If you want focused, isolated sound for meetings, choose Mackie MP Series In-Ear; if you need open-ear, waterproof headphones for swimming and workouts, choose Tayogo Rock PRO W24. For everyday calls and concentrated listening, Mackie is the more relevant fit; Tayogo is built around movement, water, and leaving your ears uncovered.
• Mackie MP Series In-Ear: Its triple-driver design, sound isolation of up to 40 dB, and several ear-tip options suit focused listening; the trade-off is that its in-ear fit blocks much more outside sound.
• Tayogo Rock PRO W24: Its open-ear bone-conduction design, built-in 32 GB MP3 storage, and IPX8 waterproof rating are geared toward swimming; the trade-off is that it has no noise control and is not designed as a meeting-first headset.
• For desk work and calls: Choose Mackie if sound isolation and a wired connection suit your setup.
• For the pool and outdoor activity: Choose Tayogo if water resistance, open ears, and onboard music storage matter most.
Mackie’s MP-320 is a wired in-ear monitor built around three dynamic drivers and a precision three-way crossover. That configuration separates the sound spectrum across the drivers, with the stated aim of delivering clarity, stereo imaging, and low-frequency response. For someone joining meetings in a noisy room, the most practically relevant specification is its sound isolation of up to 40 dB. It is a physical seal, not electronic noise cancellation, and that difference matters: it can help reduce surrounding noise, but it also makes the earphones less suited to someone who wants to hear nearby conversation.
The package includes four types of ear tips, each offered in three sizes, plus a hard case, a quarter-inch adapter, and a cleaning cloth and tool. That range of tips gives buyers more ways to adjust the fit than a single-style tip would. A shielded, braided cable is designed for durability and sonic performance. The product information also lists a 3.5 mm jack and a remote on a controller-equipped cable, making this a wired option rather than a simple wireless meeting headset. Check that its connection suits the device you plan to use.
I’d consider Mackie for someone who values a closer, more isolated sound for calls, focused listening, or audio work and is comfortable wearing in-ear tips. It may be a poor match for people who want to stay alert to household noise, dislike ear-tip pressure, or specifically want open-ear comfort. The available details describe sound and fit, but do not establish a microphone feature, so I would not choose it on the assumption that it includes a meeting microphone.
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-16 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
Tayogo Rock PRO W24: Who It's For
Tayogo takes the opposite approach. Its bone-conduction speakers sit outside the ear canal, leaving the ears uncovered. The product is designed for swimming and other active use, with an IPX8 waterproof rating and a flexible, lightweight frame listed at 32 g in its feature description. The product information gives a different weight figure, so I would avoid making a precise weight comparison based on these details. Its central advantage is clear: the design is aimed at staying usable around water, where ordinary in-ear headphones are a poor fit.
The W24 offers four modes: onboard MP3 playback from 32 GB of built-in memory, Bluetooth use above water, FM radio, and a transmitter mode that pairs with the Tayogo T6 for underwater streaming. That last function requires the separate T6 transmitter; it should not be mistaken for ordinary Bluetooth streaming underwater. Tayogo lists up to eight hours of continuous playback and a two-hour charge time. Its charging port is magnetic, while its controls are buttons rather than touch controls.
That makes Tayogo a sensible fit for swimmers who want audio without putting earbuds into their ears, or for people looking for an open-ear option during outdoor activity. It is not the natural choice for someone seeking sound isolation for a meeting: the product specifies no noise control, and an open-ear design lets the surroundings remain part of the listening experience. The provided details also do not identify a microphone, so I would not assume it is equipped for work calls.
• Best for reducing surrounding noise during focused listening → Mackie MP Series In-Ear. Its sound isolation is specified at up to 40 dB. Tayogo has no noise control.
• Best for swimming → Tayogo Rock PRO W24. It has an IPX8 waterproof rating and is designed for water-based use; Mackie is an in-ear monitor, not a swimming headphone.
• Best for a sealed in-ear fit with multiple tip choices → Mackie. It includes four tip styles in three sizes, giving you several ways to adjust the fit.
• Best for keeping the ear canal uncovered → Tayogo. Its bone-conduction design is open ear, unlike Mackie’s rounded in-ear tips.
• Best for music without carrying a phone in the pool → Tayogo. Its built-in 32 GB memory supports MP3 playback. Bluetooth is specified for use above water, while underwater transmitter mode requires the Tayogo T6.
• Best for a wired listening setup → Mackie. Its product information lists a 3.5 mm jack, and the package includes a quarter-inch adapter.
• Best for a meeting where you want to remain aware of nearby activity → Tayogo’s open-ear design, with a caveat. It leaves your ears uncovered, but the listed features do not confirm a microphone or meeting-call controls.
• Best for the “best touch control open ear headphones for meetings” search → neither is an exact match. Tayogo is open ear but uses button control, while Mackie is in-ear and designed for isolation. If touch controls are essential, neither product’s listed controls meet that requirement.
The comparison is not simply about which one sounds better. The two products solve different problems. Mackie is built around an in-ear seal and monitoring-style audio; Tayogo is built around an open-ear, waterproof form. For meeting use, an important distinction is that neither product’s listed details confirm a microphone. Mackie’s isolation may help you focus on incoming audio, but it does not by itself establish how clearly other people will hear you. Tayogo’s uncovered-ear design may help you stay aware of your surroundings, but that is different from offering a dedicated call setup.
That distinction also applies to shoppers looking for the best open ear earbuds for meetings. Tayogo is open ear, but it is a swimming headphone with button control and a feature set centered on water and sports. It is not presented as a conference headset. Similarly, the phrase best sweatproof open ear earbuds for meetings combines two separate priorities: Tayogo is specified as waterproof with an IPX8 rating and is intended for sports, while the provided details do not establish sweat-related call performance or a meeting microphone. I would judge it by the features actually listed, rather than assuming every open-ear sports headphone will handle calls well.
A practical setup check can decide the Mackie question quickly. If your computer or phone can use the listed wired connection, and you want more isolation than an open-ear design provides, it is the closer fit. If you prefer wireless listening above water, or want one device for pool workouts and stored music, Tayogo has the more relevant functions. Just keep its mode boundaries in mind: Bluetooth use is described for above-water listening, and its underwater transmitter mode depends on pairing with the Tayogo T6.
Comfort is personal, but the design differences are concrete. Mackie relies on ear tips; its multiple tip styles and sizes may help buyers find an acceptable seal, but it remains an in-ear product. Tayogo leaves the ear canal open, which may appeal to people who do not want inserted tips, yet its bone-conduction setup is a different listening experience from a sealed in-ear monitor. Neither approach is universally more comfortable. The better choice is the one that suits your ears, environment, and primary task.
In my opinion, I would choose Mackie MP Series In-Ear for meetings when the priority is focused listening and a wired, isolated fit. Its up-to-40 dB sound isolation and range of included ear tips make it the more relevant of these two for a quieter listening experience, though the listed details do not confirm a microphone. For swimming, I’d choose Tayogo instead. It is purpose-built for water, open-ear wear, and onboard music, rather than desk calls.
For focused listening, Mackie is the closer match because it is an in-ear monitor with sound isolation of up to 40 dB. Neither product’s listed specifications confirm a microphone, so I would verify call compatibility before treating either as a complete meeting headset.
The product information describes Bluetooth use above water. Underwater streaming is tied to its transmitter mode when paired with the Tayogo T6, so ordinary Bluetooth use underwater is not what the listed feature set promises.
Tayogo Rock PRO W24 has an IPX8 waterproof rating and is designed for swimming. Mackie’s listed features do not identify it as waterproof, so it is not the appropriate choice for pool use.
No touch controls are listed. Its control type is button control. Mackie’s product information lists a remote on a controller-equipped cable, so neither is described as a touch-control open-ear meeting headphone.
• OYIB Earbuds vs Tatybo Gaming Headset: Touch Control
• MIDOLA Kids vs MAS CARNEY Over Ear Headphones
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.