We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a long-lasting supply of rectangular liners cut specifically for dual-basket air fryers, choose onluckdeer 250pcs; if you need square liners sized for Cuisinart-style single-basket fryers in the 4.5–6 qt range, choose TCSNOE 125PCs. That's the short version. The longer version comes down to three things: shape, fit and how many sheets you're getting.
• onluckdeer 250pcs biggest strength: 250 rectangular sheets at 8.1" x 5.5", measured for dual-basket fryers in the 6–10 qt range — a very deep supply for daily cooking.
• onluckdeer 250pcs biggest trade-off: The rectangle is the point, and also the limit. In a round or square single-basket fryer, the shape won't line up as cleanly.
• TCSNOE 125PCs biggest strength: 7.9" x 7.9" square sheets that cover a Cuisinart-style basket corner to corner, with a stated heat tolerance of 450°F.
• TCSNOE 125PCs biggest trade-off: Half the sheet count, and the square format is aimed at specific 4.5 qt and 6 qt baskets rather than two-compartment models.
• Pick onluckdeer 250pcs if you cook in a dual-basket air fryer and want two liners per session without thinking about restocking.
• Pick TCSNOE 125PCs if you own a Cuisinart AIR-200NAS or AIR-160NAS and want one square liner per basket, every time.
This is a liner designed around a very specific piece of hardware: the dual-basket air fryer. Each sheet measures 8.1" x 5.5", a rectangle, not a square. That's not an accident — it matches the long, narrow compartments of two-drawer fryers rather than a single round pot. If you own a dual-basket model in the 6–10 qt class, the shape simply drops in and covers the floor of each drawer.
The material is unbleached parchment paper, food-grade, with a stated heat resistance up to 446°F. It's non-stick and oil-proof, which matters more than it sounds. Air frying is essentially high-speed convection with a little oil, and that oil plus breading plus heat is what turns a basket floor into a scrubbing project. A liner catches the grease, the crumbs and the residue so the basket stays clean underneath. That's the whole value proposition: remove and discard, no soaking.
Then there's the count. 250 sheets. If you use two per cook — one per basket — that's 125 cooking sessions. Even cooking twice a day, that's roughly two months of liners from a single pack. In my opinion that's the real selling point here, more than any single spec: you stop thinking about liners for a long while.
Who should skip it? Anyone with a single-basket round fryer, or a small 2–4 qt model. The rectangle won't match the basket geometry, and you'd be cutting or folding to compensate — which defeats the purpose of a pre-cut sheet. Also skip it if you rarely use your air fryer; 250 sheets is a lot of shelf space to commit to.
TCSNOE takes the opposite approach: one shape, fitted to one family of machines. These are 7.9" x 7.9" squares, and the manufacturer states they're designed to be compatible with the Cuisinart AIR-200NAS 6-quart basket fryer and the AIR-160NAS 4.5-quart basket fryer. Square basket, square liner, full coverage. No folding, no trimming, no gaps at the corners where grease sneaks past.
The paper is unbleached, BPA-free and food-safe for direct contact, rated to 450°F — essentially the same performance envelope as the onluckdeer sheets, just two degrees higher on paper. It's non-stick and oil-proof, containing grease, crumbs and sauces so the basket underneath stays clean. Same cleanup story: place, cook, toss.
One thing I appreciate about this listing: it actually explains the safe way to use a liner. Preheat the air fryer with the basket empty, then place the liner flat in the basket afterward, and add enough food to weigh the paper down. That's a genuinely useful instruction, because a lightweight sheet that isn't held down can lift into the heating element. Not every liner brand bothers to spell that out.
The versatility claim is also broader than the fit claim. TCSNOE says these work in the microwave, steamer and oven too — so if you want one box that covers more than just the air fryer, that's a point in its favor. The trade-off is the count: 125 sheets, and if you're cooking for two baskets you'd need two sheets per session, halving that.
Skip this one if you own a dual-basket fryer. The 7.9" square is built for a single square basket, and it won't map onto two narrow drawers. Also skip it if you don't own a Cuisinart AIR-200NAS or AIR-160NAS and your basket is a different size — a square liner that doesn't match the basket footprint leaves exposed corners.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for dual-basket air fryers → onluckdeer 250pcs. The 8.1" x 5.5" rectangle is cut for two-compartment drawers.
• Best for sheer supply → onluckdeer 250pcs. 250 sheets versus 125 — double the liners, double the cooking sessions before restocking.
• Best for full corner-to-corner coverage in a square basket → TCSNOE 125PCs. A square liner in a square basket leaves no exposed floor.
• Best for multi-appliance use → TCSNOE 125PCs. It's stated for air fryer, microwave, steamer and oven; onluckdeer's material is described for air fryer use.
• Best heat tolerance on paper → effectively a tie. 446°F for onluckdeer, 450°F for TCSNOE. Both sit well above typical air fryer cooking temperatures.
• Best for someone who hates scrubbing a basket → either. Both are non-stick, oil-proof, disposable sheets with the same remove-and-toss workflow.
• Best for occasional users → TCSNOE 125PCs. If you air fry once a week, 125 sheets is already a long runway; 250 may be more than you'll use before the paper ages.
If I were buying for myself, I'd pick based on the basket sitting on my counter, not on the sheet count. Owning a dual-basket fryer, I'd buy onluckdeer 250pcs — the rectangle fits the drawers without folding, and 250 sheets means I'm not reordering for months. If I owned a Cuisinart AIR-200NAS or AIR-160NAS, I'd buy TCSNOE 125PCs without hesitation, because a square liner in a square basket is simply less fiddling. Match the shape to your basket first. Everything else is secondary.
FAQ
how to use air fryer parchment paper
Preheat the air fryer first, with nothing in the basket. Once preheating finishes, place the liner flat on the bottom of the basket, then add food on top so the paper is weighed down and can't lift toward the heating element. Cook as normal, then remove and discard the liner.
how to use air fryer parchment paper liners
how to make air fryer parchment paper
You don't have to make anything — both products are pre-cut sheets. onluckdeer gives you 250 rectangles at 8.1" x 5.5"; TCSNOE gives you 125 squares at 7.9" x 7.9". If you already own a roll, you'd cut to your basket's footprint, but a pre-cut sheet removes that step entirely.
how to air fryer without parchment paper
Just cook directly in the basket. You lose the non-stick barrier, so greasy or breaded foods will leave more residue and you'll be scrubbing and soaking more often. Parchment liners exist to skip that cleanup — they're a convenience, not a requirement.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: TCSNOE 125PCs vs VinaBina 12x16: Air Fryer Parchment Paper, Glad Air Fryer Liners vs TCSNOE 125PCS: Air Fryer Parchment, TCSNOE Air Fryer Paper vs Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Round