How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a ready-made Buffalo wing flavor shortcut built on Frank's RedHot heat and McCormick spices, choose McCormick Air Fryer Buffalo; if you need replacement trays and racks for a Gourmia 24L French door air fryer oven, choose HPAITKPA 3Pcs.
• McCormick Air Fryer Buffalo — biggest strength: A seasoning mix purpose-built for the air fryer, blending Frank's RedHot cayenne heat with McCormick spices like garlic powder and paprika, with no artificial flavors.
• McCormick Air Fryer Buffalo — biggest trade-off: It's a consumable. You get a 12-pack of 1.25 oz pouches, and once the packets are gone, so is the flavor. It also only does Buffalo — if you want variety, this isn't it.
• HPAITKPA 3Pcs — biggest strength: Three pieces of heavy-duty, uncoated food-grade stainless steel sized specifically for Gourmia GTF7655, GTF7460 and GTF7465 24L French door air fryer ovens, with a fine mesh design for 360° airflow.
• HPAITKPA 3Pcs — biggest trade-off: It's a hardware accessory for a specific oven. If you don't own a compatible Gourmia model, it's useless to you.
• Who McCormick is for: Anyone with an air fryer who wants Buffalo wings and Buffalo fries with less oil and less cleanup, fast.
• Who HPAITKPA is for: Gourmia 24L French door oven owners whose original trays are worn, warped or missing.
This is a flavor product, and it knows exactly what it is. McCormick developed its Air Fryer Seasoning Mix line specifically for air fryer cooking, and the Buffalo version leans on Frank's RedHot Sauce for its heat. That matters, because "Buffalo" is a specific flavor profile — cayenne-forward, tangy, buttery-adjacent — and a generic spicy blend doesn't get you there.
What it does best is remove the guesswork. You're not building a wing sauce from scratch, measuring cayenne and vinegar, then hoping the coating crisps instead of steaming. The mix is built for air-fried food, so you get crisp Buffalo wings and Buffalo fries with less oil than deep-frying, in less time than frying, with less mess to clean up afterward. For game day or a weeknight when nobody wants to babysit a pot of hot oil, that's a genuinely useful shortcut.
The ingredient side is worth a mention too. McCormick uses its own spices here — garlic powder, paprika — and skips artificial flavors. If you're feeding kids or just prefer a label you can read without a chemistry degree, that's a point in its favor. The package also includes recipes, and if you don't own an air fryer, the mix works in a regular oven as well, which softens the "do I actually need this" question.
HPAITKPA 3Pcs: Who It's For
This is the opposite kind of purchase: not flavor, but hardware. The HPAITKPA 3Pcs set is a toaster-oven replacement part kit built around one specific family of machines — the Gourmia GTF7655, GTF7460 and GTF7465 24L French door air fryer ovens. The trays measure 12.3'' x 12.3'' x 1.3'', and the set is designed to drop in for a seamless match.
The material is the headline. These are heavy-duty, food-grade stainless steel, uncoated, described as hard to oxidize and stable under high heat without warping. That "uncoated" detail is the one I'd pay attention to: coated racks eventually chip and flake, and once a coating starts going, you're shopping again. Bare stainless doesn't have that failure mode. The manufacturer states the parts meet FDA standards for food contact.
The mesh design is the second thing that matters. A fine mesh basket structure is what allows 360° hot air circulation, which is the entire reason air frying works — hot air has to move around the food, not just under it. A solid tray or a clogged, greasy old rack gives you uneven results and soggy bottoms. This set is built to avoid exactly that, aiming for uniform heating and that crispy golden exterior.
Versatility is broader than you'd expect from "replacement parts." The set covers baking, frying and grilling, and it handles chicken wings, fries, vegetables and cookies — basically the full daily rotation of a countertop oven. Cleanup is handled too: smooth, burr-free edges (no snagging your sponge or your fingers) and all pieces are dishwasher safe, so you're not scrubbing mesh by hand.
Buy it if you own one of the compatible Gourmia 24L French door models and your original trays are stained, bent, or you simply want spares so you can cook back-to-back without washing in between. Skip it if you don't own a compatible Gourmia oven — the sizing is the whole point, and a 12.3-inch tray won't do anything for a different brand.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for flavor, fast → McCormick Air Fryer Buffalo. Frank's RedHot heat plus McCormick spices, made for the air fryer.
• Best for replacing worn hardware → HPAITKPA 3Pcs. Three stainless pieces sized for Gourmia GTF7655, GTF7460 and GTF7465.
• Best for durability under high heat → HPAITKPA 3Pcs. Uncoated food-grade stainless steel built not to warp; nothing to chip or flake.
• Best for even crisping → HPAITKPA 3Pcs. The fine mesh basket structure is what drives 360° air circulation and uniform browning.
• Best for cleanup → Both, differently. McCormick means less oil splatter and no deep-fry pot; HPAITKPA means burr-free edges and dishwasher-safe trays.
• Best for a one-time purchase → HPAITKPA 3Pcs. It's a durable good you buy once. McCormick is consumable and runs out.
• Best for oven owners without an air fryer → McCormick Air Fryer Buffalo. The mix works in a conventional oven too. HPAITKPA is strictly for compatible Gourmia units.
• Best for feeding a crowd repeatedly → McCormick Air Fryer Buffalo. Twelve 1.25 oz pouches cover a lot of wing nights.
These two barely compete — they solve completely different problems, and the "right" answer depends on what's broken in your kitchen. If your air fryer works fine and you just want great Buffalo wings without the oil and the mess, I'd buy McCormick Air Fryer Buffalo. The Frank's RedHot base, the McCormick spice blend, the no-artificial-flavors label and the fact that it works in a regular oven too make it an easy, low-risk pantry addition. If you own a compatible Gourmia 24L French door oven and your trays are past their prime, I'd buy HPAITKPA 3Pcs instead — uncoated stainless steel, a mesh design that actually moves air, and dishwasher-safe cleanup is a smarter long-term spend than nursing a warped rack. In my opinion, the deciding question is simply: do you need flavor, or do you need parts?
No. It's a dry seasoning mix that gets its flavor and heat from Frank's RedHot Sauce, combined with McCormick spices like garlic powder and paprika. It's a coating you apply before air frying, not a liquid sauce you pour on after.
Only if you own a Gourmia GTF7655, GTF7460 or GTF7465 24L French door air fry oven. The trays are sized 12.3'' x 12.3'' x 1.3'' to match those models. Check your oven's model number before buying — sizing is the entire value here.
No. McCormick states the mix can also be used in a conventional oven if you don't own an air fryer. The results are designed around air frying, but the oven is a supported fallback.
Yes. All pieces in the set are dishwasher safe, and the edges are smooth and burr-free. The stainless steel is uncoated, so there's no coating to wear away over time.
They're not comparable purchases, so compare them to what they replace. HPAITKPA is a durable three-piece set you buy once; McCormick is a 12-pack of consumable seasoning that eventually runs out. For current pricing on either, check the latest price on Amazon using the button on this page.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.