Is Socionics One of The Keys to the Great Mystery of the Human Psyche?
An Interview with Nikolai Nikolaevich Medvedev
An Interview with Nikolai Nikolaevich Medvedev
Author: Nikolai Medvedev and Grigory Shulman.
Citation: Nikolai Medvedev and Grigory Shulman. Is Socionics One of The Keys to the Great Mystery of the Human Psyche? In Psychological Essays: Works from 1985–1987, 12–21. Moscow: Chyornaya Belka, 2012.
Nikolai Nikolaevich Medvedev — One of the first and closest students and colleagues of [Aušra] "Augusta" Augustinavičiūtė, the founder of Socionics. He served as a deputy to the Supreme Soviet of the USSR and as a member of the Lithuanian Parliament for four terms. One of his well-known Socionics works is Medvedev’s Building Blocks (essentially, the first application of Jung-Augustinavičiūtė’s psychological functions to real-life situations) and the Psychological Essays in which they are described, being "published" in digital and typewritten copies in 1987.
Grigory Alexandrovich Shulman — Doctor of Philosophy, laureate of the USSR State Prize in Science and Technology, Deputy Director of the International Institute of Socionics, and Deputy Editor-in-Chief of the journal Socionics, Mentology, and Personality Psychology.
Shulman. Nikolai Nikolaevich! You were there at the very beginnings of Aušra Augustinavičiūtė’s Socionics. We met in 1987 at the First—still unofficial—School of Socionics, which Austra Augustinavičiūtė held at her dacha.* At that time, we shared with each other our research in Socionics. Now there is an opportunity to publish your Psychological Essays as a separate book. But the current generation of Socionics practitioners knows practically nothing about you. Therefore, the management of the “Black Squirrel” [Чёрная белка] Publishing Group, which is preparing your book for publication, asked me to have a conversation with you, and I thank you for agreeing to this interview.
*Translator's note: A dacha is a type of seasonal or secondary house common in post-Soviet countries.
I’ll probably ask you several questions at once—after all, it’s easier for intuitives to answer a series of questions.
So, what can you tell us about the history of the emergence—the birth—of Socionics? About yourself—how (and/or why) you came to Socionics, how it helped your work in the Lithuanian Seimas [Parliament] (and before that, at the KNIIRIT* and in the Supreme Soviet of the USSR). And surely, even before the “Memorandum,” you knew Vitas Laškovičius well—after all, he’s from Kaunas too!
*Translator's note: The letters, in Russian, stand for the Kaluga Scientific Research Radio Engineering Institute.
Medvedev. I found the answer to your first question in my personal file as a naval officer, to which I gained access after the collapse of the USSR. In the sections I filled out, it read: “He has an anarchic character and no inclination toward obedience. Prone to revisionism...”
Right on the money!
Even in my youth, I viewed the laws of gravity, the second law of thermodynamics, and the laws of physics on par with the laws devised by rulers to restrict individual freedom—as a personal insult! Strangely enough, I treated the laws of harmony, morality, ethics, and aesthetics with respect. At first, I thought these character traits were due to a Greek mix of Russian, Greek, and Irish blood (from the Melvedevs, Orlovs, Varikopulos, and O’Murray families).
Shulman. And you were absolutely right: the more “mixed” a person’s heritage is, the more extraordinary they are! Especially Ireland! And even more so with such a wide range—from Ireland to Greece!
Medvedev. I was also always fascinated by the mysteries of the universe, human nature, life, and death. The information provided by textbooks and reference books didn’t satisfy me. There were too many gaps, far-fetched ideas, and unquestioned assumptions. What is life, and what is a living being? What is the mind? How did all these stars, planets, atoms, and electrons know how to behave when they first came into existence? Why are people so different?
I always suspected that behind all this lay some universal laws that needed to be uncovered. That these laws describe not just individual things, but everything: both the living and non-living worlds, the entire universe. That there would be exceptions to these laws, the description of which would open up new horizons for people, and that people would become better and better through this knowledge.
Everything began to unfold and unravel (or become more tangled) many years later, when my friend and “mailbox” colleague from the defense industry—the eternal ringleader and head of an informal group of curious minds, Vitas Laškovičius, who used to drag us to all sorts of strange events and lectures—suddenly declared: “Let’s go to Aušra Augustinavičiūtė’s lectures! She’s the smartest woman around! There you’ll understand why we’re the way we are.” That was in 1982.
By that time, I had already—both on my own initiative and partly as part of my work—delved into Chinese, Tibetan, and Indian medicine and, consequently, philosophy. We were working on developing electronic equipment for acultural diagnosis and therapy, as well as systems for monitoring both sick and healthy patients.
During the lecture, I was struck by Aušra’s descriptions of one particular psychological type. How did she know everything about my character and lifestyle?! I asked Aušra this question during the break. In response, she announced loudly, “Meet another textbook example of a ‘Don Quixote.’ [ILE] I spotted him during the lecture on type-related reactions.” And who brought you to the lecture? Vitas Laškovičius? Of course! He’s your activator! [ESE] And the calm, round-faced lady with the warm smile? Is she part of your group? She’s ‘Dumas,’ [SEI] the complement to ‘Don Quixote.’ [ILE] Almost a quadra! That’s how Socionics works!”
That won me over! I became an active follower, student, and… heretic of Aušra’s—which, by the way, she had foreseen; she criticized my “heresies” but did not condemn me.
Shulman. And what exactly was your “heresy”?
Medvedev. I wanted to… No, rather, I was seized by the desire to “tie” Socionics to the principles governing the structure of the universe. That was the “heresy.” That’s how the “Essays” came to be. While writing them, I “stumbled upon” a number of propositions that, in the opinion of Socionics adherents, were controversial—perhaps “purely made up”—but nonetheless very interesting.
Shulman. Excuse me, who do you mean when you speak of Socionics adherents? After all, for us—the so-called “second wave” of Socionics—the adherents of Socionics are precisely you, Vitas [Laškovičius], and [Grigory] Reinin. And besides, we know absolutely nothing about… the “latent” (or purely Lithuanian) period of Socionics…
Medvedev. Adherents? Is it, first and foremost, Aušra herself, Vitas Laškovičius, and Živilė? My wife is also a follower and admirer of Aušra, although Natasha* is her Socionic conflictor type (“Dreiser” [ESI]). She’s my harshest critic. By the way, she can determine a person’s socionic type almost flawlessly, “by eye.”
*Note from Shulman: This was Medvedev's wife.
Shulman. There’s nothing surprising about that, since the ability of ESI-type individuals (“Dreisers”) to determine a person’s TIM almost instantly has long been a socionic postulate.
Medvedev. Indeed, that’s interesting! And as for the latent period… Here, in our country, Aušra’s work was met by psychologists not so much with hostility as with ridicule and mockery. And this, in my opinion, continues to this day—“No one is a prophet in their own land”! It was received much better by “techies,” especially radio engineers and computer scientists…
Shulman. Well, I’m an engineer by training, too! A mechanical engineer, to be sure. But at the Kyiv school there are physicists and electronics engineers as well. After all, Dushr’s approach is, first and foremost, a MODEL—a purely engineering perspective! From an “economist by training and a psychologist by the grace of God,” as you write in your “Essays”! Now that’s interesting! Brilliant and talented people are never talented in just one thing!
Medvedev. Yes. So here are these principles:
If you don’t understand the workings of the universe, look for the answer in human beings, including yourself. If you don’t understand the workings of human beings, including yourself, look for the answer in the universe.
The principle of the pentagram, upon which Chinese medicine is based, is the principle of a pyramid with five vertices, the topmost of which corresponds to the upper element of the pentagram; above it lies the invisible sixth element—the element of transition to structures of a higher hierarchy. This is how the parts of the human body and organs are arranged; this is how the world is arranged.
There is a profound meaning contained within “Platonic solids". This is how the Earth is structured (a dodecahedron). This is how living matter develops.
The “Yin-Yang” symbol must be supplemented. The circles located within the yang symbol (black, yin) and the yin symbol (white, yang) are not monochromatic; rather, they are smaller versions of the yang and yin symbols, which in turn contain even smaller symbols, and so on—ad infinitum in both directions. These are symbols of cosmogony, of all living things, and of humanity.
The two aspects of intuition are the two aspects of time, reflected in human consciousness. The aspects of logic are reflections of the aspects of matter; the same applies to space, and health is a state of inner space. The aspects of ethics are reflections of the aspects of energy. All thinking is based on processing information about these four realities of our three-dimensional world, in which the fourth dimension is time. There you have the four elements of the pentagram, in which the fifth element is information. This element is thought, the word, the logos—the element of transition to connection with higher hierarchies, speech leading to collective thinking.
The Quadra—the four elements of the pentagram. The fifth element is thought. The Logos of the Quadra, etc., etc.
To better understand a person and “bring Socionics closer to the truth,” one must consider the person in their psychophysical unity, rather than separately examining the psyche and the physical constitution—that is, the structure of the body. Then we will surely notice the mutual influence and mutual correction between body and spirit! It is also necessary to take past illnesses into account. And we must not forget about possible exceptions!
All of this still needed to be “untangled” and brought into a digestible form, but… new, turbulent times were approaching. My service on a minesweeper, my work in the “mailbox,” my fascination with Eastern philosophy, and my interest in Socionics were now seen as lessons leading up to a final exam. Cataclysms lay ahead. “Blessed is he who visited this world in its fateful moments”…
Working in the defense industry gave me access to all kinds of information. Analyzing this information led me to the conclusion: the days of the USSR, which possessed nuclear, chemical, and bacteriological weapons, were numbered! Having been born and lived most of my life in Lithuania, I clearly understood that there was no such thing as “friendship among peoples.” The economy, which for some reason was called “socialist,” was inefficient. There was only one conclusion: I had to get involved in politics to do everything possible to ensure that the nuclear-chemical complex—composed of peoples ready to tear each other’s throats out—would not collapse but would be gently dismantled. I didn’t think I was taking on too much; I simply wanted to face the heavens with a clear conscience. “Do what you can!”
In the fall of 1988, the entire team of “the curious ones" youth joined Sąjūdis—the Lithuanian version of the Popular Front*.
*Translator's note: An organized coalition of individuals generally advocating for reform in Russia during perestroika.
Shulman. Could you tell us a little more about this team, please?
N.M. “Team L”—that’s what we jokingly called ourselves. It was a team of inquisitive, curious, and, moreover, courageous people from Kaunas, with V. Lyskavičius serving as its driving force and guiding spirit.
Somehow I became part of the leadership circle of Sajudis, and “Team L” became the election campaign team. Even though the Medvedev surname might not have inspired confidence in Lithuania, I was elected to the Supreme Soviet of the USSR (in 1989) and then served four terms (1990–1992, 1992–1996, 1996–2000, 2000–2004) in the Lithuanian Parliament without any problems.
Shulman. Don’t you think that your command of the Lithuanian language—which you speak fluently—contributed significantly to this? I think this fact completely offset any potential distrust toward your surname that you mentioned: I know very well how gratefully people in the Baltic states appreciate such attention to them and to their language!
Medvedev. Yes, I do indeed speak Lithuanian almost perfectly, and I have a good command of Polish and Ukrainian as well. But I also have a deep understanding of the true history of Lithuania and the USSR, and I wasn’t afraid to speak openly about all of this. I delved into the most sensitive areas: military units, defense plants, and even the staff of the Kaunas branch of G.B* I was often called “a remnant of the unvanquished White Guard scum”; they promised that after victory, they wouldn’t send me to Siberia but would shoot me in Kaunas... I suppose I was lucky that times had already changed—as a contributor to the press and editor of the Russian-language edition of Kauno Aidas (Echo of Kaunas), I had “made a name for myself” abroad, including on Radio Liberty. But I didn’t know that—I just “charged ahead like a tank”: “There’s no wandering in the fire”…
*Translator's note: Stands for Государственная безопасность ("State Security")
My experience with Socionics proved very useful in the Seimas. [Lithuanian Parliament] It allowed me to argue (or rather, engage in dialogue), persuade, and prevent tensions from escalating between people without provoking conflicts. Now I’m convinced that mastery of Socionics, yoga practices, or any knowledge at all—helps, but only as long as you don’t set out to use it to cause harm or gain personal advantage. It can temporarily aid in underhandedness, but then you’ll have to pay a terrible price for it!
...The news of Vitas Lyškavičius’s death came as a sudden shock. We had no idea that our tireless generator of ideas—the creator of the tables of introverted relationships that made Socionics “tangible,” the man who knew how to calm, reconcile, and lead others to new horizons—had a heart condition! He never complained about anything! Ahead of him was the integration of Socionics with astrology; he told me about it and urged me to join these “investigations.” I refused, since I had zero knowledge in this field, lacked the time, and my amateurism could only discredit astrology (which already suffers from an overabundance of amateurs).
And then suddenly… in the spring of 1994, Vitulsa was gone! The study group stopped meeting. Without a driving force or new input, I lost interest in continuing the work, and besides, I was seriously busy in the Seimas.
Shulman. At the Poltava seminar on Socionics on April 19–20, 1988, I argued in my presentation that two Socionics conflictors, each with its own duals (I called such groups “quasi-quadras,” since they contain two dual pairs, but from different quadras. And in this case, we were talking about a conflictual quasi-quadras), could successfully solve the task set before them. Now this has become part of the ABCs of Socionics, but back then this assertion caused nothing short of outrage (in particular, among Aušra—even on the train from Kyiv—someone had “reported” my conclusions to her), since Aušra was convinced that no joint activity was possible in the context of a Socionics conflict.
And during my presentation, you gave me such strong support by sharing how you’d conducted exactly this kind of experiment in real life—at KNIPIT (the design team and the device’s housing). Perhaps you could tell us about that experiment?
Medvedev. You see, I always took Shulman’s quasi-types for granted. An unadapted—that is, unprotected—person is angry and aggressive. But with a dual, they’re protected. Even more protected—in a quadra. And fully protected—in a Socion! At the same time, we want intellectual parity! I actually conducted such an experiment: I asked conflicting pairs of duals to optimally assemble a device. The result was “excellent,” which I had absolutely no doubt about.
Shulman. During the time of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR—when you were a deputy to the Supreme Soviet—you showed me in Moscow some rough drafts of descriptions of Socionic types. True, it was only one quadra. Were you able to complete this work?
Medvedev. Yes, there were descriptions of 16 types based on the 8-channel [function] model...
The fact is that—with varying degrees of effectiveness depending on the type—all eight channels operate simultaneously for both reception and transmission, and information processing occurs simultaneously in all eight cells of this “miracle computer.” At the same time, all channels interact, drawing on experience, skills, and patterns of thought and behavior that are genetically encoded and accumulated through communication.
Here I “got stuck” on the eternal question of the determinism of behavior and the notorious “freedom of choice”: the supercomputer turned out to have no freedom of choice! It needed a channel of communication—sometimes with the Higher, sometimes with the Lower... “Something” that was neither a human nor a type. Here, the danger of the emergence (or “manifestation”) of mystical elements was already beginning to loom. This was already material for the third book of my Psychological Essays, which vanished along with the second book— Types —into the crucible of perestroika and the ensuing revolution. This happened during the “struggle against the past” in 1991 or 1992, when my institute was ransacked by Red Guards, even though formally “everything was legal”: patriots were fighting against the Soviet past; after all, our research institute was completely unnecessary for the new Lithuania and the nascent “wild capitalism.” And my manuscripts disappeared… They contained an analysis of hundreds of questionnaires filled out by people whose types had been determined through cross-validation. The plan was to examine “the operation and interaction of eight-channel, super-complex, self-learning, and self-improving biocomputers of 16 types.”
Back home in Kaunas, I still have some rough drafts left… I’m trying to reconstruct them. It’s very difficult: after all, those materials—I’ll say it again—contained the results of analyzing the “memoirs” of hundreds (!) of self-descriptions written by the types themselves! Whereas here, I have only my own speculations.
But I’ll keep trying.
Shulman. I can only hope that you succeed! After all, to this day, the most “pressing” problem in Socionics is the problem of correctly determining a person’s type. And well-crafted—so to speak—descriptions of the types will also contribute to its solution.
Medvedev. Yes, but over the years of practical application of Socionics, I’ve come to understand one more thing: Socionics is a dangerous tool of psychology. This is due to its apparent accessibility, which is bound to lead to its use by adventurers, amateurs, fanatics, and those “obsessed” with Socionics. They’ll “stir up trouble,” disrupt people’s lives, and create unviable families. And the founders of Socionics will be held accountable to people and the Supreme Intelligence! Yet working with the principles of Socionics is not a craft, but an art (just like medicine and teaching)!
I’ll never forget the words of a remarkable psychotherapist. When I asked him whether his daughter, with such a teacher, would go further than her father, he replied: “No, actually. She’s crazy about money!”
I recall two other interesting incidents as well. Back when I was still working at the “mailbox,” I was once invited to the 1st Department, where I met a man who was very, very pleasant in every way. He paid several compliments to the “mailbox,” its staff, and me, saying that it was good that, in addition to our selfless work, we found time for a hobby directly related to our main job. After all, based on the data from this hobby, one can create exceptionally capable teams—or dismantle teams engaged in “the wrong things”—without any violence. Isn’t that right? Here, cooperation will open up extraordinary prospects and opportunities.
I replied that human beings turned out to be too complex a system—beyond our capabilities—that we had become completely confused and had evidently taken the path of mysticism rather than science… We never met again.
Later, when I was a deputy to the Supreme Soviet of the USSR and a member of the then-famous International Movement for Democracy, led by Boris Yeltsin, Andrei Sakharov, and Gavriil Popov Popov, a correspondent from some “very foreign” newspaper approached me with similar questions—offering to collaborate and publish my work somewhere far away. I replied in much the same way as I had the first time.
Perhaps I’m suspicious and overly cautious? Perhaps I’m overestimating my role in this matter? It’s quite possible! But during my time as a naval officer, I was fortunate enough to serve on a minesweeper. A certain instinct for detecting mines has stayed with me for life. My colleagues on the National Security Committee in the Lithuanian Parliament have seen this for themselves more than once.
I believe that humanity must mature morally before it can apply inventions and discoveries, both large and small. This is a precautionary measure against the need for “vaccinations” of the Hiroshima and Cheronobyl variety. By the way, I also view the 1917 Revolution as a “vaccination.” The price of such “vaccinations” is millions of people who suffered and died. The effect is the salvation of humanity from even more terrible catastrophes. That’s how it is...
Shulman. Well then, thanks again!
I’d just like to add that while you—for 15(!) years—were “shirking” your work in Socionics, we, too, managed to understand a few things, and much of it lost its mystical aura and became realities of life that we have to reckon with and find ways to interact with. But that’s already beyond the scope of this interview. I think that after this is published, many will eagerly await the release of the second—and especially the third—part of your Psychological Essays.
Wishing you good health, success, and—a little bit of luck!
***
A few words for the readers—beyond the scope of the interview.
It seems to me that an excerpt from a letter by Nikolai Nikolaevich (personal correspondence) can provide a vivid impression of this remarkable man, his tireless energy, and his undimmed youth:
“I’ve carefully reviewed your book. It’s very interesting, but my goodness! How complicated everything has become. But then I immediately recalled a thought that once crossed my mind—behind simplicity lies the most fascinating complexity, and behind that, beautiful simplicity, and then it all starts over again. So, there was a simple world; then it seemed very complex to our ancestors, until Democritus showed that everything consists simply of atoms (a nucleus, with electrons around it); then it turned out that everything there is very complex—an infinite mass of particles, and so on; and then the idea emerged—and has now practically taken hold—that everything is merely vibrations, as was written about as far back as the Upanishads and the Vedas. Of course, I’ve laid all this out in a simplistic way, but it seems that’s how it is. And then it’s back to some kind of chaos again… You can find the idea that everything is one in the same places. Man, those Hindus really had some brilliant minds!”