Breaching Dragonstorm
Channel
Chatterstorm
Disciple of the Vault
Doomsday
Experimental Synthesizer
Fall from Favor
Glacial Chasm
Goblin Bushwhacker
Hopeless Nightmare
Kraark-Clan Shaman
Merchant Scroll
Monastery Swiftspear
Mystic Sanctuary
Narcomoeba
Sadistic Glee
Hello everyone! A few weeks after the French Championship, we are back with a new announcement regarding the Peasant banlist. The past few months have been particularly eventful for the format. Between rarity changes affecting several important cards, new sets, and the emergence of previously unseen strategies, the metagame continues to evolve rapidly. The French Championship gave us an opportunity to observe some of these developments on a larger scale, while also confirming several concerns we have had for some time. After discussions, reviewing results, and considering the overall balance of the format, we have decided to make the following changes
Bans
Breaching Dragonstorm is banned.
Monastery Swiftspear is banned
Unbans
No cards are unbanned.
Below, we explain the reasons behind these decisions and discuss several other cards considered by the Committee.
Before discussing the banlist changes, we would like to take a moment to thank Neral, who recently decided to leave the Peasant Committee after serving as a member since 2023. Over these three years, he made a significant contribution to the Committee's discussions and decisions, notably through his active participation in debates, extensive playtesting, and energy during our exchanges. His commitment, willingness to challenge ideas, and eagerness to explore different approaches have been invaluable in advancing our thinking and contributing to the positive development of the format. We would therefore like to thank him warmly for the time and energy he has devoted to Peasant, and wish him all the best at the tables and beyond
The French Cup took place in late October in Chalon-sur-Saône, bringing together numerous players for a weekend dedicated to Peasant. First of all, we would like to thank the organizers, volunteers, and all participants who helped make this event a success.
This edition was particularly interesting to observe. Despite a few pronounced trends, we saw considerable strategic diversity, with aggro, tempo, control, midrange, and combo decks all represented. Perhaps the biggest surprise in the archetype breakdown was the presence of Madness Burn, also known as Red Madness.
While some expected the deck to perform well, its share of the field exceeded the expectations of part of the community. Nevertheless, its strong presence did not prevent other archetypes from achieving good results. Various aggro, tempo, midrange, control, and combo strategies also found their place over the weekend.
The French Cup thus showcased a format that remains relatively diverse, but in which certain strategies are beginning to exert particularly significant pressure. And among them, one newcomer especially caught our attention.
The Emergence of Dragon Ball
One of the biggest surprises of this French Championship was the appearance of Dragon Ball, a combo deck developed and popularized in particular through MyWay's work. This archetype, previously almost absent from the competitive scene, quickly proved to be particularly effective. Beyond its results, it was above all the way the deck operates that raised several questions.
Unusual Resilience for a Combo Deck
Combo strategies generally have relatively identifiable weaknesses. Discard can disrupt their setup, counterspells can interrupt key spells, and land destruction can slow their development.
These different forms of interaction have traditionally been effective ways to fight this type of deck. Dragon Ball, however, has the unusual ability to withstand many of these answers. Its game plan, built in particular around high-value spells and cascade mechanics, allows it to advance its strategy while reducing the effectiveness of some interactions normally used against combo decks. 2 Discard does not guarantee that the deck can be disrupted for long, counterspells are not necessarily sufficient to answer all of its threats, and land-destruction strategies do not always slow it down effectively.
This ability to push through several forms of interaction is one of the archetype's main strengths.
An Excessively Polarized Metagame
The problem lies not only in the deck's power level, but also in how it shapes matchups. Dragon Ball has relatively few true predators and can make certain games particularly lopsided. Strategies without suitable answers may find themselves unable to interact effectively with its game plan, while certain highly specific hate cards can, conversely, severely undermine its ability to function. We believe that this degree of polarization is problematic for the overall balance of the format. We consider it important that different deck families have reasonable ways to interact with one another, without necessarily having to devote a disproportionate share of their deckbuilding to one particular strategy. Dragon Ball's ability to circumvent several traditional answers, combined with its power level and the small number of identified predators, now seems to go beyond what we want for the format.
We have therefore decided to ban Breaching Dragonstorm. This decision aims to reduce the excessive polarization caused by this archetype while preserving room for other combo strategies to continue existing and evolving
The case of Monastery Swiftspear is quite different. Unlike Dragon Ball, this is not a recently emerged strategy, but a card that has been part of the competitive Peasant landscape for many years. Its power level and influence on red strategies have regularly featured in our discussions.
Exceptional Efficiency for a Common One-Drop
For just one red mana, Monastery Swiftspear offers a particularly effective combination: haste, prowess, and the ability to pose an immediate and significant threat. The card can deal a considerable amount of damage very quickly while requiring relatively few resources to be effective. Prowess also allows it to exceed the usual stats of a one-mana creature and sometimes survive certain board wipes or removal spells that deal a fixed amount of damage. This versatility makes it a particularly difficult threat to answer efficiently in the opening turns.
A Card That Has Become Almost Automatic
Beyond its individual strength, what concerns us most is how easily it slots into red strategies. 3 Monastery Swiftspear naturally fits into a large proportion of aggressive red decks without requiring major deckbuilding concessions. Its inclusion has become almost systematic whenever a deck aims to pursue an aggressive strategy based on noncreature spells. This limits deckbuilding choices: when a card is so often the best available option at its mana cost, it becomes difficult to justify replacing it. Of course, we do not believe that a widely played card is necessarily problematic. However, in Monastery Swiftspear's case, this ubiquity comes with exceptionally high efficiency, even in situations where resources are limited.
A Long-Standing Influence on Red's Balance
Red strategies have regularly been the subject of discussions and interventions for several years. Some cards have been identified as problematic because of their interactions with particularly efficient creatures, including Monastery Swiftspear
For a long time, we preferred to address the elements surrounding these strategies in order to preserve, as much as possible, the cards forming their foundation. However, this approach now leads us to reconsider our position. After repeatedly trying to reduce the power of red decks by targeting their various synergies, it has become necessary to reassess the cards that form their common core. Monastery Swiftspear is precisely one of those cards. Its efficiency, versatility, and ability to strengthen very different strategies now seem excessive for a one-mana common creature. This is therefore not merely a response to Madness Burn's recent performances, but a broader decision about the balance of red strategies
We have therefore decided to ban Monastery Swiftspear. Our goal is not to eliminate red decks from the format, but to allow them to evolve toward more distinct builds without systematically relying on the same exceptionally efficient creature.
As in our previous announcements, we examined several other cards but did not consider action necessary at this time.
In our previous announcement, we decided to unban Force of Will, a decision that sparked considerable discussion within the community. Three months after its return, we wanted to gather players' opinions directly through a community survey, to better understand their feelings, potential concerns, and perceptions of the card's impact on the format. 4 A total of 53 players participated, with the following results:
39,6 % want Force of Will to remain legal (21 players).
34 % want it banned again (18 players)
26,4 % prefer not to take a position or feel they need more information (14 players).
These results show a relatively divided community. Although keeping the card legal is the most popular position, no option commands an absolute majority, and more than a quarter of respondents are not yet ready to take a position.
The comments also helped us better identify the main concerns. Among those in favor of banning it again, financial accessibility is the main point of contention. Force of Will's particularly high price represents a real barrier for some players, especially when they want to build what they consider the optimal version of their deck. Others point to its inherent power, its ability to interact without spending mana, and the frustration this mechanic can create during games. Conversely, players in favor of keeping it legal emphasize the card disadvantage it entails, the intense competition for uncommon slots, and its value in answering certain particularly explosive strategies.
We also wanted to compare this feedback with the first competitive data available since its unbanning. An analysis of 14 successful decklists running Force of Will shows fairly varied usage, with an average of 2.36 copies per deck. Only two of these lists run four copies. Force of Will is therefore clearly present in the competitive metagame and is not systematically played as a four-of; its inclusion also does not appear to come systematically at the expense of other available uncommons.
The data collected so far neither demonstrate that Force of Will is unbalancing the metagame nor rule out the possibility that it gives certain strategies an excessive advantage. More thorough observation is therefore necessary. We are nevertheless aware that three months is a relatively short observation period, and that certain concerns, particularly regarding its financial accessibility, remain entirely legitimate. We have therefore decided to keep Force of Will legal while continuing to monitor it closely
We would like to thank all players who took the time to answer the survey and share their arguments, whether for or against keeping the card legal. For those who would like to explore the subject further, a detailed survey report, together with an analysis of the initial competitive data, is available as an attachment. The survey findings can be found here
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1FHKyaFTEFeyu1JWuyAhvbad-QJXciQJZ/view?usp=sharing
Sneaky Snacker was also among the cards discussed. Its ability to return repeatedly from the graveyard makes it a valuable resource, particularly in longer games. Its synergies with cards such as Grab the Prize give certain strategies a welcome second wind without necessarily requiring a major investment of resources
Nevertheless, we do not currently consider this recursion problematic enough to justify action. The format has numerous answers that can limit its effectiveness. Graveyard hate remains accessible, board wipes can keep creature boards under control, and several commonly played creatures can block Sneaky Snacker effectively
Furthermore, the results of strategies using Sneaky Snacker do not appear to demonstrate any particular dominance. The card provides an interesting form of resilience, but that quality alone is not enough to make it problematic. We therefore do not plan to ban Sneaky Snacker at this time
Fiery Inscription naturally came up in our discussions about Madness Burn. The card is a particularly effective source of damage and contributes significantly to the deck's ability to close out games without necessarily relying on combat. It also contributes to Madness Burn's distinct identity in Peasant. We want to preserve this characteristic, which allows the archetype to offer a game plan different from that of certain red strategies found in Pauper
More broadly, we want to avoid excessively reducing the role of competitive enchantments in the format. There are relatively few enchantments that are truly viable at a high level, and their presence helps diversify the threats players must be prepared to answer. This obviously does not mean that these cards should be protected regardless of their power level.
However, in Fiery Inscription's case, we believe it is preferable to observe the consequences of banning Monastery Swiftspear before considering further action. Swiftspear's departure should notably change the speed and early pressure of the red strategies that used it, which could help rebalance Madness Burn.
Fiery Inscription therefore remains legal in the format. We will nevertheless continue to monitor the archetype's performance over the coming months.
Doomsday has also been the subject of renewed discussion within the Committee. Recently downshifted to uncommon in the Zeta Set, the card was preemptively banned to prevent the emergence of a potentially problematic combo strategy before we had sufficient insight into its impact on the format.
We nevertheless indicated that this ban could be reassessed in the future. To date, no decklist using Doomsday appears to have demonstrated an obviously excessive power level. This is, of course, an argument in favor of a possible unban.
However, the recent emergence of Dragon Ball and the issues raised by Breaching Dragonstorm encourage us to remain cautious. This example showed that a new build could emerge rapidly and exploit a previously little-played card to create a particularly powerful strategy that is difficult to contain.
Doomsday offers considerable deckbuilding potential, and we are not yet sufficiently convinced that the interactions and constraints specific to Peasant would effectively contain the strongest strategies that might exploit it. We have therefore decided to keep Doomsday on the banlist for now. This does not mean we necessarily consider the card too powerful for the format; rather, we are choosing caution in an environment that is still evolving rapidly. 7 We will continue to reassess this decision as the metagame stabilizes and new information allows us to better evaluate its potential.
We also discussed the possibility of reintroducing certain cards currently on the banlist. However, we ultimately decided not to unban any cards in this announcement. The Peasant metagame is currently undergoing a period of significant change.
Recent rarity changes affecting cards such as Baleful Strix, Price of Progress, Vandalblast, and Dispatch have opened up new deckbuilding possibilities and altered the balance of power between several archetypes. Some of these developments are still relatively recent, and we do not necessarily have enough hindsight to measure all their consequences. New sets are another factor, regularly introducing cards that may change how existing strategies operate or enable entirely new decks to emerge.
The recent emergence of Dragon Ball illustrates just how quickly the format can evolve, sometimes in ways that are difficult to anticipate. In this context, we believe it is preferable not to make too many changes at once. The two bans announced today should already have consequences for the competitive environment. We therefore want to give the metagame time to adapt and observe the resulting new dynamics before considering further changes. No unbans are planned for the time being.
These two bans should change several aspects of the current metagame. The removal of Breaching Dragonstorm should notably reduce the pressure exerted by Dragon Ball and allow certain strategies to return to less polarized matchups.
For its part, the ban of Monastery Swiftspear could significantly change red deck construction. Madness Burn, Red Assault, Kuldotha, and other aggressive strategies will probably need to revisit parts of their builds. It will be interesting to observe how players adapt, as well as the new possibilities that may emerge from these changes. We will also continue to monitor the cards discussed above, particularly Force of Will, Sneaky Snacker, and Fiery Inscription.
As always, future decisions will depend on observed results, developments in the format, and the various information available to us. Our goal remains to preserve a diverse competitive environment in which different strategies can coexist and where deckbuilding decisions and in-game interaction continue to matter.
Once again, we would like to thank everyone who helps keep Peasant thriving. Special thanks go to the organizers, volunteers, and participants of the French Cup, which remains one of the major events for our community.
We would also like to highlight the growth of local initiatives that keep the format active throughout the year. The communities of Thionville, Saint-Nazaire, and Groningen continue to organize tournaments regularly, while Chalon-sur-Saône is gradually resuming its activities.
These initiatives are essential to Peasant's vitality. They bring players together, introduce new people to the format, and sustain competitive activity beyond the major annual events.
We are pleased to see these communities remain committed and hope that more initiatives of this kind will emerge. We also thank online tournament organizers and all players whose participation and experimentation help the format evolve. We hope these changes will refresh certain deck builds, encourage new experimentation, and help Peasant continue to develop.
Until then, we wish you great games and plenty of enjoyment around the tables!
See you soon,
Le Comité Peasant