How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Perytong Sleep Headphones — biggest strength: a 2-in-1 sleep mask and sports headband with ultra-thin speakers, Bluetooth 5.2, a built-in mic and roughly 10 hours of playtime.
• Perytong Sleep Headphones — biggest trade-off: it's an open-ear fabric band, not a sealed headphone, so it won't block much outside noise on its own and the band is meant for indoor or mild outdoor use.
• HIGHEVER Ponytail Beanie — biggest strength: a genuinely warm knit hat with a ponytail opening, Bluetooth 5.0, up to 10–12 hours of playtime and 200 hours of standby.
• HIGHEVER Ponytail Beanie — biggest trade-off: it's winter-specific, and the ponytail opening means the fit and speaker placement are built around wearing your hair up.
• Choose Perytong Sleep Headphones if you want one fabric band for sleeping, napping, yoga, running and calls, and you like the idea of pulling the speakers out to wash it.
• Choose HIGHEVER Ponytail Beanie if you want music while you're outdoors in the cold — dog walks, hiking, snowboarding, commuting — and you wear your hair up.
Perytong's whole pitch is that one piece of fabric replaces two things you'd normally wear separately: a sleep mask and a pair of headphones. The band has two ultra-thin speakers set into the fabric, with the control module sitting in the middle of the band rather than on your ears. That detail matters — it's the reason the brand can say you can lie down or sleep on your side without a hard plastic pod digging into your ear. If you've ever given up on earbuds at night because they hurt after twenty minutes, that's the problem this design is aimed at.
The audio side is Bluetooth 5.2, with a dynamic driver rated from 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz, a built-in microphone and touch volume controls. Perytong claims about 2 to 2.5 hours to charge and more than 10 hours of playtime, so a single charge comfortably covers a night plus a workout. The band itself is braided cord with a breathable mesh lining, stretches to fit, and is listed at roughly 9.8–10.6 inches wide, which is a normal adult range. It's washable once you pull the speakers out, which is the practical detail that makes it usable as a gym and running accessory rather than a bedroom-only gadget.
Who should buy it: side sleepers, people with insomnia or noisy neighbours, travellers on long flights, and anyone who wants one band for the gym, yoga, jogging and a nap in the office. Who should skip it: anyone who needs serious passive noise blocking, anyone who wants the look of a real winter hat, and anyone who expects a snug over-ear seal — this is an open-ear fabric design, and that's the point.
HIGHEVER's beanie solves a much narrower problem, and it solves it well: wearing a hat with your hair up. The ponytail opening means thick, thin, curly or straight hair can sit in a high pony without the hat fighting it, and you still get warm ears. That's the feature you're buying. Everything else is built around winter.
Inside, it's Bluetooth 5.0 with a stated pairing range of roughly 33–65 feet, which is generous — you can leave your phone on a bench or in a bag and keep walking. Controls are on the hat itself: hands-free calls, volume, play/pause and track skipping. HIGHEVER says it charges in about 1.5–2 hours and gives up to 10 to 12 hours of continuous playtime with 200 hours of standby. That's a longer playtime figure than the Perytong band, and the 200-hour standby is the kind of spec that means you can leave it in a coat pocket for weeks and still have battery when you grab it.
On sound, HIGHEVER describes crisp, loud output that helps mask outside noise, with separate left and right channels and clean delivery for podcasts and audiobooks. Take that as a design claim rather than a measurement: it's a knit hat with embedded speakers, and it's tuned for walking, exercising and listening to spoken audio in cold weather. The brand positions it heavily as a gift — for women, moms, teen girls, as a stocking stuffer or Secret Santa idea.
Who should buy it: anyone who exercises outdoors in winter, dog walkers, hikers, skaters, snowboarders, commuters, and people who wear their hair up and are tired of choosing between a warm head and a ponytail. Who should skip it: anyone shopping for sleep audio, anyone who wants to wash their audio gear easily, and anyone who doesn't actually need a knit hat — because in warm weather this is just a hat you're not going to wear.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for sleeping and side-sleeping → Perytong Sleep Headphones. The ultra-thin speakers and centre-mounted control module are designed specifically so nothing presses on your ear.
• Best for the gym, yoga and jogging → Perytong Sleep Headphones. Breathable mesh lining, stretchy fit, and a washable band make it the more versatile workout pick.
• Best for wearing your hair up → HIGHEVER Ponytail Beanie. The ponytail opening is the single feature the Perytong band doesn't have.
• Best for battery life on paper → HIGHEVER Ponytail Beanie. Up to 10–12 hours of playtime and 200 hours of standby versus Perytong's 10-plus hours.
• Best for pairing range → HIGHEVER Ponytail Beanie. Bluetooth 5.0 with a stated 33–65 ft range; Perytong doesn't publish a range figure.
• Best for hands-free calls in a soft band → Perytong Sleep Headphones. Built-in microphone plus touch volume control, on Bluetooth 5.2.
• Best for gifting → HIGHEVER Ponytail Beanie. It's designed and marketed as a winter gift for women, moms and teen girls, with the ponytail cut as the talking point.
In my opinion, the decision comes down to one question: are you buying audio you can sleep in, or a hat you can listen through? If it's the first, I'd buy the Perytong Sleep Headphones — the thin speakers, the centre-mounted module, the washable band and the 2-in-1 sleep-mask angle make it the more useful object across more of the year. If your actual problem is cold ears and a ponytail, I'd buy the HIGHEVER Ponytail Beanie instead, because no sleep band solves that. Check the current price on Amazon for both before you commit.
Perytong, clearly. It's built as a sleep mask with ultra-thin speakers and a control module that sits in the middle of the band, so it's meant to be worn lying down. The HIGHEVER beanie is a winter hat; wearing a knit hat to bed isn't the use case it's designed for.
Does the HIGHEVER Ponytail Beanie have better battery life than the Perytong Sleep Headphones?
Yes — Perytong says the band is washable once you remove the speakers. That's a real advantage over the HIGHEVER beanie, which is a knit hat with electronics built in and isn't described as washable in the same way.
Neither is true noise cancelling in the sealed-headphone sense. Perytong uses the term, but the design is open-ear fabric, so it mainly keeps sound in rather than shutting the world out. HIGHEVER says its output is loud enough to mask background noise, and the knit fabric adds a little physical insulation. If blocking noise is your priority, treat both as partial solutions.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: FashionLive Music Hat Beanie vs MUSICOZY Sleep Headphones, Perytong Sleep Headphones vs Sinbana 2pcs, AEEKCARS 2 vs MUSICOZY Ice Silk Sleep: Bluetooth Headphones