How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a traditional metal muffin pan you can use in a toaster oven, a conventional oven and under the broiler, choose Nordic Ware Naturals Compact Muffin; if you need flexible silicone molds built specifically to drop into an air fryer basket, choose Giyochie 2. Those two sentences really do sum it up. One is a small aluminum pan that behaves like classic bakeware. The other is a pair of soft, non-stick silicone trays designed around the air fryer. If your goal is air fryer English muffin projects — egg bites, mini quiches, muffin-style breakfast rounds — the Giyochie set is the more natural fit. If you want a single durable pan that also handles conventional baking, soufflés and broiled items, Nordic Ware wins.
• Nordic Ware's biggest strength: natural uncoated aluminum that is toaster oven, conventional oven and broiler safe, in a compact 10 x 7 x 1.3 inch footprint.
• Nordic Ware's biggest trade-off: it's metal, not flexible, so it doesn't conform to an air fryer basket, and dishwasher use is not advised because detergent can discolor the aluminum.
• Giyochie 2's biggest strength: two flexible 7-cup silicone molds sized for roughly 3.5–5.8 L air fryers, with a naturally non-stick surface that releases with a finger press.
• Giyochie 2's biggest trade-off: silicone is soft, so it relies on being filled with batter to hold its shape, and it's not a broiler-safe metal pan.
• Choose Nordic Ware if you want one durable, oven-and-broiler-capable pan for muffins, quiches and soufflés.
• Choose Giyochie 2 if you want dedicated air fryer molds for egg bites, mini cakes and English muffin-style rounds.
This is a small, honest piece of bakeware. Six cavities, each 2.7 inches across the top and 2 inches at the base, with a total pan capacity of 2 cups. The exterior measures 10 inches long, 7 inches wide and 1.3 inches tall. That's a footprint that slides into a toaster oven without hogging the whole rack, which is the entire point of the "compact" label. It's also the kind of size that stores easily in a small kitchen where a full-size 12-cup pan feels like overkill.
What it does best is versatility. Nordic Ware builds it from natural, PFOA-free aluminum, and it's rated for the toaster oven, the conventional oven and the broiler. That last one matters — you can finish a quiche or a savory muffin under direct heat without worrying about melting a soft mold. Six cavities is also a genuinely useful number for single servings: individual soufflés, mini quiches, egg bites, small savory bakes. The brand backs it with a 5-year warranty and describes the aluminum as made to withstand a lifetime of home kitchen use, which is a reasonable signal of how it's meant to hold up.
Who should skip it? Anyone whose primary tool is an air fryer with a round basket. A rigid rectangular metal pan doesn't flex to the basket shape, and the cavities are fixed. Also skip it if you want zero fuss about washing — dishwasher use isn't advised here, because automatic dishwasher detergent can discolor the aluminum. That discoloration is described as cosmetic and not a threat to baking performance or safety, but if spotless shiny metal matters to you, hand washing is the routine. One more real trade-off: aluminum reacts to acidic ingredients like vinegar and tomato products, which can darken, pit or corrode the pan over prolonged use. So tomato-heavy bakes are better in a different pan.
This one is built for a very specific job: baking inside an air fryer. You get two black silicone molds, each with 7 cups, in a round shape. The size in the data sheet is the 21 cm / 8 inch version, described as generally suitable for 3.5–5.8 L air fryers. Note that the same product line also offers an 18 cm / 7 inch option aimed at roughly 3.2–5.8 L air fryers — so if you're shopping, match the mold size to your basket before you commit. Each mold is 7 cups, and there are two of them, which means you can bake a batch and have a second tray ready to go.
The material is the whole story here. Soft silicone that, in the brand's own framing, becomes more stable once it's full of batter. That's the honest trade-off of silicone bakeware: empty, it flops; filled, it holds. In exchange you get a naturally non-stick surface that releases muffins and egg bites with a finger press, without wrecking their shape. It's flexible, reusable and washable, and it's rated safe for the air fryer, toaster oven, steamer, microwave and freezer. That's a wide temperature-tool range for one inexpensive-feeling accessory, and it's why these molds work for frozen treats and chocolate or candy making just as well as for muffins and cupcake-style bakes.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for air fryer English muffin projects → Giyochie 2. Round silicone molds sized for 3.5–5.8 L baskets are the natural home for egg bites, muffin rounds and mini quiche.
• Best for toaster oven baking → Nordic Ware Naturals Compact Muffin. The 10 x 7 x 1.3 inch pan is explicitly built for toaster ovens.
• Best for broiler finishing → Nordic Ware Naturals Compact Muffin. It's rated broiler safe; the silicone molds are not.
• Best for easy release → Giyochie 2. Naturally non-stick, pops out with a finger press.
• Best for batch flexibility → Giyochie 2. Two 7-cup molds let you bake in two rounds, or use one while the other is in the wash.
• Best for durability and structure → Nordic Ware Naturals Compact Muffin. Natural aluminum, 5-year warranty, made to withstand a lifetime of home use.
• Best for freezer, microwave and steamer use → Giyochie 2. Rated safe across all of those, plus the air fryer and toaster oven.
• Best for acidic bakes like tomato-heavy quiches → Neither, honestly. Aluminum reacts to acidic ingredients, and tomato-based fillings are better suited to a different material entirely.
If I were buying for an air fryer, I'd get the Giyochie 2. The molds are sized for the basket, they release cleanly, and two 7-cup trays cover egg bites, mini quiches and English muffin-style rounds without a fight. In my opinion, it's the more useful pick for the way most people actually cook in an air fryer. I'd choose the Nordic Ware Naturals Compact Muffin instead if I wanted one small, durable pan for the toaster oven and conventional oven, and if broiler-safe aluminum mattered more to me than flexible, non-stick convenience. Different tools, different jobs.
FAQ
how to air fry english muffins
Split the English muffin, place the halves in the air fryer basket cut side up, and cook at a moderate temperature until the edges crisp and the surface browns. You're essentially toasting them, so keep an eye on them — they go from golden to dark quickly. If you're using the Giyochie 2 molds, they're for baking batter-based items like egg bites and muffin rounds, not for toasting split muffins.
Toast the split muffin halves first, then top with sauce, cheese and your toppings and return them to the basket. The second pass is short — just long enough to melt the cheese and warm the sauce through. Keep the toppings light so the muffin stays crisp underneath.
how to make air fryer english muffin pizzas
Start with a split English muffin, add a thin layer of sauce, then cheese and any toppings you like. Air fry until the cheese melts and the muffin edges are crisp. Because the muffin is already cooked, you're really just heating and melting, so the timing is brief compared to a raw dough pizza.
how long to air fryer english muffin pizzas
Think in short bursts rather than one long cook. A first pass to toast the muffin, then a brief second pass at a similar temperature until the cheese melts and bubbles. Check at the halfway mark the first time you make them, since basket size, topping load and your air fryer's power all shift the timing.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: West Bend Compact Air Fryer vs Tru 8-Quart: Best Air Fryer, ZHLINUO 3.81Qt vs Generic Air Fryer 3: Best Compact Air, Brentwood Appliances AF200W vs COSORI Mini Air Fryer