If you want a rugged, tool-free mounting solution for securing shovels and gear to your roof rack during family road trips, choose LuBanSir 4; if you need a reliable replacement key set for your existing Thule-style lock system without visiting a shop, choose GENERIC Two Keys that. These two products solve completely different problems for the traveler, and picking the wrong one leaves you stranded with gear you cannot secure or a lock you cannot open. I have analyzed the design specifications and feature sets of both items to help you decide which one actually belongs in your travel kit.
• LuBanSir 4: Its biggest strength is the Y-shaped design that bundles tools securely without any hardware, but its trade-off is that it only fits items within a specific diameter range of 0.86 to 2 inches. This pick is for the adventurer who carries loose gear like shovels or poles on their roof.
• GENERIC Two Keys that: Its biggest strength is being pre-cut by a professional locksmith ready for immediate use, but its trade-off is that it serves only as a backup for specific Thule-compatible locks and offers no physical carrying utility. This pick is for the cautious driver who wants to avoid lockouts while traveling with roof cargo.
The LuBanSir 4 Pack Shovel Holder is engineered for a very specific physical task: keeping bulky items from rattling around on a vehicle roof. The core of its design is the unique Y-shape, which allows you to bundle multiple tools together into a single, tight package. Instead of trying to strap individual shovels or poles separately, this holder gathers them so they move as one unit. This is particularly useful when you are driving over uneven terrain or hitting potholes, as the bundled shape reduces wind resistance and prevents individual items from shifting independently.
Installation is designed to be entirely tool-free, relying on adjustable hook and loop straps. You simply wrap the clamp around your gear and the roof rack bar, then press the closure down. If you are heading out on a family road trip where you might stop at a trailhead to dig out snow or clear debris, having shovels that stay exactly where you put them is essential safety equipment.
This product is ideal for owners of ATVs, UTVs, RVs, SUVs, trucks, and trailers who frequently transport long-handled tools. It fits items up to 2 inches in diameter, making it versatile enough for most standard shovel handles or bundled poles. However, if you have extremely thin handles under 0.86 inches or massive, thick equipment, this holder will not function correctly. It is also strictly a mounting accessory; it does not hold keys, electronics, or small luggage. If your primary concern is organizing heavy, awkward gear on a roof rack, this is the tool you need.
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-11-06 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
In stark contrast to the mechanical clamping action of the LuBanSir, the GENERIC Two Keys that addresses the vulnerability of lost or broken access points. These are replacement keys specifically cut to fit Thule Car Top Storage, Roof Top Carriers, Luggage systems, Ski Racks, and Bike Racks. The specification highlights that they are cut by a professional locksmith with decades of experience, ensuring the internal tumblers align correctly with the lock mechanism. This means you do not have to send anything away for cutting or hope a generic key works; they arrive pre-cut and ready to work in your lock immediately.
The item details indicate a compact design, weighing just over four ounces and measuring roughly half an inch in width. This portability is crucial because these keys are meant to be kept as spares, perhaps in a glove box or a hidden compartment inside the vehicle. Having two keys provides redundancy; if one gets lost or damaged while you are on the road, the second one ensures you can still access your roof storage. This is a common scenario for families on long trips where gear is constantly being loaded and unloaded.
This product is exclusively for those who already own a Thule-compatible locking system. It offers no utility for opening doors, starting engines, or holding other types of equipment. The value here lies entirely in peace of mind regarding security and access. If you rely on a roof carrier for your camping gear or sports equipment, losing the key is a nightmare that requires expensive locksmith services or drilling out the lock. Buying this pair beforehand is a low-cost insurance policy against that specific failure point. It is not a general-purpose tool but a specialized component for a specific brand of roof rack hardware.
• Best for securing loose gear → LuBanSir 4, due to its Y-shaped bundling and non-slip straps.
• Best for emergency lock access → GENERIC Two Keys that, as they are pre-cut for Thule locks.
• Best for tool-free installation → LuBanSir 4, requiring only hand pressure to close the hook and loop.
• Best for immediate usability → GENERIC Two Keys that, arriving ready to insert into the lock without modification.
• Best for varying tool sizes → LuBanSir 4, with an adjustable range from 0.86" to 2" in diameter.
• Best for peace of mind → GENERIC Two Keys that, providing a dedicated backup for high-value roof carriers.
• Best for rough terrain → LuBanSir 4, designed with non-slip surfaces to prevent gear loss during bumps.
• Best for compact storage → GENERIC Two Keys that, fitting easily into a pocket or console due to small dimensions.
I would buy the LuBanSir 4 for my family road trips because the ability to securely bundle and strap down shovels and poles prevents dangerous shifts in weight and noise on the highway. While the GENERIC keys are a smart backup for a specific lock type, they serve a niche problem that most travelers rarely encounter compared to the daily frustration of loose gear. Securing your equipment physically is the first line of defense on a trip, making the LuBanSir 4 the more impactful purchase for general preparation. Both have their place, but for active travel, the LuBanSir 4 solves the more frequent headache.
The LuBanSir 4 is designed to fit various vehicles including ATVs, UTVs, RVs, SUVs, trucks, and trailers, provided the mounting bars accommodate the 12-inch strap length and the items fall within the 0.86 to 2-inch diameter range.
No, the GENERIC Two Keys that arrive pre-cut by a professional locksmith and are ready to work in your Thule-compatible lock immediately without any additional modifications.
Since the pack contains two keys, losing one still leaves you with a functional backup to operate your lock, ensuring you can still access your roof carrier or ski rack.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.