Clean Air & Health Champions needed for Armidale!

Armidale, August 2021

We all know about the toxic chemicals in cigarette smoke, such as PAH (polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons) like benzo[a]-pyrene, featured in the "every cigarette is doing you damage" adverts.  That's why many people think it's not OK to smoke cigarettes anywhere near children.  

Wood smoke contains large amounts of the same chemicals.  Burning 15 kg of wood in an enclosed wood heater for an evening's heat produces as many toxic PAH as in the smoke from 0.6 million cigarettes.  On still nights, the smoke builds up and creates high pollution levels outside and inside our homes, as shown by this photo of Armidale in August 2001

The WHO 'Breathe Life' and UNICEF 'What does Air Pollution Do inside Children's Body and Brain?' videos explain that air pollution lurks all around us, preying on the young and old, slipping unnoticed past our body's defenses causing ill-health and deaths from heart attack, strokes, lung disease and cancer. 

The “Growing up in New Zealand” study found that every additional modern woodstove per hectare increased by 7% the risk children under 3 would need hospital emergency treatment.  The vast majority of stoves in the NZ study would have been modern, low-emission models, because NZ introduced stricter standards in 2005 for new wood stoves in urban areas than required for new stoves in Armidale in 2021.  Wood heaters meeting current Australian standards haven't been studied in Australia, but in NZ real-life emissions in NZ average 8 times worse than lab test data, resulting in health costs exceeding $3,000 per stove per year. In Tasmania, where many wood heaters are used in small towns similar to Armidale, estimated health costs were $4,232 per heater per yearHealth experts recommend not burning wood when non-polluting alternatives are available

The particles in smoke are tiny - less than 2.5 millionth of a metre.  Particles of this size, called PM2.5, behave like gases and enter our homes even when all doors and windows are closed. They also penetrate into the deepest recesses of our lungs and can cross into the bloodstream and transport toxins to every organ of the body. 

Health experts believe that there is no safe level of PM2.5. In Tasmania, researchers noted the main cause of elevated PM2.5 is biomass smoke from wood heaters during winter and bushfires and planned burns at other times of the year.  Hospital admissions for heart failure (HF, the leading cause of hospitalisation for adults aged over 65 years) started to increase in Tasmania as soon as PM2.5 exceeded 4 ug/m3, a tiny fraction of the current Australian PM2.5 standard of 25 ug/m3. The researchers also noted that there are more HF incidences and readmissions in winter in Tasmania than other seasons. 

Other studies show that many people die prematurely from PM2.5 pollution even at levels below the National PM2.5 standard. The risk is even higher when the standards are exceeded, as they were on 32 days in Armidale in 2018, according to the NSW Government Air Quality Statement.  All Armidale's exceedances were attributed to the non-exceptional event of winter wood heating. Next worse was Liverpool, Sydney, with 8 exceedances that were attributed to hazard-reduction burns and bushfires.

Launceston's successful federally-funded woodsmoke program reduced deaths in winter from respiratory disease by 28% and cardiovascular disease by 20%For a population of 100,000, the cost of cleaning up the air was less than $21 per resident.

Despite only 4.4% of households using wood as main heating in Sydney, residential wood heating is the largest single source of PM2.5 (the most hazardous air pollutant). One modern 'eco-friendly' wood stove is more polluting than 6 diesel trucks or 18 diesel cars. 

So would you like to champion clean air and health in Armidale?  If so, Council's Air Quality Working Group is a great place to start, especially for those who 

If you think you have the skills and enthusiasm to serve on the Air Quality Working Group (AQWG), please email an expression of interest (EOI) to council@armidale.nsw.gov.au by 10 pm, 13 April 2021. The EOI should be in the form of a 1-2 page letter pages addressing the Selection Criteria and explaining how you can contribute to achieving the AQWG’s goals. 

Council's 'YourSay' page had all the information, but there currently appear to be some technical problems.  

The 'Cosy Home, Clean Air' report by Armidale Regional Council's Wood Smoke Advisory Group shows that a reverse cycle heat pump has lower running costs than buying firewood (table below from p17)

WHO: Breathe Life 80 sec video: How air pollution impacts your body. Air pollution is an invisible killer that lurks all around us, preying on the young and old. Learn how it slips unnoticed past our body's defenses causing deaths from heart attack, strokes, lung disease and cancer. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GVBeY1jSG9Y 

UNICEF 170 sec video: What does Air Pollution PM 2.5 do inside children's body and brain? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QcS3ovdsgNI 

New Scientist Report and Video: log-burning stoves are harming our health and speeding up global warming (Feb 2017) https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=10155097669589589

The NSW Asthma Foundation warned that wood smoke emissions in winter pose a bigger immediate health danger in built up urban areas than cars or cigarettes. The evidence convinced the NSW Chief medical officer, who said "wood heaters are so detrimental to health she supports banning and phasing them out in built-up urban areas". 

The Australian Lung Foundation made similarly strong statements: “real-life emissions from new wood-heaters have little relationship to measurements from a perfectly operated test model under laboratory conditions), the Canadian Lung Association (“don’t burn wood in a residential setting”) the American Lung Association (“avoid burning wood”) and the American Lung Association of California who urges the public to avoid wood burning and to consider cleaner heating alternatives. Burning wood emits harmful toxins and fine particles into the air that can worsen asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). 

One modern 'eco-friendly' wood stove is more polluting than 6 diesel trucks or 18 diesel cars. Air Pollution researcher, Dr Gary Fuller:  "even stoves that pass eco-friendly standards still emit around six times more particle pollution than a modern diesel lorry – and 18 times more than a diesel car. 

New Scientist Report and Video: log-burning stoves are harming our health and speeding up global warming (Feb 2017) https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=10155097669589589

The only tests of real-life emissions of wood heaters satisfying current Australian & New Zealand standards were in NZ. They show that real-life emissions averaged 8 times worse than the lab test, and were little different from emissions of older wood heaters used in Australia - see 'Health Cost of Allowing New Wood Heaters – over $3,000 per heater per year'.

Starfish Initiatives' Cloud Valley Clearing - a project to install efficient, reverse cycle heat pumps in the homes of volunteers, to show that, coupled with insulation where needed, they provide cheaper, convenient, environmentally-friendly heating.

Additional key information about air pollution in Armidale, dropbox folder: https://www.dropbox.com/sh/vacszgm9lgqn8al/AAAEbso89eZeZRv1pjTU5cVla?dl=0