Noah Lovely - June 2nd, 2026
The kickers currently on the roster for the Jets do not inspire much confidence in the team, Younghoe Koo and Cade York have surely struggled in the past but I've mentioned before on this site that we didn't have Harrison Mevis or Nick Folk, who together missed 2 total field goals, on our roster at this time last year.
The front office doesn't seem to mind shuffling through kickers until we find the right guy through trial and error and I think it's fair that we can expect them to after how dominant our special teams were last year. That being said there are currently 11 teams with multiple kickers on their roster, including the Jets and as the UFL season winds down, more kickers from there will be available as well. Here are some teams and specific players to watch as the offseason unfolds.
The Raiders have 2 kickers battling and I would certainly not mind the Jets taking the consolation prize between the two. Matt Gay started his season with the Commanders and had only missed one field goal from under 50 yards last season, but struggled heavily hitting anything further going 4/9 (44%) from beyond 50 yards. He looked much better in his two games with San Francisco but they simply didn't try to make him kick from 50+ yards
Kansei Matsuzawa is a 27 year old rookie kicker out of Hawaii who potentially has similar issues as Matt Gay. He has only missed one extra point through his 5 year college career, but his Field Goal % didn't look great until his 2025-26 season at Hawaii. Matsuzawa only started 3 years in college, once at Hocking College (a Junior College in Southeast Ohio) where he hit 70.6% of his field goals, did not play the next year when he transferred to Hawaii, then in his next two years hit 75% then 93.1% of his field goals. Whether his senior season was a fluke or not is something I am very interested to see, but he also only had 1 field goal recorded over 50 yards out of two attempts.
Assuming Matt Gay and Matsuzawa play through camp how they played in their most recent seasons, the decision could simply come if the Raiders want Experience or Youth. As their power and accuracy are fairly similar, I would be fine with either on the Jets as well.
Matt Gay isn't the only kicker to play for the Niners and Commanders in 2025 on my list. Commanders roster has Jake Moody who essentially swapped teams with Matt Gay, and rookie Drew Stevens out of Iowa.
Jake Moody was great for the Commanders last year, but his season started off rocky. Coming off a dissapointing 2024 with San Francisco, Moody missed 2 kicks in the season opener, causing him to be waived before being picked up by the Bears to give Cairos Santos some competition. He played great throughout two games only missing one field goal, but it wasn't enought to not be relegated back to the practice squad for a month before the Commanders picked him up. In Washington he missed 1 extra point and 1 field goal through 6 games, hitting both attempts from 50+ yards (his only attempts from this distance all season).
Drew Stevens has also struggled to find consistency, he had 2 seasons where he hit more than 85% of his field goals, but both were followed by seasons where he hit less than 80%. Although the 78.6% last year is much better than the 69.2% he had his sophomore season. He also has plenty of power in his leg at only 22 years old, hitting 4 from 50+ yards last year with his longest being 58 yards.
This seems to be a similar situation to the Raiders but much younger, Jake Moody is younger than the rookie Matsuzawa even, but both kickers have the same issues just inverted from the Raiders, power kickers without much accuracy, but these guys have much more room for improvement with how young they are and are certainly worth looking at.
Currently the best kicker in the UFL, Tanner Brown has made 25/28 field goals (89%) with his longest kick going for 60 yards. He will certainly be a big target for GMs around the league when the season concludes so hopefully the Jets can make an appealing enough offer.
Another option could be John Hoyland, who went 18/22 (82%) and had a longest kick of 59 yards. A smaller sample size than Brown with one more missed kick and similar power suggests he is a little less accurate but he's also about 3 years younger than Brown and could become more accurate over time.