How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
These two products are often compared because both live in the same drawer — the "keep my air fryer clean" drawer. But they solve different problems. One is a mold you cook in. The other is a sheet you cook on and then throw away. That distinction matters more than anything else on this page.
• INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Silicone — biggest strength: it's a real set of two 8" x 4" x 2.5" flexible silicone loaf pans, so you can bake and shape food that a flat liner simply cannot hold — bread, banana bread, meatloaf, lasagna, brownies.
• INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Silicone — biggest trade-off: you have to wash it after every use, and it's sized around the Ninja Crispi / 8 x 8.5 inch basket format, so you need to check your basket before buying.
• LYHOLKEER 450 — biggest strength: 450 disposable 8" square parchment liners in one pack, with a transparent hard storage case, so you never scrub a basket again.
• LYHOLKEER 450 — biggest trade-off: it's a flat sheet. It holds crumbs and grease splatter, not batter. And it must never go in without food on top of it.
• Who each pick is for: INFRAOVENS for the home baker who wants reusable, shaped cookware and doesn't mind a rinse; LYHOLKEER 450 for the high-frequency, big-family, low-effort cook who wants cleanup to be "lift and toss."
This is bakeware, not a liner. The INFRAOVENS set gives you two rectangular silicone loaf pans, each 8 inches long, 4 inches wide and 2.5 inches deep, in a red finish. They're made for the Ninja Crispi Pro and the Ninja Crispi 4qt / 6 Cup system, and the pair is designed to sit side by side inside an 8 x 8.5 inch air fryer basket. The brand also lists compatibility with a long tail of other machines — Ninja Dual, Ninja Foodi, Smart XL, PowerXL, Chefman, Cosori, GoWise, Philips, Dash and more — but the honest read is that this set is tuned first for the Crispi format, so measure your basket before you commit.
What it does best is give your air fryer a shape. A flat liner can hold a fillet, a handful of nuggets, a slice of pizza. It cannot hold batter. These pans can. You can pour banana bread batter into one, pack a meatloaf into the other, and run both at once for a full small meal. The silicone is BPA-free, non-stick and flexible, so you can peel the sides away instead of digging with a spatula — which is the whole reason silicone bakeware exists. It's rated to resist heat up to 450°F, and it's dishwasher safe.
Who should buy it: anyone who bought an air fryer mainly to reheat and now wants to bake in it without firing up the big oven — and anyone who's tired of buying disposable liners forever. Who should skip it: if your air fryer is a round 5–6 quart basket with a small footprint, two 8-inch loaf pans probably won't fit the way you want, and if you refuse to hand-wash or load a dishwasher, this isn't for you. Also skip it if what you actually cook is messy, greasy, crumb-shedding food you'd rather not touch — that's the other product's job.
LYHOLKEER 450: Who It's For
The LYHOLKEER 450 is a supply, not a gadget. You get 450 square parchment liners, each 8 inches by 8 inches, in unbleached brown paper with a full silicone-oil coating on both sides. They're sized for 5–8 quart air fryers and listed as compatible with Instant Pot, Cosori, Chefman, Ninja, Cuisinart and others, plus ovens, steamers, microwaves and frying pans if you want to use them outside the air fryer.
The material story is the interesting part. The paper is unbleached raw wood pulp with a plant-based silicone oil coating, and it's declared free of fluorescent agents, BPA and PFAS — the last one being a genuine concern for anyone who's been reading about nonstick coatings. The brand says the liners are tested to food-grade standards and won't throw off odd odors under heat. They're heat-resistant up to 450°F — and note the wording: not exceeding 450°F. Keep an eye on that ceiling, and never use these over an open flame.
Functionally, they're thick, tear-resistant and leak-proof thanks to the full-coverage coating, with raised edges that catch grease splatter instead of letting it bake onto your basket. That's the real value: fewer deep cleans, less scrubbing, and a basket that lasts longer because it isn't being scoured. They're disposable and biodegradable, so cleanup is literally lift-and-toss.
Who should buy it: anyone who air-fries several times a week, hates cleanup, and wants one purchase to cover months of cooking. Who should skip it: anyone trying to cut down on single-use kitchen waste, and anyone who wants to bake batter-based food — a flat sheet can't do that. And take the warning seriously: don't put a liner in the air fryer without food on it. Loose lightweight paper plus a strong fan is a bad combination.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for baking bread, cake, brownies or meatloaf → INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Silicone. Two pans, real depth, real shape.
• Best for zero-scrub cleanup → LYHOLKEER 450. Lift the liner, toss it, done.
• Best for greasy, crumb-shedding food → LYHOLKEER 450. The raised edges catch splatter so your basket stays cleaner.
• Best for long-term cost per use → INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Silicone. Two reusable pans replace liner after liner.
• Best for low-waste kitchens → INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Silicone. Reusable silicone versus 450 disposables is not a close call on waste.
• Best for volume and convenience → LYHOLKEER 450. 450 sheets in a hard case will outlast most people's patience.
• Best for a Ninja Crispi 4qt / 6 Cup → INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Silicone. It's the format the set was designed around.
• Best for a 5–8 QT round basket → LYHOLKEER 450. An 8" square liner is the more forgiving fit.
In my opinion, the right answer depends on what you're actually doing with your air fryer — but if I had to pick one, I'd take the INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Silicone set. Here's my reasoning: it's the purchase that actually expands what your appliance can do. It turns an air fryer into a small oven. Disposable liners make an existing job easier; shaped silicone bakeware creates a new one. Add the reusable factor and the conversion chart, and it's the more interesting buy.
That said, I'd genuinely recommend the LYHOLKEER 450 to a different person — someone cooking for a family several nights a week who values their time over everything else. If you'd rather never touch a sponge, that pack of 450 is the more practical choice, full stop.
If both descriptions sound like you, buy both. They don't compete in the drawer.
Yes, for anything with batter. The pans are 2.5 inches deep and hold shape, which is why bread, cake, brownies, meatloaf and lasagna work. A flat parchment liner can't contain liquid batter at all. For dry or greasy food, though, the liner is the simpler option.
They're rated heat-resistant up to, but not exceeding, 450°F, and the paper is unbleached wood pulp with a plant-based silicone coating, declared free of BPA, PFAS and fluorescent agents. Don't use them over an open flame, and always put food on top before starting the air fryer.
The LYHOLKEER pack contains 450 liners, each 8" x 8", sized for 5–8 QT air fryers and compatible with brands like Instant Pot, Cosori, Chefman, Ninja and Cuisinart. If your basket is smaller than that range, measure first — an oversized square liner will curl up the sides.
I can't quote prices here, and they change often. The fair way to judge it is cost per use: two reusable pans versus 450 disposable sheets. For daily greasy cooking the pack stretches a long way; for baking, the pans win over time. Check the current price on Amazon for both before deciding.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Boribim 9 vs Mobestech Silicone Air Fryer, uxcell 18Pcs vs Generic Silicone Air Fryer, GCQFZ Air Fryer Accessories vs Komzon Silicone Air Fryer