We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a two-piece drip-and-crumb setup for a larger air fryer oven, choose HEISENLIN 2PCS; if you need a single handled grill plate that lifts food off the basket floor in a smaller air fryer, choose GWY Air Fryer Accessories.
• HEISENLIN 2PCS biggest strength: You get two 10 × 9.8-inch 304 stainless steel drip trays with a non-stick coating, plus a cleaning cloth — a spare is genuinely useful when one tray is in the sink.
• HEISENLIN 2PCS biggest trade-off: It is a flat rectangular pan built for specific oven-style models, so it does not lift food off a basket floor and it will not fit a round 3.6 QT air fryer.
• GWY Air Fryer Accessories biggest strength: A round 7.87 × 7.87-inch grill plate with a built-in handle and four rubber bumpers, designed to be pulled out of the basket mid-cook with hot food on it.
• GWY Air Fryer Accessories biggest trade-off: It is one plate only — no second piece — and the round footprint only suits air fryers that take a 7.87-inch round accessory.
• Who each pick is for: HEISENLIN 2PCS for owners of Chefman 6.3 QT, Aria 10 QT, Ultrean 12.5 QT or Emeril Lagasse Pro 6 QT oven-style units; GWY for owners of Chefman TurboFry 3.6 QT, Ultrean 4.2 QT, Emeril Lagasse 4 QT, Power XL 4.0 QT or Instant Pot Duo Crisp 11-in-1.
This is a drip-and-crumb tray, not a crisper plate, and that distinction matters more than anything else in this comparison. It sits in the drip pan slot of an oven-style air fryer and catches oil and breadcrumbs as food cooks above it. If your routine involves anything greasy — bacon, chicken wings, sausage, roasted vegetables finished with oil — this is the part that keeps the bottom of the cavity from turning into a baked-on mess.
The material story is straightforward: food-grade 304 stainless steel, BPA-free, Teflon non-stick coating on top. The two-pack is the practical hook. In an oven-style fryer you are often cooking in two rounds, and having a second tray means you can swap a dirty one out instead of scrubbing mid-meal. HEISENLIN also throws in a non-stick cleaning cloth, which pairs with their own warning: don't use abrasive pads or metal scouring balls, because that will wreck the coating. That is honest, useful guidance rather than marketing fluff.
Who should buy it: anyone with a Chefman 6.3 QT digital air fryer, Aria 10 QT, Ultrean 12.5 QT or Emeril Lagasse Pro 6 QT who is tired of cleaning the same baked-on pan every night. The 10 × 9.8-inch size is the reason for that list — it is a wide rectangular tray, and the brand itself says it only fits specific oven models.
Who should skip it: anyone with a basket-style round air fryer, and anyone hoping to raise food off the basket floor for better air circulation. This tray sits flat and catches drips. It is not a grill plate, and it will not crisp the underside of anything.
The GWY plate solves a different problem: everything in a basket air fryer sits on one surface, and when you want to cook a second batch you either wait or stack. This round 7.87-inch stainless steel plate with an enameled non-stick coating gives you a removable second surface. The handle is the smart part — you can lift the plate with food on it straight out of the basket, set it down, and drop the next batch in. Clean everything at the end instead of between rounds. The four rubber bumpers are there to keep the plate from rattling or scratching the basket interior.
Cooking-wise, GWY lists barbecue, steak, vegetables, fish, french fries, pizza, beef, chicken wings and onion rings, plus dehydrating fruit. That is a broad list, but the mechanics are simple: it is a flat round plate that lets heat and air move around food that would otherwise sit in the basket base.
Who should buy it: owners of a Chefman TurboFry 3.6 QT, Ultrean 4.2 QT, Emeril Lagasse 4 QT, Power XL 4.0 QT or Instant Pot Duo Crisp 11-in-1 who cook in batches and want a grab-and-go surface with a handle. It is also dishwasher safe, which suits anyone who refuses to hand-wash accessories.
Who should skip it: anyone with an oven-style air fryer — this plate is round and sized for a basket. And if you only ever cook one portion at a time, the extra plate adds a dish to wash without adding much convenience. Note the brand's own instruction to measure your air fryer before ordering, which is worth taking seriously given how many 4 QT baskets vary in shape.
• Best for oven-style air fryers → HEISENLIN 2PCS. The 10 × 9.8-inch rectangular tray is built for Chefman 6.3 QT, Aria 10 QT, Ultrean 12.5 QT and Emeril Lagasse Pro 6 QT ovens.
• Best for basket-style air fryers → GWY Air Fryer Accessories. The 7.87-inch round plate fits Chefman TurboFry 3.6 QT, Ultrean 4.2 QT, Emeril Lagasse 4 QT, Power XL 4.0 QT and Instant Pot Duo Crisp 11-in-1.
• Best for catching grease and crumbs → HEISENLIN 2PCS. That is literally its job: it slots into the drip pan position and collects oil and debris during cooking.
• Best for lifting food out mid-cook → GWY Air Fryer Accessories. The handle design is the whole point; you can remove a loaded plate from a hot basket without tongs.
• Best for batch cooking → GWY Air Fryer Accessories. The removable plate lets you start the next food immediately instead of cleaning the basket first.
• Best for having a spare on hand → HEISENLIN 2PCS. Two trays means one can be soaking while the other works.
• Best for dishwasher users → GWY Air Fryer Accessories. It is explicitly dishwasher safe, whereas HEISENLIN's coating calls for gentler handling — no abrasive cloths or metal balls.
• Best for easy cleanup on a flat surface → HEISENLIN 2PCS. The non-stick coating plus the included cleaning cloth is a tidy package for a wide, shallow tray.
If I owned a Chefman 6.3 QT, Aria 10 QT, Ultrean 12.5 QT or Emeril Lagasse Pro 6 QT oven-style air fryer, I would buy the HEISENLIN 2PCS. Two trays and a cleaning cloth for a job that is entirely about catching mess is a sensible, low-drama purchase, and the spare tray earns its place the first time you cook two rounds back to back.
If I owned a smaller basket fryer — a TurboFry 3.6 QT, Ultrean 4.2 QT, Emeril 4 QT, Power XL 4.0 QT or Instant Pot Duo Crisp — I would buy the GWY plate instead. The handle and the removable surface change how you sequence a meal, and that is worth more day to day than a second flat tray you have nowhere to put. In my opinion, the deciding question is simply which shape your appliance takes, not which accessory is "better."
It comes down to shape. HEISENLIN's tray is 10 × 9.8 inches and fits Chefman 6.3 QT, Aria 10 QT, Ultrean 12.5 QT and Emeril Lagasse Pro 6 QT models. GWY's plate is 7.87 × 7.87 inches and fits Chefman TurboFry 3.6 QT, Ultrean 4.2 QT, Emeril Lagasse 4 QT, Power XL 4.0 QT and Instant Pot Duo Crisp 11-in-1. Measure before ordering.
I can't quote prices here, and both listings change over time anyway. Check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page before you decide — that is the only figure that matters at checkout.
GWY states its plate is dishwasher safe. HEISENLIN says its tray is easy to clean thanks to the non-stick coating and includes a soft cleaning cloth, but warns against abrasive pads or metal scouring balls that would damage the coating. Hand-wash the HEISENLIN tray if you want it to last.
Neither is a crisping gadget. HEISENLIN catches drips below the food; GWY gives you a removable surface with airflow around it and a handle for pulling food out mid-cook. For crispness, technique and spacing matter more than either accessory.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: SALLO 2-in-1 vs BAVRQMZX 2PCS: Air Fryer Multi Purpose Rack, HEISENLIN Air Fryer Replacement vs KunoNana Air Fryer Grill, Instant Pot Duo 7-in-1 vs SIK Air Fryer Accessories