How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a reusable, food-grade silicone liner that keeps a 4–5.3QT basket air fryer clean and doubles as a baking mat or serving tray, choose Masgarlan Round Silicone Air; if you need a stainless-steel replacement crumb tray plus fiberglass oven liners built specifically for a Ninja Foodi countertop air fryer oven, choose GXF Air Fryer Accessories.
• Masgarlan's biggest strength → Food-grade, BPA-free silicone rated to 450°F, with a raised texture that separates grease and improves air circulation. Two liners in the pack, reusable and dishwasher-safe.
• Masgarlan's biggest trade-off → It's sized for round 4–5.3QT basket air fryers (8.07" top, 6.89" bottom, 1.97" tall). It won't fit a large countertop oven-style air fryer.
• GXF's biggest strength → A food-grade stainless steel replacement crumb tray (13.2 x 12.8 inches) plus four fiberglass oven liners, all dishwasher safe, designed to catch drips and cut down on smoke and odors.
• GXF's biggest trade-off → It's built for Ninja Foodi SP100/SP101/SP1001C/SP201 ovens only. If you own a basket air fryer, this set simply won't fit — you must measure first.
• Who each pick is for → Masgarlan for basket-air-fryer owners who want easy cleanup and a multi-use silicone liner; GXF for Ninja Foodi countertop oven owners who need a drop-in crumb tray replacement and protective liners.
The Masgarlan liners solve the single most annoying part of basket air frying: scrubbing grease off the bottom of the drawer. You drop one in, cook, then rinse it under the tap or toss it in the dishwasher. Because the surface is non-stick silicone, oil and residue don't cling the way they do to bare metal, so cleanup takes seconds rather than a soak-and-scrub session.
The design detail I like most is the raised texture. It lifts food slightly off the base, which lets hot air move underneath and gives fat somewhere to drain. That's the difference between soggy bottoms and evenly crispy results, especially with things like nuggets, fries or roasted vegetables. The silicone is food-grade, BPA-free, odorless and heat-resistant up to 450°F, so it's fine for direct contact with food and for most air-fryer recipes you'd realistically run.
Who should buy it: anyone with a compatible 4–5.3QT basket air fryer who cooks often and hates cleanup. The versatility is a real bonus too — it works in ovens, microwaves, fridges and steamers, and doubles as a baking mat, serving tray or fruit plate. Who should skip it: owners of large oven-style air fryers, or anyone whose basket falls outside that 4–5.3QT range. A round liner in a rectangular oven cavity just wastes space.
GXF Air Fryer Accessories: Who It's For
GXF takes the opposite approach. Instead of a liner you place inside a basket, this is a replacement part set for a specific appliance: the Ninja Foodi SP100, SP101, SP1001C and SP201 countertop air fryer ovens. The centerpiece is a stainless steel crumb tray measuring 13.2 x 12.8 inches that sits at the bottom of the oven and collects oil, grease and food bits as you cook.
That placement matters. When drips land on the tray instead of the heating element or the oven floor, they don't burn onto a hot surface — which is exactly why GXF highlights reduced smoke and odors. Anyone who has baked something fatty in a countertop oven knows the smell of grease hitting a hot element. Catching it lower down prevents that, and it also stops stubborn stains from baking onto the hard-to-reach bottom of the appliance.
The tray is food-grade stainless steel, BPA-free, non-toxic and tasteless, and it's dishwasher safe with a non-stick coating on the surface. One practical note from the specs: don't scrub it with abrasive pads or metal balls, since that damages the coating. The set also includes four fiberglass oven liners, giving you extra protection and flexibility for messy recipes.
Who should buy it: Ninja Foodi SP-series oven owners whose original crumb tray is worn, stained or missing, or anyone who wants a spare plus liners on hand. Who should skip it: anyone with a basket air fryer, or with a Ninja model outside the SP100/SP101/SP1001C/SP201 family. The specs even warn you to measure your existing grill plate before ordering — take that seriously, because a 13.2 x 12.8-inch tray is not a universal fit.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for basket air fryers (4–5.3QT) → Masgarlan Round Silicone Air. The round dimensions and listed Ninja/COSORI/Chefman/Bella/Instant Pot compatibility are built for that shape.
• Best for Ninja Foodi countertop ovens → GXF Air Fryer Accessories. It's engineered specifically for the SP100, SP101, SP1001C and SP201.
• Best for easy daily cleanup → Both, honestly. Masgarlan rinses clean thanks to non-stick silicone; GXF's tray is dishwasher safe with a non-stick coating.
• Best for grease separation while cooking → Masgarlan. The raised texture lifts food and drains fat during the cook, not just after.
• Best for multi-use beyond the air fryer → Masgarlan. It works as a baking mat, serving tray or fruit plate, and fits ovens, microwaves and steamers.
• Best for replacing a worn-out part → GXF. This is a replacement crumb tray plus liners, not a universal accessory.
• Best if you're unsure about fit → Measure first either way. Masgarlan needs a 4–5.3QT round basket; GXF needs a 13.2 x 12.8-inch SP-series oven cavity.
If I had to pick one, it depends entirely on which machine is sitting on your counter — and that's the honest answer here, because these two products barely compete for the same buyer. For a standard 4–5.3QT basket air fryer, I'd buy the Masgarlan Round Silicone Air. It's the lower-effort upgrade: drop it in, cook, rinse, repeat, and the raised texture genuinely helps with crisping and grease drainage. For a Ninja Foodi SP-series countertop oven, I'd buy the GXF set, because a silicone basket liner is useless in that appliance and a proper stainless crumb tray is the thing that actually protects it. Match the product to your appliance first, then check the current price on Amazon.
FAQ
It's designed for the Ninja Foodi SP100, SP101, SP1001C and SP201 air fryer ovens, at 13.2 x 12.8 inches. The manufacturer advises measuring your existing grill plate before ordering, which is good advice for any replacement part.
Both are dishwasher safe. Masgarlan's silicone is non-stick and rinses quickly; GXF's tray has a non-stick coating but should be washed without abrasive pads or metal scrubbers to protect it.
Yes. It's listed as suitable for ovens, microwaves, refrigerators and steamers, and can serve as a baking mat, serving tray or fruit plate.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Linda's Essentials Reusable Round Silicone vs GXF Air Fryer Accessorie, rhsaae Round Air Fryer vs OUKEYI Air Fryer Accessories，Upgrade, GCQFZ Air Fryer Accessories vs Komzon Silicone Air Fryer