How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Honeydak 24 — biggest strength: A 24-piece, two-shape system (extended clips plus round weights) that covers air fryer parchment and sous vide bag submersion in one kit.
• Honeydak 24 — biggest trade-off: More pieces and two distinct shapes mean more to store and keep track of than a minimal set.
• Generic Magnets — biggest strength: A compact 4-piece set of heat-resistant silicone-and-magnet buckles built purely to hold liners flat and clean up easily.
• Generic Magnets — biggest trade-off: One shape, four pieces, and no sous vide or multi-appliance role — you get liner holding and not much else.
• Buy Honeydak 24 if you cook both air fryer and sous vide, or you want spare magnets on hand for multiple appliances.
• Buy Generic Magnets if you only need a handful of liner holders for a single air fryer and prefer the simplest possible tool.
Honeydak 24 is the more ambitious of the two. The set arrives as 24 pieces arranged into four sets of three, in red and black, and the design deliberately splits into two shapes: extended clips that lock around the air fryer edge to pin parchment paper down, and compact round weights that sink sous vide bags so food stays submerged instead of floating. That dual-shape approach is the whole point. A clip that grips an edge and a weight that drops into a water bath are different jobs, and Honeydak builds for both rather than pretending one shape does everything.
The material is silicone with heat-resistant magnets inside, and the stated purpose is stability under heat: keep the liner from sliding or folding, keep the bag from drifting, and keep your hands away from hot surfaces when you're repositioning things. If you've ever watched a corner of parchment curl up toward a hot element, you already understand why a magnetic buckle that holds the liner flat is appealing. The kit is also pitched as universal — it's meant to attach to any air fryer with metal components and to work in ovens, slow cookers and sous vide setups too.
So who should buy it? In my opinion, Honeydak 24 fits the cook who runs more than one appliance and wants one accessory drawer to cover all of it. It also suits anyone who likes having spares: 24 pieces across four sets means you can keep a few in the air fryer rotation, a few with the sous vide gear, and still have backups. Who should skip it? If you own exactly one air fryer, never touch sous vide, and dislike keeping track of small parts, this is more system than you need. The trade-off is real: two shapes and two dozen pieces is more to manage than four identical buckles.
Generic Magnets takes the opposite approach. This is a 4-piece set of heat-resistant silicone magnet buckles in black, each roughly 4.13 x 0.63 x 0.28 inches and about 31 grams. The stated job is narrow and clear: hold air fryer parchment liners in place, resist heat so the holder doesn't warp, and grip the liner firmly enough that it stops curling and shifting mid-cook. The silicone exterior is described as stain-resistant and easy to clean, and the material is built to resist tears and wear near hot appliances rather than deform after a few uses.
There's also a broader claim in the listing — that the buckles can work with trays and containers and integrate into most air fryers — but the core identity here is a liner holder, full stop. That's not a criticism. For a lot of people, liner management is the entire problem: parchment lifts, food slides, cleanup gets messy, and a small magnetic buckle solves it in one motion.
Buy Generic Magnets if you want a minimal, no-thinking-required set for a single air fryer and you value easy cleaning and a low parts count. Skip it if you also cook sous vide, if you want weights for bag submersion, or if you like having spares around — four pieces is four pieces, and if two end up lost in a drawer, your set is suddenly half its size. It's also a single-color, single-shape product, so there's no clip-versus-weight flexibility to lean on.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for air fryer parchment control → both work, but Honeydak 24's extended clips are purpose-built to lock onto the fryer edge, while Generic Magnets relies on a single buckle shape to pin the liner.
• Best for multi-appliance kitchens → Honeydak 24, which is explicitly positioned for air fryer, sous vide, oven and slow cooker use.
• Best for simplicity → Generic Magnets. Four identical buckles, one color, one job.
• Best for having spares on hand → Honeydak 24 with 24 pieces across four sets.
• Best for easy cleaning → Generic Magnets calls out a stain-resistant silicone exterior; Honeydak 24 is silicone too, so both wipe down, but the Generic set is smaller to wash.
• Best for small storage footprint → Generic Magnets — four compact buckles at about 31g each.
• Best for gifting or outfitting a shared kitchen → Honeydak 24, simply because the larger count covers more people and more appliances.
I'd buy Honeydak 24. In my opinion, the two-shape design is the deciding factor: clips for the air fryer and round weights for sous vide cover two real problems instead of one, and 24 pieces means I'm not rationing them between appliances. Generic Magnets is a perfectly sensible minimal pick if all you want is a few liner holders for one air fryer and nothing more. But if you're comparing these two specifically, Honeydak 24 does more per piece. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit, since that's the one thing that could tip a close call.
If you cook sous vide or own multiple appliances, yes — the round weights and larger count add capabilities the 4-piece set doesn't have. If you only air fry, the basic set covers the essentials.
Do Generic Magnets work in any air fryer?
The listing says they fit most air fryers and work with trays and containers. They need a metal surface for the magnets to grip, so check your model's interior before relying on them.
For one air fryer and one liner, two to four buckles is typically enough, which makes the Generic set workable. Honeydak 24's 24 pieces make more sense if you want spares or you're also weighing down sous vide bags.
Generic Magnets buckles are about 4.13 x 0.63 x 0.28 inches each at roughly 31g. Honeydak 24 lists its paper size as 16x24 inches across 24 units, but doesn't break out individual buckle dimensions.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Gavigain Kitchen Fryer vs Generic Air Fryer Cooking, Fdit Air Fryer Magnetic vs HJPNHFHNT Air Fryer Cooking, Generic Air Fryer vs OEKFVCHVZ Air Fryer Disposable