How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a durable stainless-steel grill surface that gives you real searing and airflow for meat, choose GWY Air Fryer Grill; if you need a flexible, non-stick silicone liner that keeps your baskets spotless and handles saucy or sticky foods, choose NEWITEE Air Fryer Silicone.
• GWY Air Fryer Grill — biggest trade-off: Fit is locked to Ninja Foodi DZ090 / DZ201 / DZ100 (and UK AF300) — it will not drop into just any air fryer, and the non-stick surface needs gentle washing to survive.
• NEWITEE Air Fryer Silicone — biggest strength: A snug-fitting 2-pack of BPA-free platinum silicone liners (7.9 x 5.9 x 2.8 in) with deep bottom grooves for airflow, a handle for lifting, and a 10-year warranty.
• NEWITEE Air Fryer Silicone — biggest trade-off: Sized for Ninja 10QT DoubleStack XL and DualZone XL models (DZ401, DZ550), so it's the wrong shape for smaller or non-Ninja baskets.
• Pick GWY if you want a firm metal surface for steaks, wings and char.
• Pick NEWITEE if you want zero-scrub cleanup and a soft liner you can lift straight out.
The GWY grill plate is a direct replacement part, not a universal accessory. It's built for the Ninja Foodi DualZone family — DZ090, DZ201, DZ100 in the US and AF300 in the UK — and each plate measures 8.1 x 5.5 inches. That's the whole point: it drops into those specific baskets instead of rattling around in whatever you happen to own. If your model isn't on that list, this is not your part, and GWY is upfront about telling you to measure first.
What it does well is give food somewhere firm to sit. The perforated, whirlwind-style airflow design lets hot air move under and around the food, which is exactly what you want for chicken wings, steak, fish, onion rings, fries, vegetables or pizza. The stainless-steel body with a non-stick coating is food-grade, BPA-free and non-toxic, and there's a handle in the middle so you can lift a loaded plate out of the basket without tongs gymnastics.
The package is thoughtful for the money-free side of things: two grill plates, eight rubber bumpers and a cleaning cloth. Those bumpers matter more than they sound — they sit under the plate and keep it from scratching the inside of your air fryer's pot. Cleaning is dishwasher-friendly, though GWY warns against abrasive cloths or metal scouring balls, because that will strip the non-stick layer.
Buy it if you own one of the listed Ninja DualZone models and you want a metal grilling surface that browns and crisps rather than steams. Skip it if your air fryer is a different brand or size, or if you'd rather never deal with a coated surface at all.
The NEWITEE liners solve a different problem: the mess. These are 5-quart rectangular silicone liners measuring 7.9 x 5.9 x 2.8 inches, and they're engineered specifically for Ninja 10QT DoubleStack XL and DualZone XL two-basket fryers, including the DZ401 and DZ550. The raised height is deliberate — it protects the basket walls, not just the floor, so drips and grease stay in the liner instead of baking onto your machine.
The material is 100% platinum food-grade silicone, BPA-free, and heat-resistant to 230°C (446°F), which covers air frying, baking and steaming. If you use them in a regular oven, NEWITEE says to keep a 1-inch gap from the walls and heating elements. The bottom has deep grooves designed to keep air moving under the food, which is the detail that separates a good silicone liner from a flat one that turns everything soggy.
Two practical touches stand out. First, the two-pack comes in two colors (brown and green), so you can dedicate one to meat and one to vegetables — genuinely useful if you're cooking a protein and a side in the same session. Second, they're non-stick in the real sense: food slides off, a little hot soapy water handles most cleanup, and they're dishwasher safe. That's the whole pitch against parchment — no flimsy sheets, no oily residue, no scrubbing.
NEWITEE also backs these with a 10-year warranty and around-the-clock support, which is unusually long for a kitchen accessory and signals confidence in the silicone holding up.
Buy it if you own a Ninja 10QT DoubleStack or DualZone XL and you're tired of scraping baskets. Skip it if you have a different air fryer size, or if you specifically want a hard surface for searing.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for searing and browning → GWY Air Fryer Grill. A stainless-steel plate with perforated airflow gives meat a firm, hot surface; silicone can't replicate that char.
• Best for effortless cleanup → NEWITEE Air Fryer Silicone. Lift the liner out, rinse or dishwasher it, done. No scraping the basket.
• Best for sticky or saucy foods → NEWITEE. Marinades, cheese and wet rubs stay contained in the liner's raised walls.
• Best for two-basket meal prep → tie, with a nudge to NEWITEE. Both are 2-packs, but NEWITEE's two colors make separating meat and veg obvious.
• Best for heat tolerance → GWY. Bare stainless steel with a non-stick coating is built for the high heat of air frying; NEWITEE's silicone tops out at 230°C (446°F).
• Best for protecting your air fryer's finish → NEWITEE. Full-height walls shield the basket sides, not just the base.
• Best for a specific fit guarantee → check your model first. GWY fits DZ090/DZ201/DZ100 and AF300; NEWITEE fits DZ401/DZ550. Neither is universal.
In my opinion, the right pick comes down to what you cook most. If you're grilling — wings, steaks, chops, anything you want browned and crisp — I'd buy the GWY Air Fryer Grill, because a metal plate with real airflow does a job silicone simply can't. If your priority is keeping the air fryer clean with almost no effort, I'd buy the NEWITEE Air Fryer Silicone instead: the snug fit, the two colors, the deep airflow grooves and the 10-year warranty make it the more forgiving everyday accessory. Both are two-packs, so either way you're covered for a dual-basket machine. Just confirm your exact Ninja model before ordering — that's the one mistake that ruins either purchase.
FAQ
No. GWY fits Ninja Foodi DZ090, DZ201, DZ100 (US) and AF300 (UK). NEWITEE fits Ninja 10QT DoubleStack XL and DualZone XL models including DZ401 and DZ550. Check your model number before buying either.
You can cook in it, but you won't get a hard sear. Silicone is soft and non-stick, so it's better for vegetables, fish, casseroles and anything saucy. For char and browning, the metal GWY plate is the better tool.
GWY is dishwasher safe but must avoid abrasive pads or metal scouring balls, which damage the non-stick coating. NEWITEE cleans with hot soapy water or in the dishwasher. Both are low-effort; GWY just needs gentler handling.
Both are inexpensive accessories with very different jobs, so value depends on your air fryer model and what you cook. Use the button on this page to check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: KunoNana Air Fryer Grill vs LxueLxic Silicone Mat: Best Air, GWY Air Fryer Grill vs brikinte 1pcs, GWY Air Fryer Basket vs ALJ Air Fryer Grill