How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-19 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• NewFantasia Replacement Audio Cable — biggest strength: it's a purpose-built replacement for the Arctis family (3, 5, 7, Prime, Pro), with independently shielded L, R and mic lines plus a 3.5 mm Y-adapter in the box.
• NewFantasia Replacement Audio Cable — biggest trade-off: it is only a cable. It fixes a broken Arctis connection, but it does nothing if you don't already own a compatible SteelSeries headset — and it will not power the Arctis Pro's lights.
• PowerA Headset — biggest strength: a complete, ultra-lightweight over-ear headset with 50 mm dynamic drivers, on-ear volume slider and mic mute, a detachable boom mic, and an adjustable fabric-wrapped headband.
• PowerA Headset — biggest trade-off: it's wired, Nintendo Switch-focused, and has no noise control or wireless option — so it's a fixed setup, not a flexible one.
• Buy the NewFantasia cable if you own a SteelSeries Arctis headset and the cable is dead, crackling, or too short.
• Buy the PowerA Headset if you want a whole headset to plug straight into your Switch's 3.5 mm port and start playing.
Start with what this thing actually is: a 1.3 m (4.3 ft) black auxiliary cable, 3 mm in diameter, male-to-male, with three pins and a round, plastic-or-rubber jacket. It ships in a sealed anti-static bag with one audio cable and one 3.5 mm (1/8") Y-adapter. That's the whole package — no headphone, no handle, just the cable and the adapter.
The engineering detail that matters most is the shielding. NewFantasia builds this cable with independently shielded left, right and microphone lines. In plain terms, that means the audio channels and the mic signal don't bleed into each other inside the cable — which is exactly the kind of interference you can hear as hum, crosstalk or a mic that picks up game audio. It's also described as soft and comfortable, which matters more than it sounds: a stiff replacement cable tugs at your ear cups all session.
Compatibility is the whole point here. This cable is built for the SteelSeries Arctis 3, Arctis 5, Arctis 7, Arctis Prime and Arctis Pro. It connects your PC, PS4, Xbox One, Mac, consoles, phones and tablets to those headsets. One honest caveat straight from the spec sheet: if you use it to connect an Arctis Pro to a computer, the mic works fine, but the headset's lights will not turn on. That's a real limitation, and it's worth knowing before you buy rather than after.
So who should buy it? Someone whose Arctis cable has failed — the classic symptoms being one ear cutting out, a mic that crackles, or a connector that only works at a certain angle. Also anyone who wants a shorter, tidier run to their controller or phone without a coiled mess on the desk. It's rated for indoor and outdoor use, so tossing it in a bag with a handheld setup is fair game.
Who should skip it? Anyone who doesn't own one of those SteelSeries models — the connector and pin layout are designed for that family, and it will not magically work with another brand. And anyone expecting a full headset or working Arctis Pro lighting should look elsewhere.
The PowerA Wired Stereo Headset is the opposite kind of product: a complete, self-contained headset rather than a repair part. It's officially licensed for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, connects through the console's 3.5 mm jack, and comes in a Fortnite Llambro theme with a code for a bonus virtual item called Glyphic included in the box.
Comfort is clearly the design brief. The frame is ultra-lightweight at 7.84 ounces, with over-ear breathable fabric earpads and a fabric-wrapped headband that expands to fit. For long sessions — the kind where you forget you're wearing anything — that combination of low weight and breathable fabric is the right call. The Llambro color and video-game theme are cosmetic, but they're the reason a lot of people pick this model over a plain black headset.
Audio comes from 50 mm dynamic drivers with a listed sensitivity of 220 gravity. That's a large driver for a headset at this weight, and larger drivers generally move more air, which tends to translate into fuller game audio and clearer voice chat. Whether it sounds good to you is subjective, but the hardware is aimed at the "hear the footsteps and the party chat" job.
Who should buy it? Switch and Switch 2 owners who want one box that solves everything — headset, mic, controls — and who value light weight over wireless freedom. It's also a good fit for younger players or anyone who wants a detachable mic for the commute. Who should skip it? PC players who want a headset for a SteelSeries Arctis setup, people who need wireless, and anyone who needs noise isolation on a loud bus or in a shared room. It also carries a 2-year limited warranty, which is worth noting if durability worries you.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for fixing a broken Arctis headset → NewFantasia Replacement Audio Cable. It's the only one of the two that connects to SteelSeries Arctis 3, 5, 7, Prime and Pro.
• Best for a complete plug-and-play setup → PowerA Headset. Everything you need is in the box, including the mic.
• Best for voice chat clarity → PowerA Headset. A dedicated detachable boom mic with an on-ear mute button beats relying on a replacement cable to carry your existing mic signal.
• Best for cable length control → NewFantasia Replacement Audio Cable. A fixed 1.3 m (4.3 ft) run with a 3 mm profile is short and tidy for controller or phone use.
• Best for long-session comfort → PowerA Headset. 7.84 ounces, breathable fabric earpads and an adjustable headband are built for hours.
• Best for drivers and control → PowerA Headset. 50 mm dynamic drivers plus an on-ear volume slider and mute button.
• Best for travel and portability → PowerA Headset. The boom mic detaches, and the headset is light enough to pack.
• Best for Arctis Pro owners who want lights → neither, honestly. The NewFantasia cable runs the mic and audio but won't light up the Arctis Pro.
• Best for console flexibility → NewFantasia Replacement Audio Cable. It works across PC, PS4, Xbox One, Mac, consoles, phones and tablets — but only into a compatible Arctis headset.
My Verdict
That said, I'd recommend the NewFantasia Replacement Audio Cable without hesitation to a specific buyer: someone who already owns an Arctis 3, 5, 7, Prime or Pro and whose cable has failed. Replacing a cheap cable is far smarter than replacing a working headset, and the independent L/R/mic shielding is the right design for that job. Just remember the Arctis Pro lighting caveat. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever one matches your situation before you commit.
It's designed for the Arctis 3, Arctis 5, Arctis 7, Arctis Prime and Arctis Pro. If your headset isn't on that list, don't buy it — the connector is built for that family specifically.
It's designed and licensed for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2 and connects via the 3.5 mm port. Any device with a standard 3.5 mm jack may accept it, but the product is aimed squarely at Switch consoles.
No. The spec sheet states clearly that when you connect an Arctis Pro to a computer with this cable, the mic works well but the lights don't turn on. Audio and mic only.
They're not really comparable purchases. In my opinion the PowerA Headset gives you more for the money if you need a whole headset, while the NewFantasia cable is a targeted, low-cost fix for an Arctis owner. Check the current price on Amazon for both and decide based on which problem you actually have.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.