How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Norpro Air Fryer Parchment — biggest strength: 100 disposable, food-grade parchment sheets sized for 3–6.5QT air fryers and rated heat resistant to 430°F/220°C. Biggest trade-off: it's single-use, so you go through the stack and repurchase.
• Generic Second — biggest strength: reusable food-grade silicone tray rated to 464°F/240°C with raised lines designed to improve heat circulation. Biggest trade-off: it's one item you wash and store, and the data sheet lists only one color and no confirmed size consistency.
• Who Norpro is for: anyone who hates scrubbing the basket after flatbread, pizza, or greasy fried food.
• Who Generic Second is for: anyone who wants a reusable tray that also works as a cake or fruit tray and can go in the dishwasher.
The Norpro liner is a square parchment sheet with a top measurement of 8.5″ x 8.5″ (21.5cm), a bottom of 6.25″ (16cm), a height of 1.75″ (4.5cm), and a laid-flat length of 9.75″ (25cm). The tapered shape is the point: it sits in the basket like a shallow paper bowl, so crumbs, oil, and cheese drips land on the paper instead of the basket floor. You get 100 pieces per pack, and each one is disposable, bio-degradable, oil resistant, waterproof, FDA/LFGB food grade, and kosher. Rated heat resistance is 430°F/220°C.
That shape matters most for flatbread. A flatbread, a flatbread pizza, or a piece of fried chicken tends to leak oil and stick. With Norpro, you lift the paper out and the basket is essentially clean. It's also not air-fryer-only — the data sheet lists it for multi-cookers, ovens, microwaves, and steamers, so the same sheet works for oven-baked flatbread when you want it. Since the top is wider than the bottom, the paper folds upward and holds small bits like sesame seeds or herbs.
Who should buy it: anyone with a 3–6.5QT air fryer who air fries flatbread, pizza, or sticky glazed food regularly and wants the cleanup to take seconds. Who should skip it: anyone trying to cut single-use paper waste, anyone with a basket outside that 3–6.5QT range, and anyone who wants a tray that survives hundreds of uses. Also note the safety guidance in the data sheet — don't put a liner in while preheating, make sure enough food covers the paper, don't use it near an open flame or close to the heating element, and don't leave the air fryer unattended.
Generic Second is a reusable silicone baking tray, square and foldable, measuring 11.8″L x 7.9″W (11.81″ x 7.87″). The material is food-grade silicone, rated from hot to cold up to 464°F (240°C), which means it also handles cold environments — so it can double as a fruit tray or a cake tray. The color listed is Beige. It ships as one piece.
The design detail that matters is the raised lines. The data sheet describes many raised lines on the pad that are meant to improve heat circulation and heat food evenly while keeping it intact. In practice, that's the difference between a liner and a tray: a flatbread sitting on raised ridges gets hot air moving under it, which helps the underside crisp instead of steaming. It's also described as dishwasher safe, so cleanup is a machine job rather than a hand-scrub. Aside from flatbread and pizza, the sheet lists fried chicken, daily home baking, and barbecue.
Who should buy it: anyone who wants one tray they reuse, who air fries or bakes flatbread and wants better airflow underneath it, and who prefers dishwasher cleanup. Who should skip it: anyone who wants zero washing, anyone who wants exact size certainty (the data sheet notes manual-measurement error and possible display color differences), and anyone who wants volume — this is one tray, not a stack.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for zero-scrub cleanup → Norpro Air Fryer Parchment. Lift it out, bin it, done. Nothing to wash.
• Best for reuse → Generic Second. One silicone tray you wash and use again, dishwasher safe.
• Best for heat circulation under flatbread → Generic Second. The raised lines are designed to let hot air move under the food.
• Best for higher heat ceiling → Generic Second, at 464°F/240°C versus Norpro's 430°F/220°C.
• Best for multi-appliance flexibility → Norpro Air Fryer Parchment, listed for air fryers, multi-cookers, ovens, microwaves, and steamers.
• Best for cold use and non-baking uses → Generic Second, which the sheet says can also serve as a cake or fruit tray.
• Best for buying once and not restocking → Generic Second; best for buying once and never washing → Norpro Air Fryer Parchment (100 sheets).
In my opinion, I'd buy Norpro Air Fryer Parchment if my main job is air frying flatbread, flatbread pizza, and fried chicken and my least favorite part is washing the basket — 100 disposable, food-grade sheets that lift out is a genuinely easy routine. I'd buy Generic Second instead if I want one reusable, dishwasher-safe tray and I care about airflow under the food, since the raised lines are designed for exactly that. If you're unsure which trade-off you'd rather live with, check the current price on Amazon for both and let that break the tie.
how to air fry flatbread
Put the flatbread in the basket in a single layer and don't overcrowd it. With Norpro, line the basket first and make sure enough food covers the paper. With Generic Second, set the flatbread on the raised lines so air can move underneath. Either way, don't leave the air fryer unattended.
how to air fry flatbread pizza
Treat it like a small pizza: flatbread as the base, toppings on top, and don't overload it or the center stays soft. Norpro's sheet catches the cheese and oil drips, which is the whole reason to use it. Generic Second's raised lines are designed to heat the base more evenly. Keep the food covered over the liner.
how long to air fry flatbread
The data sheets don't give cook times, so go by doneness rather than a fixed number and check early the first time. A thin flatbread usually needs only a few minutes, so start short and add time. Watch it — the guidance is not to leave your air fryer unattended.
how long to air fry flatbread pizza
Again, no time is specified in the data, so judge by how the cheese and edges look. Because toppings add moisture, a flatbread pizza generally wants a little longer than a plain flatbread. Check it as it cooks rather than setting a timer and walking away.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Webake Air Fryer Mini vs Generic Stainless Steel Stackable, DNSSY Air Fryer Parchment vs Syntus 30, Beasea Air Fryer Round vs katbite Parchment Paper Rounds