How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-03 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
One is a passive blocker that leans hard on sealing power. The other is a tunable plug that lets you dial how much of the world you let in. Below is how they actually differ once you get past the marketing.
• Huikeya Noise Cancelling Ear — biggest strength: Up to 50dB of noise reduction through a triple-layer seal, with four tip sizes (XS–L) and a lightweight 0.1oz-per-pair build that stays put during movement.
• Huikeya Noise Cancelling Ear — biggest trade-off: It's a single-mode passive plug, so you get one level of blocking with no way to soften it for conversations or live music.
• Clicar Ear Plugs — biggest strength: A built-in dial switch with three modes (Quiet, Engage, Experience), so one pair adapts from deep sleep to concerts to talking with someone nearby.
• Clicar Ear Plugs — biggest trade-off: Its stated ceiling is lower, reducing noise above 60dB to within roughly 30dB — and it openly notes it does not fully isolate.
• Who Huikeya is for: Side sleepers, travelers and light sleepers who want maximum quiet and a secure, featherweight fit.
• Who Clicar is for: People who need one pair to do several jobs — sleep, commuting, swimming and live events — and want to adjust on the fly.
The Huikeya plug is built around one idea: seal the ear canal and block as much as possible. The triple-layer seal is the core of the design, and the claimed reduction reaches up to 50dB. In practice, that's a lot of blocking, and it's aimed squarely at the low-frequency stuff that ruins sleep — traffic rumble, a snoring partner, the drone of an airplane cabin.
The tip range is a real selling point. You get eight soft ear tips spanning XS through L, so most people can find a size that actually seals instead of just sitting there. The contoured shape is meant to stay secure when you move, and at 0.1oz per pair these are genuinely light — the kind of thing you forget you're wearing. They're washable and rated to withstand 500+ uses, which matters if you plan to wear them every night rather than occasionally.
Where it earns its place is sleep and travel. The compact 2.5" x 2" case has dedicated storage slots and attaches to a bag or keys, and the matte black-and-white finish is understated enough to wear in public without looking like medical gear. The earbud-compatible design is a nice touch — it filters low-end noise while preserving mid-range clarity, which is why it works as well for studying or commuting as it does for a snore stopper.
Clicar Ear Plugs: Who It's For
The Clicar plug takes the opposite approach: instead of one fixed level of blocking, it gives you a dial. The in-ear switch cycles through three modes — Quiet for maximum isolation, Engage for easier conversation, and Experience for crisper sound at live events. That single feature is what separates it from almost every other soft silicone sleep earbud in this category.
The numbers tell a more modest story than the Huikeya. Clicar states it reduces noise above 60dB to within about 30dB, and it's upfront that these won't fully isolate you. That's an honest framing, and for sleep — where the goal is knocking a loud room down to something tolerable rather than total silence — it's a sensible target. The company even notes that around 30dB is a comfortable level for sleeping.
You get four pairs of single-layer silicone tips in XS, S, M, and L, sized to cover the elderly, children, men and women. That's a broader sizing spread than most plugs offer, and the ergonomic shape is designed to sit naturally in the canal. The material is soft, skin-friendly silicone that's washable and built for long-term use, so you're not throwing these away every week like disposables.
Portability is handled well too. There's a compact travel case with an integrated lanyard, and the design carries its own patent — a rare bit of style in a category full of generic foam. The sheet also flags swimming and concerts alongside sleep, which makes this the more versatile pick of the two. It's pitched as a gift as well, which tells you the brand is thinking about broad appeal rather than one narrow use case.
Who should skip it? If your single priority is the deepest possible block — a genuinely loud environment you need flattened — the Huikeya's higher ceiling and triple-layer seal are the better bet. And if you want zero fiddling, the mode switch is one more thing to think about at 2am.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for flexibility across situations → Clicar Ear Plugs (Quiet, Engage and Experience modes in one pair).
• Best for sleep specifically → Huikeya, thanks to the secure contoured fit and featherweight 0.1oz-per-pair build — though Clicar's ~30dB target is explicitly tuned for sleep too.
• Best for concerts and live music → Clicar, whose Experience Mode is designed to keep sound crisp rather than muffled.
• Best for swimming → Clicar, the only one of the two with water use in its stated use cases.
• Best for ear-fit range → Both are strong, but Clicar ships four full pairs of tips versus Huikeya's eight individual tips across four sizes.
• Best for travel kit → A draw. Huikeya offers a scratch-resistant case with storage slots; Clicar offers a compact case with an integrated lanyard.
• Best for long-term durability → Huikeya, rated to withstand 500+ uses and washable for daily wear.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the Huikeya Noise Cancelling Ear for sleep and travel. In my opinion, the higher reduction ceiling, the triple-layer seal and the genuinely lightweight fit make it the stronger single-purpose tool — and sleep is what most people are actually shopping for. I'd choose the Clicar Ear Plugs instead if I wanted one pair to cover sleep, commuting, concerts and swimming with an adjustable dial, and I'd accept the lower stated ceiling as the price of that versatility. Neither is a bad buy; they just answer different questions.
For sleep, look for a soft silicone plug that seals well and stays put overnight. The Huikeya Noise Cancelling Ear fits that brief with a contoured, secure shape, eight tips across XS–L, and a 0.1oz-per-pair weight. The Clicar Ear Plugs also work for sleep, with a Quiet Mode and a stated ~30dB level the brand describes as suitable for sleeping.
Yes — both of these are reusable silicone sleep plugs rather than electronics. Huikeya is a passive noise blocker rated up to 50dB and built to withstand 500+ uses. Clicar adds an in-ear dial with three modes and ships four pairs of XS–L tips. Neither requires charging or batteries.
Roll or compress the soft tip slightly, pull your ear up and back to straighten the canal, then insert and let the silicone expand to seal. Fit is everything — that's why both sets include multiple sizes (XS–L). If sound still leaks in, size up or reseat the plug.
No. Clicar states plainly that its plugs reduce noise above 60dB to within about 30dB and do not fully isolate. Huikeya claims up to 50dB through a triple-layer seal, but no passive plug eliminates every sound. Both cut the low-frequency drone that disrupts sleep far more than they erase sharp, sudden noises.
If you're weighing these two, the deciding question is simple: do you want the deepest block, or the most adjustable one? Check the current price on Amazon for whichever fits your answer, and match the tip size carefully — with soft silicone sleep earbuds, the seal you get matters more than any spec on the box.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Skullcandy Push 720 vs Groovz Open-Ear Plus True, Sony MDR-7506 vs Sennheiser Professional HD 300, sweatproof earbuds, Tyadas Headset Adapter vs HyperGear Kombat Kitty Headphones