We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-19 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a complete ear-tip overhaul kit — foam tips, silicone tips, ear fins and cord clips in one box — choose Luckvan Universal Ear Fins; if you need a set of adjustable hooks made specifically to stop AirPods and AirPods Pro from slipping out, choose IiEXCEL 3.
• Luckvan Universal Ear Fins — biggest strength: it's a full replacement ecosystem. Three pairs of silicone ear fins, three pairs of memory foam tips, three pairs of silicone tips and two cord clips, sized L/M/S, in one pack.
• Luckvan Universal Ear Fins — biggest trade-off: it's a universal-fit kit, so you have to measure your earbud nozzle and housing before you buy. Nothing here is molded for one specific model.
• IiEXCEL 3 — biggest strength: it does one job with almost no guesswork. Three pairs of bendable TPU hooks that are listed as compatible with AirPods 1, 2, 3 and AirPods Pro 1 and 2.
• IiEXCEL 3 — biggest trade-off: it's hooks only. No replacement tips, no foam, no cord clips — if your tips are worn out, this pack doesn't fix that.
• Buy Luckvan if you own in-ear workout buds with a removable tip and you want to change how they sound and how they lock in.
• Buy IiEXCEL 3 if you own AirPods or AirPods Pro and your only problem is that they slide out during runs.
Luckvan sells a fix-it kit rather than a single accessory. The bag contains three pairs of silicone ear hooks in L/M/S, three pairs of memory foam tips in L/M/S, three pairs of standard silicone replacement tips in S/M/L, plus two 360-degree rotating cord clips. That's a genuinely broad package — it covers the three things that usually go wrong with a pair of in-ear sport buds: the tips wear out, the seal gets loose, and the earbud won't stay put during movement.
The fit numbers are the part worth reading carefully. The silicone tips have a 3.8 mm inner hole and are listed to fit nozzles from 4 mm to 6 mm. The memory foam tips run a 4.5 mm inner hole and are listed for 4.6 mm to 6.5 mm nozzles, with a medium size intended to suit most ears. The ear fins use a 10 mm wing hole and are listed to fit earphone housings measuring roughly 11 mm to 14 mm. So before ordering, measure your nozzle and the widest part of your earbud body. If your numbers land in those ranges, this kit will almost certainly work; if your buds are unusually slim or unusually chunky, they won't.
Who should skip it? Anyone with AirPods or AirPods Pro. Those have no removable tip on the standard models and no nozzle to measure, so a universal tip kit is the wrong shape of product. People who want zero measuring and zero thinking should also look elsewhere — this pack rewards a buyer who checks two dimensions first.
IiEXCEL 3: Who It's For
IiEXCEL 3 is a much narrower, much simpler product. You get three pairs of translucent ear hooks, and that's it — the listing is explicit that the earphones aren't included. They're made from bendable thermoplastic polyurethane, which is the key detail: TPU can be reshaped by hand and is meant to hold that new shape rather than springing back, so you can mold each hook to the curve of your own ear instead of accepting a fixed geometry.
The adjustment story goes further than most hooks. IiEXCEL lists both adjustable length and 360-degree rotation, which means you can slide and swivel the hook relative to the earbud stem to find an angle that actually sits against your ear rather than pressing on it. That's the difference between a hook you forget about and one you're constantly fiddling with. The C-shape wraps around the AirPod body to hold it in place, and the intended use cases are the obvious ones: running, jogging, cycling, gym work, anything where a loose AirPod means a dropped earbud.
Compatibility is where this product is strongest and most limited at the same time. It's listed for AirPods 3, 2 and 1, and for AirPods Pro 2nd and 1st generation. If that's what's in your pocket, the fit question is already answered — no measuring, no nozzle diameter, no housing width. If it isn't, this product has nothing for you. There's also no foam here, no replacement tips and no cord clips, so it won't change how your AirPods sound or how well they seal. It only changes how well they stay attached to your head.
Who should skip it? Anyone with wired in-ear buds, Beats models, Jaybird or similar sport earphones — the hooks are shaped around the AirPod stem and won't translate. Also skip it if your real complaint is muffled sound or a weak seal; that's a tip problem, not a hook problem. And if you want a hook that already matches your ear out of the box, note that these need a bit of hand-shaping first, which is a feature but also a small chore.
• Best for fixing the whole earbud setup → Luckvan Universal Ear Fins. Tips, fins and clips in one purchase instead of three separate orders.
• Best for AirPods and AirPods Pro owners → IiEXCEL 3. It's the only one of the two built around Apple's stem shape.
• Best for sound and noise isolation → Luckvan Universal Ear Fins. The memory foam tips are designed to expand and seal your ear canal, which is where bass and passive noise blocking come from.
• Best for zero-measuring convenience → IiEXCEL 3. Compatibility is stated by model name, so there's nothing to check with a ruler.
• Best for wired sport buds (Beats Flex, BeatsX, Jaybird-style) → Luckvan Universal Ear Fins. The cord clips and the 10 mm fin hole are aimed at exactly this kind of earbud.
• Best for adjustability → IiEXCEL 3. Bendable TPU plus 360-degree rotation and adjustable length gives you more ways to tune the angle.
• Best for value per piece → Luckvan Universal Ear Fins. Nine pairs plus two clips versus three pairs of hooks; you get far more usable parts per pack.
• Best for a single, focused fix → IiEXCEL 3. If the only thing wrong is that your AirPods fall out, this solves it and nothing else.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the Luckvan Universal Ear Fins — but only because my earbuds aren't AirPods. In my opinion it covers more ground: foam tips that genuinely change how in-ear buds seal and sound, silicone tips and fins that keep them locked in during runs, and cord clips for wired models. The catch is that you must measure your nozzle and housing first. If you own AirPods or AirPods Pro, though, my answer flips completely — the IiEXCEL 3 is the one I'd recommend, because it's shaped for your earbuds, adjusts in three directions and needs no measurement at all. Check the current price on Amazon before deciding, then buy based on which buds are in your pocket.
Not in any meaningful way. The kit is built around removable earbud tips and a fin hole sized for 11 mm–14 mm housings, while standard AirPods have no nozzle to fit a replacement tip onto. AirPods and AirPods Pro owners are better served by the IiEXCEL 3 hooks.
The listing names AirPods 3, 2 and 1 plus AirPods Pro 1st and 2nd generation only. The C-shape is molded around the AirPod stem, so it won't clip onto Beats, Jaybird or generic in-ear buds properly. Buy it for Apple earbuds or not at all.
Luckvan Universal Ear Fins, in my opinion. Its memory foam tips are designed to expand with your body temperature and fill the ear canal, which is what improves seal, low-end response and passive noise blocking. IiEXCEL 3 changes fit and retention only — it has no tips and won't alter sound.
The silicone parts of the Luckvan kit are the toughest here — washable, soft and reusable, and the fins are the pieces doing the gripping during exercise. The memory foam tips are the softest and will wear out fastest with heavy sweat, so expect to replace those sooner. IiEXCEL's TPU hooks are flexible and resist deforming, which makes them a solid long-term option if you only need retention.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.