How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a complete wired gaming headset with a big-driver stereo sound and a mic you can twist off and toss in a bag, choose IO CREST GamesterGear PC PS4; if you need a cheap drop-in replacement boom mic to revive a broken or lost Turtle Beach headset, choose NewTH Replacement Game Microphone. That is the whole call in one line, and it holds whether you are gaming at a desk or hunting for the best with microphone true wireless earbuds for sleeping and other low-key listening setups.
• IO CREST GamesterGear PC PS4 — biggest strength: It is a full over-ear headset, not a part. 57mm dynamic drivers at 32 ohms, a detachable twist-lock boom mic, floating ear cups and a 3.5mm four-pole plug with an audio splitter included.
• IO CREST GamesterGear PC PS4 — biggest trade-off: It is wired only, plastic-bodied, and the mic is wired through the headset rather than a universal 2.5mm boom. If your headset is a Turtle Beach, this will not slot into it.
• NewTH Replacement Game Microphone — biggest strength: It is a direct 2.5mm replacement boom for a specific list of Turtle Beach Ear Force models, plug and play with no drivers or batteries, 6.5-inch cable, 360-degree bendable arm and noise-cancelling electret condenser cartridge.
• NewTH Replacement Game Microphone — biggest trade-off: It only works with the listed Turtle Beach headsets. If you do not own one of those, it is the wrong purchase entirely.
• Who each pick is for: IO CREST for someone buying one wired headset to cover PC, PS4, Xbox One, Mac, iPad and mobile; NewTH for someone who already owns a compatible Turtle Beach headset and just needs the mic back.
The IO CREST GamesterGear PC PS4 is the all-in-one option. It is a wired, over-ear stereo headset built around 57mm dynamic drivers running at 32 ohms with a 20Hz to 20KHz frequency range. In plain terms, that is a big driver for a gaming headset, and the design intent is clear from the spec sheet: the brand is chasing a wide, loud, gameplay-forward sound rather than a flat monitoring signature. The description frames it as a headset that adds definition to sounds and music and makes everything come to life, which lines up with the large-driver approach.
The feature I would actually point a buyer toward is the detachable microphone. The boom secures to the PC200-I with a twist lock, so it comes off and goes back on without tools. That single detail changes how the headset lives in your life. Unplug the mic and it becomes a plain pair of wired over-ear headphones for music, video, or a quiet late-night listen — the sort of thing people reach for when they want sleep headphones for sleeping rather than a headset bristling with a boom. Reattach it and you are back on voice chat.
Comfort is addressed through the floating ear cups, which are shaped to follow the angle and contour of your ears, and the build is ABS thermoplastic — the sheet specifically notes it survives being thrown in a backpack or dropped from a desk. Connectivity is a 3.5mm four-pole headset plug plus a 3.5mm audio splitter in the box, so you can run it off a single combined jack on a console or split it into separate headphone and mic jacks on a PC. It is listed for PC, PS4, Xbox One, iPad, mobile, tablet and Mac. There is a one-year warranty, and it weighs 16 ounces.
Who should buy it: someone who wants one wired headset that does gaming audio and voice chat, values a removable boom mic, and moves between a console, a PC and a tablet. Who should skip it: anyone who already owns a Turtle Beach headset and only needs a mic, anyone who wants wireless, and anyone who needs a mic that fits a headset other than this one.
The NewTH Replacement Game Microphone is a single-purpose part, and it is honest about that. It is a 2.5mm boom mic made to replace a broken or lost microphone on a specific set of Turtle Beach Ear Force headsets: PX4, PX5, PX51, XP300, XP400, XP500, XP510, X4, X41, X42, 500X and Z300. The sheet tells you plainly to check your headset model before ordering, and that is the most important sentence in the listing. Get the model right and this is a clean fix. Get it wrong and nothing about it will help you.
The mechanics are simple. Plug and play, no drivers, no batteries. The cable is 6.5 inches — the sheet describes it as exactly the right length to reach your mouth — and the arm bends a full 360 degrees and holds the position you set. Inside is an electret condenser cartridge with high sensitivity, low impedance and anti-noise, anti-jamming characteristics, with a unidirectional polar pattern. That unidirectional pickup is a real design choice: it favors the direction it is pointed, which is what you want from a boom mic sitting near your mouth.
The 2.5mm jack is gold-dipped and copper covered, the body is a mix of ABS plastic and silicone, and it ships with a foam cover plus an extra foam pop filter piece. The foam is dust resistant and the sheet notes it maintains audio quality while cutting unwanted noise. The mic measures 6.3 x 0.39 x 0.39 inches as a bare part, sits at 45 ohms impedance, and carries a two-year manufacturer warranty. It is listed as compatible with PS4, PS5, Xbox One, Xbox One S, Xbox One X, Series X, PC, phones, and anything else you can connect a 2.5mm headset to — but read that carefully. The compatibility is with the 2.5mm jack and the listed Turtle Beach headsets, not with every headset on earth.
Who should buy it: you own one of the listed Turtle Beach Ear Force headsets, the mic died or vanished, and the rest of the headset is fine. Who should skip it: everyone else. If your headset is not on that list, this is not your part.
• Best for a complete setup out of the box → IO CREST GamesterGear PC PS4. Headset, detachable mic and splitter cable in one purchase.
• Best for fixing a headset you already own → NewTH Replacement Game Microphone. It exists to replace one part, not to be a headset.
• Best for big-driver stereo sound → IO CREST GamesterGear PC PS4. 57mm dynamic drivers at 32 ohms across a 20Hz–20KHz range.
• Best for a directional, noise-cancelling voice pickup → NewTH Replacement Game Microphone. Unidirectional electret condenser with anti-noise and anti-jamming design.
• Best for long-session comfort → IO CREST GamesterGear PC PS4. Floating ear cups shaped to the angle of your ears, over-ear placement, 16-ounce build.
• Best for travel abuse → both, with an edge to IO CREST. The headset is ABS thermoplastic and built to survive a backpack or a desk drop; the NewTH part is ABS and silicone and small enough to disappear in a pocket.
• Best for console-to-PC flexibility → IO CREST GamesterGear PC PS4. 3.5mm four-pole plug plus the included audio splitter covers both single-jack and split-jack setups.
• Best for warranty length → NewTH Replacement Game Microphone. Two-year manufacturer warranty versus one year on the IO CREST.
In my opinion, the IO CREST GamesterGear PC PS4 is the one to buy for most people, because it solves the whole problem at once: audio, comfort, a twist-lock detachable mic, and a splitter cable so it works across PC, PS4, Xbox One, Mac and tablets. The NewTH Replacement Game Microphone is the smarter buy only if you already own one of the listed Turtle Beach Ear Force headsets and just need the boom back — and that is a genuinely useful, low-fuss fix for that exact situation. If you are weighing this for sleeping, low-volume listening or a budget pair of sleep headphones for sleeping, the IO CREST with the mic twisted off is the more versatile of the two, and it is the one I would put in a cart. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit, since that is the one thing this comparison deliberately leaves out.
are studio headphones better than gaming headsets
what headphones do pro gamers use
That varies by player and title, and the data sheets here do not name any sponsored or pro-used gear, so I will not invent one. What matters for competitive play is positional clarity and a reliable mic. On that front, the IO CREST's 57mm drivers and detachable twist-lock mic cover both needs, while the NewTH mic is a replacement part rather than a headset.
do all headphones have mics
No. Plenty of headphones are listen-only. The IO CREST GamesterGear PC PS4 ships with a detachable boom mic, so it doubles as a headset when attached and a plain pair of headphones when removed. The NewTH Replacement Game Microphone is only a mic — it has no drivers and cannot play audio on its own.
can studio headphones be used for gaming
Yes, they can. Any wired headphone with a compatible 3.5mm connection will play game audio, and the IO CREST uses a 3.5mm four-pole plug with an included audio splitter for PC or console. The catch is voice chat: a plain studio headphone has no mic, so you would need a separate one. A headset with a detachable mic sidesteps that entirely.
More Comparisons
• Soul Electronics S-TRON True vs Audiovance Vibes 202M
• Niukeke Replacement Ear Pads vs Vikye Protein Leather Earmuffs
• Plugfones Basic vs kiisdaa 3.5mm: Passive Noise Reduction
• Prtukyt 6S vs Microsoft Xbox Series S: Wireless Stereo
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.