How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Homikit 10x12 — biggest strength: pure stainless steel with no chemical coating, rolled edges and a 1-inch depth, plus a wire cooling rack that nests right in the pan.
• Homikit 10x12 — biggest trade-off: it is one pan and one rack. No muffin cups, no loaf shape, no round cake pan. If you bake layer cakes, you buy them separately.
• PERLLI Baking Kit Nonstick — biggest strength: six pieces in one set — cookie sheet, round cake pan, 12-cup muffin pan, loaf pan, roaster and square pan — in a nonstick carbon steel build with silicone handles.
• PERLLI Baking Kit Nonstick — biggest trade-off: it is a coated set, so you have to treat the nonstick surface with care, and only the cookie sheet and roaster shapes read as air-fryer-friendly.
• Who each pick is for: Homikit for the air fryer and toaster-oven cook who wants one pan for bacon, wings, fries and vegetables; PERLLI for the home baker who wants a whole set of shapes on day one.
The Homikit set is two pieces: a 12.4" x 9.6" x 1" baking sheet and an 11.6" x 9.1" wire cooling rack. That's it. And that's the point. The pan is stamped from stainless steel with no chemical coating at all, so there's nothing to peel, flake or wear through. The brand's own framing is that it's a straight replacement for aluminum or ceramic trays, and the spec sheet backs the logic: food-grade steel, mirror-polished surface, seamless body with rounded corners.
The design details are the ones that matter in an air fryer. Rolled edges add rigidity so the pan resists twisting under high heat, and the brand calls out that it's deforming resistant with no warping or bending. There's a 1-inch depth, which is deeper than a flat cookie sheet and enough to hold rendered fat from bacon or chicken without it running over the edge. The slight outward angle on the sides lets two of these nest together for storage. The wire rack is welded with parallel lines close enough to keep food from dropping through, and it stands on four raised feet, so air circulates under whatever you're crisping.
Buy it if you cook in an air fryer, toaster oven or standard oven and you want one pan that can go from roasting vegetables to crisping fries to cooling cookies on the same rack. It's also the right call if you're avoiding coated bakeware on purpose — no nonstick layer means no scratching anxiety and no coating to degrade. It's dishwasher safe, and at 1.6 pounds it's light enough to handle one-handed.
PERLLI Baking Kit Nonstick: Who It's For
PERLLI goes the opposite direction: one box, six tools. You get a cookie sheet, round cake pan, 12-cup muffin pan, loaf pan, roaster and a square pan that doubles as a storage pan for the rest. Every piece is carbon steel with a nonstick coating the brand describes as extra firm, scratch resistant and odor-free, plus silicone handles for grip.
The material note worth flagging is the BPA-free claim — the steel is listed as free of bisphenol-A. Heat tolerance is listed at up to 230°C (446°F), and the brand says the set is compatible with standard convection ovens. It's also dishwasher safe and stackable, which matters more than people admit: six pieces of bakeware take up serious cabinet space if they don't nest.
On the air fryer question, be realistic. This is a six-piece oven set, and the pieces that translate to an air fryer basket are the cookie sheet and the roaster. A 12-cup muffin pan or a round cake pan won't fit most air fryer baskets. So if your primary appliance is an air fryer, you're buying this set for the oven and using one or two pieces in the air fryer when they fit.
Buy it if you're building a kitchen from scratch, baking for a family, or you want cake, bread, muffins and roast chicken all covered without shopping piece by piece. The range of shapes — square, rectangle and round — is the actual value here. Buy it if you want nonstick release for sticky batters and easy cleanup after a roast.
Skip it if you cook almost entirely in an air fryer, if you want uncoated metal, or if you'd rather buy one excellent pan than six decent ones. Also skip it if you're hard on your bakeware — nonstick coatings reward gentle handling with plastic or silicone utensils, not metal ones.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for air fryer cooking → Homikit 10x12. The 12.4" x 9.6" footprint, 1-inch depth and uncoated steel suit bacon, wings, fries and vegetables in a basket or toaster oven.
• Best for people avoiding coatings → Homikit 10x12. Pure stainless steel, no chemical coating, nothing to peel.
• Best for easy release and cleanup → PERLLI Baking Kit Nonstick. The full set is nonstick coated and dishwasher safe.
• Best for a two-piece do-everything setup → Homikit 10x12. Pan plus rack, usable together or separately, and they nest for storage.
• Best for a starter kitchen or gift → PERLLI Baking Kit Nonstick. One purchase, six pieces, stackable.
• Best for long-term durability against warping → Homikit 10x12. Rolled edges and stainless construction are pitched specifically at resisting twist and warp.
• Best for bakeware that fits inside another pan → PERLLI Baking Kit Nonstick. The square pan stores the rest of the set.
If I'm cooking in an air fryer, I'd buy the Homikit 10x12. The size, the 1-inch depth, the rack with raised feet and the lack of any coating are exactly what an air fryer pan needs, and there's no nonstick surface to baby. In my opinion it's the better single-purpose tool for that appliance.
I'd buy the PERLLI set instead if I were outfitting an oven for actual baking. You can't make muffins or a round cake in a sheet pan, and six pieces in one box solves that in a single move. My honest read: these two barely compete. One is an air fryer workhorse; the other is an oven bakery in a box. Buy the one that matches the appliance you actually use.
FAQ
what is an air fryer baking pan
what is an air fryer cake pan
A round or square pan small enough to sit inside an air fryer basket for baking cakes and brownies. The PERLLI set includes a round cake pan and a square pan, but it's sold as a six-piece oven set, so you'd need to confirm each piece fits your specific air fryer basket before relying on it there.
what is an air fryer safe baking pan
One made from a material and construction that tolerates the air fryer's concentrated heat without warping or releasing anything into your food. The Homikit pan is stainless steel with no chemical coating, rolled edges and a deforming-resistant build, which is why it's the more natural air fryer fit of these two.
are air fryer pans oven safe
Generally yes, and both of these qualify for oven use. The Homikit pan is stainless steel and the brand lists it for oven, toaster oven and air fryer use. The PERLLI set is carbon steel rated heat-safe up to 230°C (446°F) and described as compatible with standard convection ovens.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: ANDRESLAD Air Fryer Baking vs ABOOFAN Frying Omelette Rings, Lifetime KitchenAid Nonstick Aluminized vs Aramox Air Fryer Accessorie, GCQFZ Air Fryer Replacement vs Homikit 10x8: Air Fryer Steak