How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want to keep the earpads on your studio over ear headphones clean and intact, choose Jarmor Earpads Sweater Cover; if you need a hard shell to carry and protect the whole headset — especially a Beats Studio Pro or a similar set you use for Xbox — choose Mchoi Headphone Case Fits. These two products sit at opposite ends of the headphone-care spectrum: one wraps the cushions, the other wraps everything. And if you're sorting out a setup for your console, whether it's an open ear headphones for xbox situation or a best bluetooth headset for xbox decision, knowing which of these actually solves your problem saves you from buying the wrong thing twice.
• Jarmor Earpads Sweater Cover — biggest strength: stretchable knit fabric covers that slip over 1.57–3.14 inch ear cushions to block dirt, sweat and scratching, with no tools required and two pairs in the pack.
• Jarmor Earpads Sweater Cover — biggest trade-off: it only protects the cushions. Your headband, hinges and drivers get nothing, and there's no storage or carry protection at all.
• Mchoi Headphone Case Fits — biggest strength: a hard EVA shell, waterproof and shockproof, with a 360-degree zipper, mesh accessory pocket, hand strap and carabiner for real travel protection.
• Mchoi Headphone Case Fits — biggest trade-off: it's an empty case only. It protects a headset you already own but improves nothing about how that headset sounds or feels.
• Who Jarmor is for: anyone whose pads wear out fast from sweat and daily contact — commuters, gym users, long-session gamers.
• Who Mchoi is for: anyone who throws a headset in a bag, travels, or wants a single tidy home for a Beats Studio Pro, Solo 4, Solo 3 or Studio 3.
The Jarmor Earpads Sweater Cover is a maintenance product, not an accessory you'll notice. Each cover is a stretchable knit sleeve that pulls over your existing ear cushions, sized for pads between 1.57 and 3.14 inches. That range covers the Beats Solo HD, Solo2 and Solo3, plus a long list of generic headsets with similar cushion diameters. You get two pairs in black, and installation needs no tools — you stretch, you tuck, you're done.
What it actually does well is address the most common failure point on any over-ear headphone: the pads. Cushions are the part that touches your skin, absorbs sweat, collects dust and slowly flakes apart. A knit cover takes that abuse instead. That means the underlying pad keeps its shape and surface longer, and the cover itself is hand washable when it gets grimy. For studio over ear headphones used in long mixing or gaming sessions, that's a genuinely practical upgrade — especially in summer, when foam pads turn into a sponge.
Who should buy it: people who already like their headset and just want the pads to last. Gamers who wear a set for hours, anyone who shares a headset, and Beats Solo owners who've watched a pair of pads degrade. Who should skip it: if you're looking for a carrying solution, drop protection, or anything that changes fit and feel dramatically, this isn't that. And if your cushions fall outside that 1.57–3.14 inch window, check your measurements first — knit fabric stretches, but it has limits.
The Mchoi Headphone Case Fits is the other half of the equation. This is a hard EVA shell measuring 6.8 x 4.9 x 3.5 inches, designed around a specific family of over-ear headphones: Beats Studio Pro, Beats Solo 4, Beats Solo 3, Beats Studio 3, and the TOZO HA1 and HT2 on-ear models. It's listed in pink here, with the case sold empty — the headset in any product imagery is illustrative only.
The build is the story. EVA foam gives you a shell that's waterproof and shockproof, which matters more than people think. A headset tossed loose in a backpack gets crushed by laptops, snagged on zippers and exposed to rain. This case closes that off with a smooth 360-degree zipper, and inside there's a mesh pocket for cables, dongles or a small adapter. Outside, a sturdy hand strap handles carrying, and a carabiner keychain lets you clip the whole thing to a purse, backpack or bag strap. It's also compact enough for tight spaces, which is the point of the 6.8 x 4.9 x 3.5 inch footprint.
Who should buy it: anyone whose headset leaves the house. Students, commuters, travelers, and console players who move a headset between rooms or take it to a friend's place. If you've ever pulled a headset out of a bag and found a cracked headband or a bent hinge, this is the fix. Who should skip it: if your headphones live permanently on a desk stand, a case adds nothing. And check compatibility — if your model isn't on that list, don't assume it fits.
• Best for protecting the ear cushions → Jarmor Earpads Sweater Cover. It's the only one of the two that touches the pads at all.
• Best for protecting the entire headset → Mchoi Headphone Case Fits. Hard EVA shell, waterproof, shockproof, zipped shut.
• Best for travel and commuting → Mchoi Headphone Case Fits. Hand strap, carabiner and a compact 6.8 x 4.9 x 3.5 inch body.
• Best for sweat and daily wear → Jarmor Earpads Sweater Cover. Knit covers take the contact damage and can be hand washed.
• Best for cable and accessory organization → Mchoi Headphone Case Fits. The built-in mesh pocket handles the small stuff.
• Best for Beats Solo 3 or Studio 3 owners → both, honestly. Jarmor covers the pads, Mchoi houses the headset — they don't compete, they stack.
• Best for a touch control headphone for xbox setup → Mchoi Headphone Case Fits. If you're carrying a headset to and from a console, the case protects the controls and hinges that a knit cover can't reach.
• Best if you only want one purchase → decide by your actual risk. Pads wearing out? Jarmor. Headset getting knocked around? Mchoi.
In my opinion, the honest answer is that these aren't rivals — they solve different problems, and the "versus" framing only matters because you probably only want to buy one thing today. If I had to pick a single product for a studio over ear headphones owner who uses a set for Xbox and moves it around, I'd buy the Mchoi Headphone Case Fits. A hard, waterproof, shockproof shell with a mesh pocket and carabiner protects the expensive part — the headset itself — and that's the failure you can't fix with a washable cover. The Jarmor Earpads Sweater Cover is the smarter buy only if your pads are your weak point and your headset never leaves your desk. Buy the case first; add the covers later.
The cushions should sit around your ears, not press on them — the pad seals against the side of your head. That contact is exactly where the Jarmor Earpads Sweater Cover sits, since it's sized for 1.57–3.14 inch cushions. A proper seal matters more than clamping force.
Drivers inside each cup convert electrical signal into sound, and the sealed cushion chamber shapes what you hear. Because the pads do the sealing, worn or dirty foam changes the sound — which is the practical argument for the Jarmor knit covers. The Mchoi case, by contrast, protects the housing when the set isn't in use.
That depends on what you need them for. Studio-style over-ear sets are built for accurate, comfortable long sessions, and if you're using one for Xbox or mixing, protecting it makes sense. That's where the Mchoi Headphone Case Fits comes in — a hard EVA shell, waterproof and shockproof, keeps a headset intact between sessions.
Studios lean on closed and open over-ear models with wide cushion diameters — the same 1.57–3.14 inch range the Jarmor Earpads Sweater Cover is built for. If you own one of those sets, the Mchoi case fits Beats Studio Pro, Solo 4, Solo 3, Studio 3 and TOZO HA1/HT2 models specifically.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: RORSOU R10 vs Nanddi Gaming Headset: Budget Headphones, YINPUTENGS Earbuds or YTHYTHYTH 5.0: which is better, RORSOU B10 vs ADOOPE Kids Headphones, Yamaha HPH-150B vs Yealink BH74: Flat Frequency Response