If you want a direct replacement for your Silverado or Sierra's undercarriage hoist system without the frustration of factory latches getting stuck, choose JDMSPEED Spare Tire Winch; if you need a heavy-duty, vibration-resistant carrier to mount a spare tire on a utility or boat trailer, choose Joroamp Spare Tire Mount.
These two products solve completely different problems in the automotive world. One is an internal mechanical fix for a specific truck lineage, while the other is an external mounting solution for hauling equipment. Trying to use one where the other belongs will lead to immediate failure or safety hazards. The JDMSPEED unit is engineered to restore function to a vehicle that has already lost its ability to lower a tire safely, whereas the Joroamp unit creates a new storage location for tires on trailers that lack proper retention systems.
• JDMSPEED Spare Tire Winch: Its biggest strength is the updated design that eliminates the secondary safety latch prone to rust and jamming; the trade-off is it is strictly limited to specific GM trucks like the Silverado and Sierra 1500/2500. This pick is for owners of those specific vehicles who need a reliable, plug-and-play repair.
• This pick is for anyone with a utility, boat, or cargo trailer needing a secure way to carry a spare wheel.
The JDMSPEED Spare Tire Winch is designed specifically as a functional restoration part for General Motors trucks. If you drive a Silverado or GMC Sierra 1500 or 2500, this component is intended to replace the original hoist mechanism located underneath the rear of your vehicle. The primary issue it addresses is the common failure point found in the factory parts: the secondary safety latch or lock. Over time, exposure to mud, road salt, and water causes these latches to corrode and stick, leaving drivers unable to lower their spare tire when they actually need it.
This product stands out because it features an updated design that removes that problematic secondary latch entirely. By doing so, it simplifies the mechanism and removes the most common cause of failure. It is tested before shipping to ensure it functions correctly right out of the box. The installation process is described as "plug and play," meaning it replaces the exact part numbers listed in the documentation, such as 924-510, 20870067, and 15703311, without requiring custom fabrication or complex modifications.
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-11-07 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
You should buy this unit if you are tired of fighting with a stuck tire hoist on your truck. It is the ideal choice for someone who needs a direct, drop-in replacement that solves the specific mechanical flaw of the original equipment. However, you should skip this product if you do not own a compatible GM truck. It is not a universal winch, nor is it designed to hold a tire in a fixed position on a trailer or outside of a vehicle's chassis. If your truck model is not listed in the compatibility details, this part will not fit your vehicle at all.
In stark contrast to the JDMSPEED winch, the Joroamp Spare Tire Mount is built for the world of towing and hauling. It is a robust carrier designed to attach directly to the frame of a utility trailer, boat trailer, or cargo trailer. The core problem it solves is the instability of traditional tire mounts. Many standard trailer mounts rely on fewer fasteners or weaker designs that allow the spare tire to shake, rattle, and eventually loosen during transit. The Joroamp mount counters this with a specific three-nut design intended to better lock the tire in place.
The engineering here focuses heavily on durability and security. The construction utilizes sturdy welded reinforced zinc-plated steel, which provides resistance against rust and corrosion—a critical feature for anything exposed to the elements while being towed. The versatility is another key factor; it adapts to a wide range of bolt patterns, accommodating 4-lug, 5-lug, and 6-lug wheels with various hole diameters ranging from 4 inches to 5.5 inches.
This product is perfect for a rideshare driver who also uses a trailer for deliveries or a weekend warrior who hauls boats. If you find yourself constantly tightening loose bolts on your trailer's spare tire holder, this mount offers a more permanent solution. The package includes the necessary zinc-plated mounting hardware, so you do not have to source bolts separately. However, it is strictly a trailer accessory. It is not designed to be installed inside a vehicle's wheel well or used as a winch mechanism. If you are looking to replace a broken part on your personal sedan or truck, this item will not work for you.
• Best for restoring a stuck truck hoist → JDMSPEED Spare Tire Winch (Specifically for Silverado/Sierra models with failed latches).
• Best for securing a tire on a moving trailer → Joroamp Spare Tire Mount (Superior vibration control and load capacity).
• Best for universal lug pattern compatibility → Joroamp Spare Tire Mount (Fits 4, 5, and 6-lug setups from 4" to 5.5").
• Best for a direct factory-style fitment → JDMSPEED Spare Tire Winch (Matches specific GM part numbers exactly).
• Best for rust resistance on open frames → Joroamp Spare Tire Mount (Zinc-plated steel construction).
• Best for simple, no-drill installation → Both (JDMSPEED is plug-and-play for trucks; Joroamp is bolt-on for trailers).
• Best for eliminating factory defects → JDMSPEED Spare Tire Winch (Removes the secondary latch that causes jams).
I would choose the Joroamp Spare Tire Mount if I were buying for my utility trailer because the three-nut design offers peace of mind that standard mounts simply cannot match. However, for my daily driving vehicle, specifically a Silverado, I would immediately grab the JDMSPEED Spare Tire Winch because it fixes the dangerous situation of a tire that won't come down. For rideshare drivers who might need both a reliable daily truck and occasional hauling capability, owning the JDMSPEED winch ensures your daily transport is never stranded by a stuck spare tire, while the Joroamp mount handles the extra gear securely. In my opinion, neither product is superior in a vacuum; they are only superior to each other depending on whether you are fixing a truck or building a trailer setup.
No, the JDMSPEED Spare Tire Winch is designed exclusively for Chevrolet Silverado and GMC Sierra 1500 and 2500 models based on the listed part number replacements.
No, the JDMSPEED product is solely the hoist mechanism or winch carrier itself; it replaces the existing failing part on your vehicle and does not include a spare tire.
The Joroamp mount features a bolt-on design that typically requires no cutting or drilling, though you may need basic hand tools to tighten the included zinc-plated hardware.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.