A county sheriff is accused by his two daughters of having abused them. Under interrogation, and guided by his pastor, he thinks the devil has blinded him to his guilt and confesses. The girls' accusations get more and more elaborate, involving satanic rituals, their mother, other police officers and neighbors. A memory expert is called into to clarify the growing confusion and can easily see the girls are lying.
William Devane William Devane ... Dr. Richard Ofshe
John Shea John Shea ... Sheriff Matthew Bradshaw
Bess Armstrong Bess Armstrong ... Roberta 'Bobbie' Bradshaw
Dean Norris Dean Norris ... Detective Carl Messenger
Brian Markinson Brian Markinson ... Lowell Hart
Lisa Dean Ryan Lisa Dean Ryan ... Rebecca Bradshaw
Timothy Patrick Quill Timothy Patrick Quill ... Stan Cooper (as Tim Quill)
Gary Grubbs Gary Grubbs ... Reverend Ralph Newton
John M. Jackson John M. Jackson ... Wayne Everett
Ray McKinnon Ray McKinnon ... Steve Sweetler
Brandon Smith Brandon Smith ... Sheriff
T.C. Warner T.C. Warner ... Laura Bradshaw
Matthew Faison Matthew Faison ... Attorney Leggert
Karla Tamburrelli Karla Tamburrelli ... Mrs. Gibbons
Julie Ariola Julie Ariola ... Jerry
based on Lawrence Wright's New Yorker articles and his book Remembering Satan,[1] which was in turn based on the actual case of Paul Ingram