How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a plug-and-play wired headset that works across PC, PS4, PS5 and Switch and also holds its own for music production, choose ONITOON Lightweight Gaming Headset; if you need a desk stand that stores your headset, controller and small accessories in one tidy spot, choose MyGift Industrial Matte Black. These two products sit in completely different categories, so the honest answer is that they solve different problems — one is audio gear you wear, the other is furniture you set on a desk. Read on and you'll know exactly which one belongs in your setup.
• ONITOON Lightweight Gaming Headset — biggest strength: a genuine wired gaming headset with 50mm dynamic drivers, an adjustable omnidirectional mic, a 3.5mm jack and multi-platform compatibility, plus detachable pink cat ears and gradient RGB lighting that needs USB power.
• ONITOON Lightweight Gaming Headset — biggest trade-off: the RGB lighting only works when you plug the USB cable into a powered USB port, and the mic does not work when connected to Switch-series consoles.
• MyGift Industrial Matte Black — biggest strength: a matte black metal frame with a burnt wood base and a built-in tray, with three prongs shaped to hold both a headset and a gaming controller.
• MyGift Industrial Matte Black — biggest trade-off: it produces no sound at all. It's a storage and display accessory, not a headset, so it can't replace audio gear in any way.
• Who each pick is for: the ONITOON if you actually need to hear and talk to people; the MyGift if you already own a headset and want your desk to stop looking like a cable explosion.
This is a wired over-ear headset built around a 50mm dynamic driver with a 32 ohm impedance, a 20Hz–20KHz frequency range and 105dB sensitivity. In plain terms, that's an easy-to-drive spec sheet — it doesn't need a dedicated amplifier to get loud, which matters if you're plugging straight into a controller, a laptop or a phone with a 3.5mm jack. The enclosure is plastic with a pink cat-ear theme and round gel ear cups wrapped in protein leather. The aluminium frame is described as flexible, and the headband is adjustable, so it's meant to fit a range of head shapes rather than one.
Who should buy it: someone who wants one wired headset that hops between PC, laptop, PS4, PS5, Switch, tablet or phone, wants a mic they can bend into position, and likes the cat-ear aesthetic. It's also a reasonable pick if you're doing music production on a budget and want an inexpensive wired monitoring option with a wide-ish frequency range — though for serious production you'd want to treat it as a starting point, not a reference monitor. Who should skip it: anyone who needs wireless freedom, anyone who needs RGB lighting to work on a PS5 without extra power, and anyone who wants a neutral, understated look rather than pink cat ears.
MyGift Industrial Matte Black: Who It's For
Let's be blunt: this is not a headset. It's a desktop headphone stand with a controller holder, made from matte black metal with a burnt wood tray base. The overall footprint is roughly 5.9 x 5.9 x 10.4 inches, each of the three prongs is about 2.0 x 1.6 inches, and the base is about 1 inch high with a 5.9-inch diameter. Item weight is 1.8 pounds, so it's substantial enough to sit still when you drop a headset onto it.
The design is the selling point. Three prongs let you hang both a headset and a gaming controller, and the solid wood tray underneath gives you somewhere to drop cables, earbuds or a USB drive. If you've ever had a controller sliding around under your monitor while your headset balances on the edge of a speaker, this is the fix. The burnt wood and matte black finish is styled for industrial, farmhouse or modern office setups, so it also reads as decor rather than pure utility.
Who should buy it: console and PC players who want their headset and controller off the desk surface, streamers and studio users who need small accessories corralled, or anyone who cares about how their setup looks on camera. Who should skip it: anyone shopping for actual audio. If you don't already own a headset, this purchase solves nothing about sound — it's the shelf, not the stereo.
• Best for actually hearing game audio → ONITOON Lightweight Gaming Headset. 50mm drivers, stereo surround positioning, 20Hz–20KHz range.
• Best for voice chat → ONITOON Lightweight Gaming Headset. Adjustable omnidirectional mic, though it doesn't work on Switch-series consoles.
• Best for multi-platform use → ONITOON Lightweight Gaming Headset. PC, laptop, desktop, PS4, PS5, Switch, tablets and phones via 3.5mm.
• Best for desk organisation → MyGift Industrial Matte Black. Three prongs for a headset and controller plus a tray for cables, earbuds and USB drives.
• Best for a tidy, styled setup → MyGift Industrial Matte Black. Matte black metal and burnt wood in a compact 5.9 x 5.9 x 10.4-inch footprint.
• Best if you want RGB lighting → ONITOON Lightweight Gaming Headset, with the caveat that the lights need USB power and won't be driven by the PS5 controller.
• Best for long sessions → ONITOON Lightweight Gaming Headset on comfort grounds: gel ear cups reduce heat build-up, protein leather padding, adjustable headband, and a light 268g weight.
• Best for music production on a tight setup → honestly, both, but in different roles. The ONITOON gives you a wired 3.5mm listening option; the MyGift gives you a clean place to park it between takes.
In my opinion, these aren't rivals — they're complements, and if you can only pick one, pick based on the hole in your setup. If you need to hear audio and talk to teammates, I'd buy the ONITOON Lightweight Gaming Headset. It's the only one of the two that makes sound, it runs off a standard 3.5mm jack across PC, PS4, PS5 and Switch, and the 50mm drivers and 268g build make it a sensible entry point for gaming and casual music production alike. I'd only choose the MyGift Industrial Matte Black if I already had a headset I liked and my real problem was clutter — because as a stand with a controller holder and a storage tray, it does that job well, but it will never play a note.
FAQ
No, but it helps. The ONITOON is a wired over-ear headset with a 3.5mm cable, so it can rest anywhere — the MyGift stand simply gives it a dedicated hook plus a tray for the cable, which keeps a desk setup tidier.
Not through the console alone. The RGB lighting requires USB power, and the PS5 transmits audio through the controller rather than powering accessories, so the lights may not come on unless you plug the USB connector into a powered port.
For production you need to hear audio, so the ONITOON is the relevant pick — it's wired, 32 ohm, 50mm dynamic drivers, 20Hz–20KHz. The MyGift is a metal and wood stand with a storage tray and no audio function at all, so it can only hold your gear, not reproduce sound.
• STECEi AI Translation Earbuds vs L LTGEM Headphone Headset Case
• Apogee Groove AE USB-C vs Behringer P16-HQ
• MUSICOZY Sleep Headphones vs WolfLawS Gaming Headset
• WASRUYI Lightning vs VBANU Replacement Charging Cable
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.