How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• LYHOLKEER's biggest strength: a food-grade silicone liner rated to 450°F with dual-side perforations and dual handles, sized to drop into a long list of 5–8 QT air fryers.
• LYHOLKEER's biggest trade-off: it is a 1-pack, and because it fits 5–8 QT baskets rather than one exact model, you have to measure your basket before ordering.
• HPAITKPA's biggest strength: a complete crumb-management kit — one stainless steel tray plus four thickened PTFE mats — aimed at a specific family of Ninja Foodi ovens.
• HPAITKPA's biggest trade-off: it is a replacement part, not a universal accessory. If your oven is not one of the listed Ninja SP models, it is the wrong buy entirely.
• Who each pick is for: LYHOLKEER for the cook who wants less scrubbing and more flexibility; HPAITKPA for the Ninja Foodi SP101/SP151/SP201/SP301 owner replacing a tired tray or protecting the original one.
This is a liner, not a replacement part, and that distinction matters. The LYHOLKEER Silicone Air Fryer is a single square silicone basket liner measuring 8.8 inches across the top, 8 inches across the bottom and 3.2 inches tall. It is designed to sit inside your existing air fryer basket and catch the mess — grease, crumbs, sauce, whatever your chicken wings decide to throw around. The point is that your basket stays mostly clean while the liner takes the punishment, and since it is dishwasher safe, cleanup becomes a rinse-and-load job rather than a soak-and-scrub one.
The design details are where it separates itself from the cheap liners you see everywhere. Perforations run along both sides, which is meant to keep air moving around the food instead of trapping it, so you are not sacrificing crispness for convenience. There are two handles, which is a small thing that becomes a big thing when you are pulling a hot liner out of a 400°F basket. The silicone is food grade, heat resistant up to 450°F, and the brand describes it as thicker and taller than typical liners — taller walls mean more containment when you are cooking something saucy or breaded.
HPAITKPA Crumb Tray Pan: Who It's For
The HPAITKPA Crumb Tray Pan is a different animal entirely. It is a replacement crumb tray for Ninja Foodi air fryer toaster ovens, compatible with the SP101, SP151, SP201 and SP301 models. If you own one of those ovens and your original tray has seen better days — or you want to keep the original in good shape — this is the category of product you are looking for. It is built from stainless steel with a black finish, and it ships with four thickened PTFE mats as a set of five items total.
The mats are the interesting part. They are reusable, they catch crumbs before those crumbs reach the tray, and the idea is that you wipe or rinse them instead of scrubbing baked-on residue off metal. Both the tray and the mats are dishwasher safe, so the whole cleaning loop is short. HPAITKPA describes the PTFE material as food grade with a non-stick surface coating and notes that it does not release harmful substances under high heat. One thing to actually pay attention to: the mats are rated to a maximum of 480°F, but the brand recommends keeping cooking temperature below 450°F and watching your cooking duration for stable performance. That is a real operating constraint, and ignoring it is how non-stick coatings get ruined.
Who should buy it? Ninja Foodi SP-series owners who want a spare or replacement tray and like the idea of sacrificial mats catching the worst of the mess. It is a maintenance purchase, and it makes sense for someone who uses their toaster oven constantly and is tired of chiseling grease off metal. Who should skip it? Everyone else. If your appliance is not one of the listed Ninja models, this will not fit, and no amount of clever positioning fixes that. And if you were hoping for something that goes inside a basket-style air fryer, this is a completely different form factor — a flat tray, not a deep liner.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for keeping your basket clean → LYHOLKEER Silicone Air Fryer. It is literally shaped to sit inside a basket and catch what falls.
• Best for Ninja Foodi SP101/SP151/SP201/SP301 owners → HPAITKPA Crumb Tray Pan. Compatibility is explicit and narrow.
• Best for brand flexibility → LYHOLKEER Silicone Air Fryer. It covers a long list of 5–8 QT air fryers from multiple brands.
• Best for heat tolerance headroom → HPAITKPA's mats at 480°F max, with LYHOLKEER close behind at 450°F. Both handle normal air frying; HPAITKPA asks you to stay under 450°F anyway.
• Best for multi-piece value in one box → HPAITKPA Crumb Tray Pan. Tray plus four mats, five items total.
• Best for someone who wants one thing and not a kit → LYHOLKEER Silicone Air Fryer. One liner, one job.
• Best for countertop-to-camping versatility → LYHOLKEER Silicone Air Fryer. It works in ovens, microwaves, steamers and as a storage container.
In my opinion, most people landing on this comparison should buy the LYHOLKEER Silicone Air Fryer. It solves the problem that actually annoys air fryer owners — cleaning the basket — and it does so across a wide range of 5–8 QT machines, with perforated sides, handles and a 450°F rating that covers everyday cooking. I would only point you to the HPAITKPA Crumb Tray Pan if you specifically own a Ninja Foodi SP101, SP151, SP201 or SP301 and you need a tray or a protective mat layer. Buy for your appliance, not for the category. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit, and measure your basket first.
how to clean air fryer crumb tray
Let it cool completely, then wipe or rinse it. The HPAITKPA tray and its PTFE mats are dishwasher safe, so for most people the answer is simply to load them in the dishwasher. For stubborn spots, a soft sponge and warm soapy water does the job without scratching the non-stick coating.
how to clean breville air fryer crumb tray
The HPAITKPA Crumb Tray Pan is not listed as compatible with Breville ovens — it is made for Ninja Foodi SP101, SP151, SP201 and SP301 models. For a Breville tray, follow that manufacturer's own cleaning guidance. If you own one of the listed Ninja ovens, this tray and its four mats are dishwasher safe.
how to clean ninja air fryer crumb tray
If you have a Ninja Foodi SP-series toaster oven, the HPAITKPA tray is a compatible replacement and cleans with a wipe, a rinse or a dishwasher cycle. The four included PTFE mats are designed to catch crumbs so the tray underneath stays cleaner for longer. Keep cooking below 450°F to protect the mat coating.
how to get grease stains off of air fryer crumb tray
Grease responds best to warm soapy water and a non-abrasive sponge, since scrubbing hard can damage a non-stick surface. The HPAITKPA mats exist precisely so grease lands on something replaceable rather than on the tray itself. Both tray and mats are dishwasher safe, which handles most grease without extra effort.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: TeamFar Cooling Rack vs LYHOLKEER Loaf Pan Liners: Air Fryer, SHEbaking Silicone Muffin Pans vs Generic Air Fryer Tray, KunoNana Crumb Tray vs Anniparts 304: Air Fryer Crumb Tray