How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a plush, immersive PC-first headset with virtual 7.1 surround and a detachable mic, choose HyperX Cloud II Gaming; if you need a lightweight, go-anywhere headset that folds flat and plugs into basically anything with a 3.5mm jack, choose SteelSeries Arctis 1.
• HyperX Cloud II Gaming — biggest strength: hardware-driven virtual 7.1 surround with big 53mm drivers, memory foam ear pads, and a durable aluminum frame. It's built to disappear on your head during long PC sessions.
• HyperX Cloud II Gaming — biggest trade-off: it's a wired, over-ear tank at 11.29 ounces, and the 7.1 surround only works on PC and Mac. On consoles and mobile you're getting plain stereo.
• SteelSeries Arctis 1 — biggest strength: a lightweight, steel-reinforced headband with fold-flat earcups and a universal 3.5mm jack. One headset, every platform, and it doubles as street headphones.
• SteelSeries Arctis 1 — biggest trade-off: no virtual surround, a narrower 20Hz–20kHz range, and less isolation than a closed memory-foam cup.
• Pick HyperX Cloud II Gaming if you mostly game on PC and want maximum comfort plus positional audio.
• Pick SteelSeries Arctis 1 if you play across Xbox, PlayStation, Switch and mobile, travel with your headset, or want one cable that just works everywhere.
The Cloud II is the headset you buy when comfort over a four-hour session matters as much as sound. HyperX uses memory foam ear cushions and a padded leatherette headband, and the whole thing sits inside a solid aluminum frame that's meant to survive daily abuse. You also get two sets of interchangeable ear cups — leatherette and velour — so you can pick the texture and sound profile you prefer. That's a genuinely thoughtful touch most headsets in this class skip.
Audio is where the Cloud II leans hardest. The 53mm dynamic drivers, a 10Hz–23kHz frequency range, 60-ohm impedance and 98dB sensitivity give you plenty of headroom. The real selling point is hardware-driven virtual 7.1 surround, toggled with a button on the USB control box, which adds a sense of distance and direction that helps in shooters and atmospheric games. The closed-cup design delivers passive noise cancellation, so outside chatter fades and you stay locked in. The detachable mic is noise-cancelling and certified for TeamSpeak and Discord, and when you run it through the USB control box you also get AGC and echo cancellation. It ships with an airplane adapter, mesh bag and a limited two-year warranty.
Who should buy it: PC and Mac gamers who want immersive surround, long-session comfort and a mic they can pull off for solo play. Who should skip it: console-first players who won't use the 7.1 feature, anyone who wants a wireless or pocketable headset, and people who dislike a heavier over-ear fit. If you're on the fence about cost, check the current price on Amazon — but the spec sheet is what should decide it for you.
The Arctis 1 takes the opposite approach: light, low-profile and flexible. It's built around a steel-reinforced headband that adjusts to fit a wide range of head sizes while staying light — it comes in at 10.24 ounces. The earcups fold flat, which makes it easy to toss in a bag, and the AirWeave fabric cushions are designed to keep your ears cool and dry instead of trapping heat the way leatherette can.
Connectivity is the headline. A universal 3.5mm jack means it works with Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One natively and with PS5, PS4, Switch and mobile, all over the same cable. The 3-meter cable gives you room to move, and on-headset push-button controls let you adjust volume and mute without digging through menus. The ClearCast microphone is detachable, bidirectional and built for noise cancellation and clarity, and it's Discord certified — pull it off and the headset becomes a normal pair of over-ear headphones for commuting or calls.
On audio, the Arctis 1 uses a 32-ohm dynamic driver with a 20Hz–20,000Hz range and a soundscape tuned to emphasize subtle, critical cues rather than thump. It's a cleaner, more neutral presentation than a bass-forward gaming set. Note the spec sheet lists active noise cancellation as the noise-control method — treat that as the headset's noise-handling behavior rather than expecting it to erase a noisy room the way a closed cup does. It carries a one-year warranty.
Who should buy it: multi-platform players, travelers, and anyone who wants one headset for gaming and everyday listening. Who should skip it: PC players who specifically want virtual surround, and people who prefer a heavier, deeply isolating fit.
• Best for virtual surround sound → HyperX Cloud II Gaming. Hardware-driven 7.1 on PC and Mac, toggled from the USB control box.
• Best for multi-platform flexibility → SteelSeries Arctis 1. Universal 3.5mm works across Xbox, PS5, PS4, Switch and mobile.
• Best for long-session comfort → HyperX Cloud II Gaming. Memory foam pads, padded leatherette headband, and two swappable ear-cup sets.
• Best for travel and on-the-go → SteelSeries Arctis 1. Lightweight, fold-flat earcups and a detachable mic.
• Best for isolation → HyperX Cloud II Gaming. The closed-cup design provides passive noise cancellation.
• Best for PC-only immersion and bass → HyperX Cloud II Gaming. Bigger 53mm drivers and a wider 10Hz–23kHz range.
• Best for a neutral, cue-focused sound → SteelSeries Arctis 1. Tuned to emphasize subtle in-game audio over heavy bass.
• Best for mic flexibility → SteelSeries Arctis 1. Detachable, Discord-certified ClearCast mic plus on-headset push-button controls.
In my opinion, the HyperX Cloud II Gaming is the better buy for most people shopping this matchup — it gives you more comfort engineering, bigger drivers, virtual 7.1 surround and a sturdier aluminum build, and those are the things that actually shape day-to-day gaming. I'd only steer you to the SteelSeries Arctis 1 if your life is genuinely split across consoles, PC and mobile, or if you need a headset light enough to wear on a commute. If you're a single-platform PC gamer, the Cloud II wins; if you're platform-agnostic and want one cable for everything, the Arctis 1 is the smarter pick.
Neither brand is universally better — it comes down to design. HyperX's Cloud II leans into comfort, big 53mm drivers and PC-only virtual 7.1 surround, while SteelSeries' Arctis 1 leans into a lightweight, multi-platform 3.5mm design with a detachable mic. Match the features to how you actually play.
Yes, but with a catch. The 7.1 virtual surround only functions on PC and Mac. On PS4, Xbox One, Switch and mobile you get stereo audio through the wired connection.
No. The Arctis 1 is a stereo headset with a 20Hz–20,000Hz range and a 32-ohm driver, tuned to emphasize subtle audio cues rather than virtual surround. If surround is your priority, the Cloud II is the one that offers it.
The HyperX Cloud II Gaming is the stronger choice on paper, thanks to memory foam ear cushions, a padded leatherette headband and interchangeable leatherette or velour ear cups. The Arctis 1 counters with a lighter 10.24-ounce build and breathable AirWeave fabric, which some people prefer for heat and portability.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: hyperx vs corsair headset, AKKE Hyperx Headset Mic vs GBSCLOVER Mic: Detachable Mic, Yealink UH37 vs HyperX Cloud Stinger 3: Wired Headset