We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a reusable liner that keeps dual-basket air fryers clean for years and doubles as a baking accessory, choose MMH Silicone Air Fryer; if you need zero-washup disposable sheets that fit a rectangular grill-and-air-fryer combo tray, choose GOAUS Parchment Paper Liners.
• MMH Silicone Air Fryer — biggest strength: Two reusable, food-grade silicone pots with handles and grooved bases that catch grease, survive up to 428°F, and go in the dishwasher. Sold as a 2-count, so each dual-zone basket gets its own liner.
• MMH Silicone Air Fryer — biggest trade-off: You have to wash them. Flexible silicone holds onto oil film, so it needs real washing between greasy cooks, and the 7.68 x 5 x 2.76 inch footprint is built for 6–8 qt dual-basket machines, not slim rectangular trays.
• GOAUS Parchment Paper Liners — biggest strength: 150 precut, unbleached paper sheets sized 11.5 x 6 inches for rectangular air fryer/grill combo trays. Cook, lift, toss. No scrubbing, no dishwasher space used.
• GOAUS Parchment Paper Liners — biggest trade-off: They are single-use, and they are the one accessory you must never leave in an empty basket during preheat — loose paper can blow into the heating element and scorch.
• Who each pick is for: MMH suits dual-basket owners who hate repurchasing and want one purchase that lasts. GOAUS suits rectangular-tray grill combo owners who value speed over longevity.
The MMH liners are a two-piece set of rectangular silicone pots, each measuring 7.68 x 5 x 2.76 inches in red. They are designed around dual-zone cooking: the Ninja Foodi DualZone DZ201 8QT, the DZ090 6QT, and the Ninja DoubleStack SL201 8QT are the named fits, and MMH also rates them for other 6–8 qt dual-basket fryers. The capacity listing is 6 quarts, so if you cook in two baskets at once, you get a liner for each side — that is the whole point of the 2-count.
Buy it if you own a dual-basket fryer and want to stop buying consumables — one purchase, repeated use, no restocking. Skip it if you have a rectangular grill combo tray or a small single basket, if you genuinely will not hand-wash a greasy silicone pot, or if you want the option of throwing the mess away at the end of a cook. Also note the first-use guidance: give them a simple wash before the first cook.
GOAUS Parchment Paper Liners: Who It's For
GOAUS sells 150 precut rectangular paper sheets, 11.5 x 6 inches, unbleached and food-grade, made from natural wood pulp. They are shaped "with sides" — a shallow bowl form rather than a flat sheet — so they sit in the bottom of a rectangular tray and hold crumbs, grease and oil instead of letting it run into the drip path. Heat resistance is rated to 428°F, the same ceiling as the silicone liners, and the paper is waterproof and greaseproof with a non-stick surface so food lifts off cleanly.
The fit is the whole story here. These are built for air fryer/grill combos with a rectangular pan or tray — the Ninja Foodi FG511, BG550, DG551 family is called out, along with the FG551, DG551 and IG651 in the product title. If your machine has a rectangle tray, a round or square liner will not seat properly; this one will. Because you get 150 sheets, a heavy user can double up on messy, greasy cooks as GOAUS itself recommends, and still get through months of cooking.
Buy it if your priority is speed and zero cleanup, if you own a rectangular grill combo, or if you cook for people who don't want to handle greasy cookware at all. Skip it if you want a permanent accessory, or if you'd rather not think about safe placement every single time. That last point is not a small one: you must not preheat with an empty paper liner in the basket, because hot air lifts the lightweight sheet into the heating duct where it can burn. Weight it down with food, and read the instructions first.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for rectangular air fryer/grill combos (FG511, BG550, DG551, FG551, IG651) → GOAUS Parchment Paper Liners. An 11.5 x 6 inch footprint made for a rectangular tray.
• Lowest ongoing effort per cook → GOAUS. Lift the sheet with the food, throw it away, done. No washing.
• Lowest cost over years of use → MMH. Two reusable silicone pots replace an endless stream of disposable sheets.
• Best for high-heat versatility beyond the air fryer → MMH. Rated for oven, microwave, steamer and Instant Pot use, -40°F to 428°F.
• Best for greasy, messy foods → GOAUS. Double the liners, then bin them; no oil film left on silicone to scrub.
• Safest for forgetful preheaters → MMH. Silicone stays put and cannot blow into the heating element; loose paper can.
• Best for gifting a cooking enthusiast → MMH. The 2-count silicone set reads like a durable kitchen upgrade rather than a consumable.
I would buy the MMH Silicone Air Fryer set, and it comes down to ownership versus consumption. If you own a dual-basket Ninja Foodi, the 2-count design, the 428°F ceiling, the dishwasher-safe silicone and the built-in handles solve the actual problem — grease baking onto your baskets — without you ever buying the accessory again. The GOAUS liners are genuinely excellent at what they do, and if my machine had a rectangular grill combo tray I would keep a box in the drawer for greasy cooks and lazy nights. But for most dual-zone owners, the reusable set is the smarter long-term pick. Check the current price on Amazon for both before you decide, since that is the one number that can flip this call.
MMH. The 2-count silicone pots are sized for dual-zone machines like the DZ201 8QT, DZ090 6QT and DoubleStack SL201, and give you one liner per basket with handles for lifting.
Not well. They are 11.5 x 6 inch rectangular sheets designed for air fryer/grill combos with a rectangle tray or pan, such as the FG511, BG550 and DG551 — not round or dual-basket cavities.
No. GOAUS specifically warns against placing a liner in the basket without food during preheating, because hot air blows the lightweight paper onto the heating duct and it can burn. Always weigh it down with food.
That is the honest trade-off. MMH liners are dishwasher safe, but they still need to go in the machine and take up space. If you truly want zero cleanup, the GOAUS disposable route is the better match for how you cook.
MMH is a reusable 2-count, so it lasts until the silicone wears out. GOAUS gives you 150 precut sheets, and GOAUS recommends doubling liners for very greasy cooks, so plan accordingly.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Generic AAFEEN 100 vs Fukaisu 8: Air Fryer Parchment Liners, AODPWEN 130 vs TCSNOE 150PCS: Air Fryer Parchment Paper, KUKUGO Air Fryer Liners vs EKACO 10: Can You Use Parchment