How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want to shield a pair of AirPods Max in a shell that looks and feels like genuine carbon fiber, choose MONOCARBON Real Carbon Fiber; if you need to bring a tired pair of PHONON SMB-02 or SMB-02G headphones back to life, choose PHONON SMB-02/02G.
These two products share a category — headphone accessories — and almost nothing else. One is a hard protective cover for Apple's over-ear headphones. The other is a pair of replacement ear pads for a specific line of studio-monitoring headphones. The right pick depends entirely on which problem is sitting on your desk.
• MONOCARBON Real Carbon Fiber — biggest strength: a 10 g, 0.6 mm shell made of 100% real carbon fiber that adds military-grade drop, scratch and sweat protection to AirPods Max without changing how they feel on your head.
• MONOCARBON Real Carbon Fiber — biggest trade-off: it protects and refines the headphones you already own; it does nothing for sound, pads or comfort, and it only fits AirPods Max.
• PHONON SMB-02/02G — biggest strength: a fresh pair of luxury ear pads with protein-leather surfaces and a polyurethane interior designed to cut bass reverberation and block outside noise.
• PHONON SMB-02/02G — biggest trade-off: it is a genuine replacement part, not an upgrade or a cosmetic accessory — and it fits only SMB-02 and SMB-02G headphones.
• Buy MONOCARBON if you own AirPods Max and want to keep them looking new.
• Buy PHONON if you own SMB-02 or SMB-02G headphones and your current pads are worn out.
The pitch here is material honesty. MONOCARBON states plainly that the cover is 100% real carbon fiber — the same family of material used in racing-car bodies — rather than a printed carbon-look plastic. That matters for two reasons. First, carbon fiber is naturally stiff and light, so the company can quote a shell weight of just 10 g and a thickness of 0.6 mm. Second, the material is described as corrosion-resistant and stable enough that it will not fade even after ten years of use. In practice, that means you can carry your AirPods Max in a bag, set them down on a desk, or wear them through a sweaty commute and expect the shell to shrug it off rather than scuff.
The fit is the other half of the story. MONOCARBON says the case is molded from the real product with precision cutting, so the buttons and holes line up exactly and the cover reaches maximum area coverage. Notably, the cutouts leave the Bluetooth antenna exposed — a small design detail that avoids the connectivity complaints that sometimes come with fully sealed metal shells. It is compatible with both the 2024 model and older AirPods Max, and it installs easily. A one-year warranty is included.
Who should buy it? Someone who already owns AirPods Max and treats them as a long-term purchase. The extra features — anti-slip surface, scratch resistance, slim profile, water resistance — all point to daily-carry use: commuting, travel, studio sessions, working from cafés. The glossy forged black finish is understated enough to suit most people, and the gift-box packaging makes it a reasonable present for someone who has just bought a pair of these headphones.
Who should skip it? Anyone who does not own AirPods Max — the fit is specific to that headphone. And anyone hoping an accessory will change how their headphones sound. This is protection and appearance, nothing more. If you want to compare the current price on Amazon before deciding, the button on this page will take you there.
This is a maintenance product, and it is honest about that. PHONON sells a single pair of replacement ear pads — one for the left cup, one for the right — built specifically for the SMB-02 and SMB-02G headphones. The listing is clear that the headphones themselves are not included. You are buying the part that wears out first.
The construction is where the thought shows. The outer surface uses high-quality protein leather, chosen for comfort against the skin during long listening sessions. The interior uses polyurethane leather, and its job is to reduce bass reverberation — essentially keeping low frequencies from bouncing around inside the cup and turning muddy. PHONON also notes that the pads' large gussets are shaped to preserve a certain amount of side pressure, which is what keeps the headphones stable on your head and helps the seal do its work.
That seal is the functional core of the design. PHONON describes the pads as adding sound insulation and blocking external sound better than a worn-out pair would. For studio work especially, where monitoring accuracy depends on what is actually reaching your ears, a fresh, well-sealed pad changes what you hear far more than most people expect. The same applies at home: a proper seal means you hear more of the recording and less of the room.
Who should buy it? Owners of SMB-02 or SMB-02G headphones whose pads are flattened, cracked, peeling or simply past their best. Also anyone who shares those headphones and wants a hygienic fresh pair, or who keeps a spare set so they are never caught out mid-project. Who should skip it? Owners of any other headphone brand — the fit is model-specific. And anyone shopping for a gift for an AirPods Max owner; this will not fit.
• Best for protecting an expensive new purchase → MONOCARBON Real Carbon Fiber. A 10 g shell that guards against drops, scratches and sweat.
• Best for restoring headphones you already love → PHONON SMB-02/02G. New pads for SMB-02 and SMB-02G, nothing else included.
• Best for sound-related improvement → PHONON SMB-02/02G. Protein leather plus a low-reverberation polyurethane interior is a direct acoustic design choice.
• Best for long-term durability of the accessory itself → MONOCARBON Real Carbon Fiber. Real carbon fiber, described as fade-resistant over a decade of use, with a one-year warranty.
• Best for travel and daily carry → MONOCARBON Real Carbon Fiber. Anti-slip, scratch-resistant, slim and water resistant.
• Best for studio and critical listening → PHONON SMB-02/02G. The pads are designed around monitoring accuracy and external-noise blocking.
• Best as a gift → MONOCARBON Real Carbon Fiber. It ships in luxury gift packaging and suits a wide range of ages and tastes.
• Best for a quick, low-effort fix → PHONON SMB-02/02G. Pads swap on and off in minutes; the cover is a cosmetic and protective layer you add on top.
If you put a decision in front of me, I would buy the PHONON SMB-02/02G — but only because I would be solving for a specific pair of headphones that actually needs new pads. For SMB-02 and SMB-02G owners, this is the difference between hearing your headphones properly and hearing a muffled, leaking version of them, and the material choices show the part was designed rather than sourced. If, on the other hand, you own AirPods Max and want to keep them pristine, the MONOCARBON cover is the smarter buy: real carbon fiber, genuinely light, and cut to fit the buttons and antenna properly. In my opinion, most people reading this already know which of those two problems is theirs.
Yes. MONOCARBON states the cover fits both the 2024 model and the original AirPods Max, with precision cutouts that leave the Bluetooth antenna exposed.
No. PHONON specifies these pads for the SMB-02 and SMB-02G only. They are a model-specific replacement part, not a universal fit.
They are designed to. The protein-leather surface and polyurethane interior are intended to reduce bass reverberation and improve external-noise blocking, which typically sharpens monitoring accuracy compared with worn pads.
They solve different problems, so value depends on what you own. For AirPods Max owners, the MONOCARBON cover protects a costly device with a very light shell. For SMB-02 or SMB-02G owners, the PHONON pads restore a headphone you already have instead of replacing it. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever matches your headphones.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.