How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Kitchen Curated Square Air Fryer — biggest strength: a 2-piece set of rigid 2.63mm platinum silicone liners (LFGB certified, BPA-free) rated from -40F to 446F, with raised bottom ridges that lift food off the surface so grease drains and air circulates.
• Kitchen Curated Square Air Fryer — biggest trade-off: it is sized specifically for 5QT square baskets (Ninja AF141/AF142/AF181/AF182, Cosori CAF-L501), so it does not fit larger Cosori 5.8QT/6QT baskets, and as a solid liner it shields the airflow directly beneath your food.
• GXF Air Fryer Accessories — biggest strength: a steel, non-stick replacement crisper plate built for the Chefman 8QT TurboFry 4-in-1 (RJ38-SQSS-8T / RJ38-SQSS-8TAM), with a vortex airflow design, a center handle, and four rubber bumpers to protect the basket walls.
• GXF Air Fryer Accessories — biggest trade-off: it is a single replacement part for one narrow family of Chefman models, so if your air fryer is not on that list it simply will not fit.
• Who each is for: Kitchen Curated is for owners of compatible 5QT Ninja or Cosori square baskets who want less cleanup and reusable liners; GXF is for Chefman 8QT TurboFry 4-in-1 owners who need a working crisper plate or a spare.
The Kitchen Curated Square Air Fryer is not an appliance. It is a 2-piece set of square silicone liners designed to drop into the basket of a 5QT square air fryer. The pitch is simple: you cook in the liner, the liner catches the mess, and your basket stays clean. The 2.63mm thickness matters here, because it means the walls stand rigidly upright instead of flopping over onto your food the way thin parchment does.
The details that stand out to me are practical ones. The liners are rated from -40F to 446F, so they move between the air fryer, oven, microwave and steamer without a second thought. They are 100% platinum silicone, LFGB certified, BPA-free, and described as flavorless and odorless with no fillers. Raised ridges on the bottom lift food slightly so hot air can move underneath and grease can drain away. Cleanup is a wipe or a dishwasher cycle.
Sizing is where you need to pay attention. The liner measures 8.1 x 8.1 inches across the top and 2.75 inches deep, and Kitchen Curated lists it for the Ninja AF141, AF142, AF181 and AF182 plus the Cosori CAF-L501 (5QT). It does not fit the larger Cosori 5.8QT or 6QT baskets, and the product notes specifically call out incompatibility with the Cosori CAF-DC601 and the Instant Vortex Plus 6QT. Measure your basket before ordering.
GXF Air Fryer Accessories: Who It's For
The GXF Air Fryer Accessories is a replacement part, not a liner. Specifically, it is a steel crisper plate with a non-stick coating, built as a direct replacement tray for the Chefman 8QT TurboFry 4-in-1 Air Fryer, models RJ38-SQSS-8T and RJ38-SQSS-8TAM. It measures 9.6 x 9.8 inches and ships with four rubber bumpers.
The design is straightforward and thoughtful in a repair-part way. There is a handle in the middle, so you can lift the hot plate out of the basket without fishing around with tongs. The surface uses a vortex airflow pattern intended to heat food more evenly. The four rubber bumpers sit along the four side edges rather than the rounded corners, and their job is to keep the plate from scratching the inner wall of your fryer. The material is food-grade steel with a non-stick coating, BPA-free and non-toxic, made to meet FDA standards. It is dishwasher safe, though GXF warns against abrasive cloths or metal scrubbers, which would chew up the coating.
The compatibility list is the whole story here, and it is narrow. GXF states this plate is not compatible with the Chefman Easy View Air Fryer 8QT (RJ38-SQSS-8TW, RJ38-WD-8T, RJ38-SQPF-8T) and does not fit the Chefman Crispinator 8QT. It also notes the plate is larger than what the GAF856 model takes. In the box you get one grill plate and four bumpers.
Who should buy it? Chefman 8QT TurboFry 4-in-1 owners whose original crisper plate has worn out, lost its coating, or gone missing, and anyone who wants a spare so they are not stuck mid-cook. It handles the usual lineup well: barbecue, steak, vegetables, fish, fries, pizza, chicken wings. Who should skip it? Everyone else. If your air fryer is not one of the two listed Chefman models, this plate will not fit, and no amount of enthusiasm will change that. Measure your basket and check your model number first.
• Best for keeping the basket clean → Kitchen Curated Square Air Fryer. Deep walls contain marinades, sauces and grease so the basket itself stays largely untouched.
• Best for replacing a worn or missing part → GXF Air Fryer Accessories. It is a direct-fit crisper plate, not an add-on.
• Best for saucy, sticky, baked meals → Kitchen Curated Square Air Fryer. This is exactly the use case the liner is designed around.
• Best for crisp, even browning on a Chefman → GXF Air Fryer Accessories. The vortex airflow design and steel surface are built to move hot air around food, not block it.
• Best for maximum crisp in a Ninja or Cosori 5QT → neither, honestly. Use the bare basket, or flip food halfway with the Kitchen Curated liner in place.
• Best for heat range flexibility → Kitchen Curated Square Air Fryer. Rated -40F to 446F across air fryer, oven, microwave and steamer.
• Best for dishwasher convenience → both. Kitchen Curated is dishwasher safe; so is the GXF plate, as long as you skip abrasive scrubbers.
• Best for gifting → Kitchen Curated Square Air Fryer. Two reusable liners in plastic-free recyclable packaging suit anyone who air-fries often.
If I were buying for myself, I would pick the Kitchen Curated Square Air Fryer — but only if I owned one of the compatible Ninja or Cosori 5QT square baskets. In my opinion, a reusable liner that survives years and keeps a $150 appliance's basket clean is the more broadly useful purchase, and the honest airflow caveat is one I can plan around by flipping food or going bare-basket for fries. I would choose the GXF Air Fryer Accessories only if I owned a Chefman 8QT TurboFry 4-in-1 and needed a functioning crisper plate. That is a replacement decision, not a preference one. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever fits your machine, and measure your basket first.
FAQ
Yes, in my view, if your basket matches. Parchment is single-use; this is a 2-piece reusable set at 2.63mm thick, rated -40F to 446F and dishwasher safe. You stop rebuying parchment, and the rigid walls do not collapse onto your food.
It depends on which one. The GXF plate is a crisper plate designed for airflow, so it should help browning. The Kitchen Curated liner is a solid silicone wall, and Kitchen Curated notes it shields airflow beneath food. For ultra-crispy fries, flip halfway or use the bare basket.
Both are dishwasher safe. Kitchen Curated wipes clean or goes in the dishwasher, and its deep walls mean less scrubbing of the basket itself. The GXF plate is dishwasher safe too, but GXF warns against abrasive cloths or metal balls that would damage the non-stick coating.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GXF Air Fryer Accessories vs GWY Air Fryer Grill: Is Air, EKRHORBY 9PCS vs Fastand 130PCs: Air Fryer Accessories, GXF Air Fryer Grill vs HQT Air Fryer Crisping: Air Fryer