How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-20 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• HTINDUSTRY's biggest strength: a straightforward, comfort-first replacement pad built specifically for the Marshall Monitor over-ear headphone, using soft protein leather over memory foam.
• HTINDUSTRY's biggest trade-off: it is a single-purpose fit — the listing names the Marshall Monitor only, so it is not the pad to buy if you own a Sony WH-1000XM4.
• BUTIAO's biggest strength: a full refresh kit for the Sony WH-1000XM4 — two ear pads, two sponge cushions and a plastic stick to make installation fast.
• BUTIAO's biggest trade-off: it is locked to the WH-1000XM4 only, so it is useless on any other headphone, Marshall included.
• Pick HTINDUSTRY if your priority is a like-for-like comfort and noise-blocking refresh on a Marshall Monitor.
• Pick BUTIAO if you own a Sony WH-1000XM4 and want to bring tired, flattened pads back to life with a thicker, slow-recovery foam setup.
The HTINDUSTRY Earpads Replacement Cushion is a focused product. It exists for one job: replacing worn pads on the Marshall Monitor over-ear stereo headphone. The listing states compatibility with that model and nothing else, so the value here is precision rather than universality. The pad itself is built from soft, skin-friendly protein leather wrapped around memory foam — the same basic recipe most people want when the original cushions have gone shiny, cracked or flattened.
Comfort and noise reduction are the two pillars HTINDUSTRY leans on. The memory foam is there to keep your ear cushioned over long listening sessions, and the faux-leather enclosure helps seal around the ear, which is what actually blocks outside noise. Neither claim is exotic — it is the standard physics of a well-sealed pad — but that is exactly what you want from a replacement: no surprises, just a snug fit again. The pads come from a dedicated earpad factory under what the listing describes as strict quality control, and they are advertised as installable without special tools.
BUTIAO Replacement Earpads Ear: Who It's For
The BUTIAO Replacement Earpads Ear is the opposite kind of product: a complete refresh kit for the Sony WH-1000XM4 over-ear headphone, and only that model. The listing is emphatic about it — WH1000XM4 only. If that is your headphone, the kit is genuinely more than just two pads. You get two ear pads, two sponge cushions and a plastic stick. That stick matters more than it sounds: getting a new pad seated evenly around the housing is the fiddly part of any replacement, and having a dedicated tool turns it into a job the listing describes as roughly a five-minute task.
The material story is where BUTIAO makes its case. The pads use high-grade protein leather over high-density, slow-recovery memory foam, plus the extra sponge cushion. Slow-recovery foam is the interesting detail — it compresses gradually and conforms to the shape of your ear instead of springing straight back, which is what gives a personalized, enveloping fit. BUTIAO also claims the added thickness holds up over time so the pads do not go flat, and that the seal is optimized for noise isolation and bass response. That is a coherent design argument: a tighter, thicker seal is exactly what improves passive isolation and low-end punch on a noise-cancelling headphone.
The listing frames the purchase around reviving a headphone you already like — giving a well-used WH-1000XM4 a fresh look and feel rather than replacing the whole unit. It also offers replacement or refund if something is wrong, which is worth knowing for a part you will handle and stretch during installation.
Who should buy it: Sony WH-1000XM4 owners whose pads are compressed, peeling or uncomfortable, especially anyone who wants the extra foam thickness and a helping tool for installation. Who should skip it: everyone else. If you do not own a WH-1000XM4, this kit simply does not fit.
• Best for a Marshall Monitor → HTINDUSTRY Earpads Replacement Cushion. It is the only one of the two designed for that headphone.
• Best for a Sony WH-1000XM4 → BUTIAO Replacement Earpads Ear. Purpose-built for that model, no adapter guesswork.
• Best for a complete refresh kit → BUTIAO. Two pads, two sponge cushions and a plastic stick in one package.
• Best for tool-free installation → HTINDUSTRY. The listing says no special tools are needed for the fit.
• Best for a thicker, conforming foam feel → BUTIAO. Extra-thick slow-recovery memory foam plus a sponge layer.
• Best for a simple comfort-and-seal swap → HTINDUSTRY. Soft protein leather over memory foam, nothing more to manage.
• Best for long-term thickness → BUTIAO. Its design specifically targets pads that stay plump instead of flattening.
• Best for warranty reassurance → HTINDUSTRY. One year against manufacturer defects; BUTIAO offers replacement or refund instead.
In my opinion, this is not a close call once you know which headphone you own — the two products do not overlap at all. If you have a Sony WH-1000XM4, I would buy the BUTIAO Replacement Earpads Ear: the kit's extra sponge cushions, slow-recovery foam and included plastic stick make it the more complete and more thoughtfully designed refresh, and the thicker seal is aimed squarely at the isolation and bass you bought the headphone for. If you have a Marshall Monitor, the BUTIAO kit is simply not an option — the HTINDUSTRY Earpads Replacement Cushion is the right buy, and its protein-leather-and-memory-foam build with a one-year defect warranty is a sensible, low-drama replacement. Match the pad to your headphone first, then to your preference for a thicker foam feel versus a straightforward comfort swap. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
No. HTINDUSTRY lists compatibility with the Marshall Monitor only, and BUTIAO states its pads fit the WH1000XM4 only. Buying the wrong one means a poor or impossible fit.
HTINDUSTRY says no special tools are needed for its pads. BUTIAO includes a plastic stick with its kit and describes installation as quick, typically around five minutes.
Both lean on a sealed protein-leather fit for isolation. BUTIAO additionally claims optimized acoustics for noise cancelling and enhanced bass through its thicker, slow-recovery foam. HTINDUSTRY frames it as blocking external noise via the soft leather and memory foam.
BUTIAO specifically designs for long-term thickness so the pads do not go flat. HTINDUSTRY's focus is on softness and comfort rather than foam longevity claims.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.