If you want a proven, compact carrier that fits standard crossbars with ease and offers solid 17 cubic feet of space for weekend gear, choose Maxsa Innovations 17; if you need maximum capacity for family road trips with oversized items like strollers or multiple large suitcases, choose SierraSquad ABS Rooftop Cargo.
• Maxsa Innovations 17: Its biggest strength is its balanced 69-inch length and 165-pound capacity, making it ideal for couples or small families who want to free up back seats without overloading the roof; its trade-off is less total volume than larger competitors.
• SierraSquad ABS Rooftop Cargo: It shines with massive storage options up to 880 liters (26.5 cu ft) and extra dimensions designed specifically for bulky family loads; however, its sheer size and heavier weight demand more careful consideration regarding vehicle load limits and aerodynamics.
• Who it's for: The Maxsa is perfect for those prioritizing agility and fit on smaller SUVs, while the SierraSquad targets families moving in bulk who need every inch of available space.
The Maxsa Innovations 17 Cu Ft Rooftop Cargo Box Carrier stands out as a workhorse for travelers who value efficiency without sacrificing protection. Measuring exactly 69 inches long by 33 inches wide and 11 inches high, this unit strikes a deliberate balance between storage volume and vehicle integration. Whether you are hauling ski equipment, camping tents, or just clearing out the trunk for passengers, this box does the job without feeling like an afterthought on your roof.
One of the most practical features here is the dual-side opening mechanism. You do not have to circle your vehicle to access your belongings from one side only; the lid lifts easily from either the driver or passenger side. The self-supporting gas struts keep the lid propped open securely, allowing you to pack or unpack with both hands free. This is a genuine quality-of-life improvement when you are parked in tight spots at a hotel or a campsite where walking around the car isn't always convenient.
The construction relies on a durable ABS hard shell with a glossy finish. This material choice provides impact resistance against road debris, rust, and UV rays, ensuring your gear arrives dry and clean even after exposure to rain or snow. The low-profile aerodynamic shape is designed to cut through wind noise, which is critical for maintaining a comfortable driving experience. Installation is equally straightforward, requiring no drilling and fitting quickly onto factory, round, square, or aero crossbars. If you are looking for a reliable solution specifically for bike racks or general luggage that needs to stay secure but doesn't require a warehouse-sized container, this is the tool for the job.
However, there are clear boundaries to what this carrier can handle. At 17 cubic feet, it simply cannot accommodate the same volume as the largest models on the market. If you are planning a multi-week family relocation or need to transport six or more large suitcases simultaneously, you will likely find this space too cramped. It is a premium option for those who need reliability and smart design rather than sheer bulk.
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-11-06 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
The SierraSquad ABS Rooftop Cargo Box is built for a different kind of traveler: the family on a grand adventure. With sizes ranging from 600L to a massive 880L, this carrier is engineered to solve the problem of "not enough room." The largest model measures roughly 79.5 inches long, 35.4 inches wide, and 15.7 inches high, offering a staggering 26.5 cubic feet of storage. This extra height and width are not just numbers; they translate to the ability to stack bulky items like folding strollers, large coolers, and multiple oversized suitcases that would never fit in a smaller box.
The design philosophy here centers on capacity and accessibility. The hydraulic arms allow the heavy lid to be held open with minimal effort, a crucial feature given the larger surface area of the lid. Like the Maxsa, it features a dual-side opening, meaning you can load up from either side of the vehicle regardless of where you park. This flexibility is invaluable when dealing with heavy loads, as you don't have to wrestle with a narrow gap to reach deep into the box. The sealed design promises waterproof and sun-resistant performance, keeping clothes, sleeping bags, and delicate electronics dry during unexpected storms or long drives through harsh weather.
The physical build uses a high-quality ABS hard case that resists cutting and theft, providing peace of mind for expensive gear. The streamlined, water-drop shape is intended to reduce wind resistance compared to older, boxier designs, though the sheer size of the unit means some aerodynamic drag is inevitable. The installation process involves U-bolts and internal knobs, securing the box firmly to your crossbars. The glossy black finish adds a bold aesthetic to the vehicle, signaling that this is a serious piece of gear for serious trips.
This carrier is clearly aimed at households with significant travel needs. If you frequently take kids' gear, sports equipment, or camping supplies that fill up the trunk instantly, the SierraSquad eliminates the need to leave things behind. However, the increased dimensions mean it requires a vehicle with robust roof rails and a higher dynamic weight capacity. It is not a subtle addition to your car; it is a statement piece designed to carry everything you own when the interior space runs out.
• Best for Compact Vehicles: Choose Maxsa Innovations 17 if you drive a sedan or a smaller SUV where a 69-inch length is safer and easier to manage than a longer box.
• Best for Maximum Capacity: Choose SierraSquad ABS Rooftop Cargo if you need to haul six or more large pieces of luggage, strollers, or bulky camping gear that demands extra vertical and horizontal space.
• Best for Weight Limits: Choose Maxsa Innovations 17 if your vehicle has lower dynamic weight limits, as the smaller box is lighter and carries a slightly lower maximum payload recommendation.
• Best for Aerodynamics: While both claim streamlined designs, the Maxsa 17's lower profile and shorter length generally offer better fuel economy and less wind noise on highways.
• Best for Dual-Side Access: Both excel here, but the SierraSquad's hydraulic arms may feel smoother to operate due to the larger lid size and heavier construction.
• Best for Standard Crossbars: Maxsa Innovations 17 is often easier to mount on a wider variety of crossbar shapes without needing extensive adjustment.
• Best for Family Road Trips: Choose SierraSquad ABS Rooftop Cargo for long-distance family vacations where every ounce of packing space counts.
• Best for Weekend Warriors: Choose Maxsa Innovations 17 for quick trips where you need to clear the trunk but don't need to store a month's worth of gear.
After analyzing the specs and intended use cases, I would buy the Maxsa Innovations 17 for my personal setup. While the SierraSquad offers impressive volume, its sheer size often makes it impractical for everyday driving or vehicles with moderate roof load limits. The Maxsa 17 hits the sweet spot of being large enough to handle a week's worth of luggage yet small enough to remain aerodynamic and manageable. It is the superior choice for most drivers who want a reliable companion for bike racks and general travel without turning their car into a slow-moving barge. However, if you absolutely cannot fit your family's gear inside, the SierraSquad is the only logical alternative.
Yes, the Maxsa Innovations 17 is explicitly designed for use alongside bike racks or other roof accessories, provided the combined weight stays under the vehicle's limit and the box fits securely on your crossbars.
Both units feature ABS hard shells and sealed designs to protect against rain and snow. The SierraSquad emphasizes its sealed design for long road trips, while Maxsa highlights its glossy finish and impact resistance for debris and UV protection.
Both the Maxsa Innovations 17 and the SierraSquad ABS Rooftop Cargo utilize tool-free or bolt-down systems that attach directly to existing crossbars, eliminating the need for any drilling on your vehicle's roof.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.