps, but a mesh rack is the more aggressive crisping tool.
Yes. PINTAUR's silicone liner is designed for hand or dishwasher washing, and GCQ states its steel parts are dishwasher safe as well.
For GCQ, yes — it's sized 9.3 x 8.6 inches for the Chefman 10QT, so it won't suit other brands. PINTAUR covers a broader range of 8–10QT dual-basket fryers, but it's still worth confirming your basket dimensions.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GCQFZ Air Fryer Replacement vs Silique Kitchen Silicone Air Fryer, GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement vs MMH Air Fryer Silicone, GCQ Air Fryer Replacement vs GZHCJJ Air Fryer Grill