How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a true wireless gaming headset tuned for Xbox One with two sound modes and a boom mic built for in-game chat, choose PDP Xbox One Afterglow; if you need an all-day noise-cancelling headset for work calls, music and commuting, choose Avantree Aria 90B. These two look similar on a shelf — both are black over-ear wireless headsets — but they are built for completely different jobs, and picking the wrong one means living with the wrong set of compromises for years.
• PDP Xbox One Afterglow — biggest strength: 50 mm Neodymium drivers with two switchable audio modes (Pure Audio and Bass Boost) and a removable noise-cancelling boom mic — a package designed around Xbox One gaming.
• PDP Xbox One Afterglow — biggest trade-off: Battery life is listed at up to 16 hours, but the spec sheet's average battery life field reads 5 hours, so real-world runtime between charges is the weak point. No 3.5 mm jack means no wired fallback.
• Avantree Aria 90B — biggest strength: Active Noise Cancellation plus up to 35 hours per charge at 60% volume, a detachable extended mic with a mute switch, and a USB adapter that skips Bluetooth pairing entirely on a PC.
• Avantree Aria 90B — biggest trade-off: It's a general-purpose headset, not a gaming one — no game-tuned audio modes, and at 230 g it's light but not purpose-built for marathon controller sessions.
• Who each pick is for: Choose the PDP Afterglow if you game on Xbox One and want chat and bass-heavy audio in one wireless headset. Choose the Avantree Aria 90B if you split your day between work calls, music and travel.
The Afterglow AG 9+ is a gaming-first design, and everything in the spec sheet points that way. The 50 mm Neodymium dynamic drivers cover a 20 Hz–20,000 Hz range, and the two audio modes matter more than they sound: Pure Audio keeps dialogue and footsteps clean, while Bass Boost adds weight to explosions and soundtracks. If you play shooters where audio cues decide fights, that toggle is the feature you'll actually use.
Where it gives ground is flexibility. There's no headphone jack, so once the battery is done you're done — no cable rescue. The spec sheet lists a 2-hour charge time and an average battery life of 5 hours, with marketing copy promising up to 16; treat the higher number as a best case and plan on charging often. It's also an Xbox One headset first: the wireless transmitter setup is aimed at that console, not at your laptop. Buy it if your priority is game audio and party chat on Xbox One. Skip it if you need one headset for work calls, flights and music — the Afterglow isn't trying to be that.
Avantree Aria 90B: Who It's For
The Aria 90B is the opposite kind of product: a work-and-travel headset that happens to be comfortable enough to wear all day. The headline feature is Active Noise Cancellation, which the spec sheet says reduces low-frequency ambient noise — airplane engines, subway rumble, city traffic — by up to 90%, and it works in both wired and wireless modes. If you've ever tried to take a call next to a running appliance, that's the difference ANC makes.
Battery is the second pillar. Avantree rates it at up to 35 hours per charge at 60% volume, which is a genuinely different class of runtime from the Afterglow. The 230 g weight and replaceable memory foam earpads back that up — this is a headset designed for long stretches, whether that's a full workday of meetings or a weekend of binge-watching.
Connectivity is where the Aria 90B earns its keep for remote workers. It ships with a USB adapter that's already paired to the headphones, so on a PC you plug the dongle into a USB port, power on, and you're connected — no Bluetooth menus, no driver wrestling. It's listed as working with Windows, Mac and Chromebook, and with Zoom, Skype for Business, Microsoft Teams and Google Meet. Bluetooth 5.0 handles the wireless side with a stated range of up to 30 meters (roughly 33 ft), and there's a 3.5 mm AUX port plus Type C charging if you want a wired option. The detachable extended mic sits near your mouth, which is why it picks up your voice clearly and rejects background noise, and it has a built-in mute switch you can hit without touching your phone.
The trade-off: it isn't a gaming headset. There are no game-tuned audio modes, no console licensing, and the styling is understated office gear rather than living-room showpiece. Buy it if you're on calls, commuting or listening to music for hours. Skip it if your main use is Xbox One party chat and you want bass-boosted game audio.
• Best for Xbox One gaming → PDP Xbox One Afterglow. It's officially licensed for Xbox One and pairs via its own USB transmitter.
• Best for battery life → Avantree Aria 90B. Up to 35 hours per charge versus the Afterglow's listed 5-hour average (16-hour best case).
• Best for work calls and video meetings → Avantree Aria 90B. Plug-and-go USB adapter, extended mic with mute switch, and listed support for Zoom, Teams, Skype and Google Meet.
• Best for game audio tuning → PDP Xbox One Afterglow. Two modes, Pure Audio and Bass Boost, driven by 50 mm drivers.
• Best for travel and commuting → Avantree Aria 90B. Active Noise Cancellation cuts low-frequency engine and traffic noise by up to 90%.
• Best for wired fallback → Avantree Aria 90B. It has a 3.5 mm AUX port; the Afterglow has no headphone jack at all.
• Best for long-wear comfort → Avantree Aria 90B. 230 g with replaceable memory foam earpads, built for all-day sessions.
• Best for mic flexibility while gaming → PDP Xbox One Afterglow. The noise-cancelling boom mic is removable and flexible for personalized placement.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the Avantree Aria 90B — because it covers more of real life. Noise cancellation, up to 35 hours of battery, a plug-and-go PC adapter and a mute-switch mic make it useful for work, travel and music, and the 3.5 mm port means it never becomes a paperweight. The PDP Afterglow is the better gaming headset and I'd recommend it without hesitation if Xbox One chat and bass-heavy audio are your only priorities — but its short average battery life and lack of a wired fallback make it a one-job tool. For most people reading this comparison, the Aria 90B is the safer, more versatile buy. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
The PDP Afterglow. It's officially licensed for Xbox One, ships with a USB transmitter for wireless pairing, and offers game-focused Pure Audio and Bass Boost modes. The Aria 90B is a general Bluetooth headset aimed at PCs and phones.
Avantree rates the Aria 90B at up to 35 hours per charge at 60% volume. The PDP Afterglow is listed with up to 16 hours in its marketing copy but a 5-hour average battery life field, with a 2-hour charge time — so plan on charging it far more often.
Yes. It ships with a pre-paired USB adapter, so you plug it into your PC's USB port and it's ready — no Bluetooth pairing steps. The detachable extended mic sits near your mouth and has a built-in mute switch.
The Avantree Aria 90B. It has Active Noise Cancellation that reduces low-frequency ambient noise by up to 90% and works in both wired and wireless modes. The PDP Afterglow's spec sheet lists no noise control feature — its noise handling is limited to the microphone.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.