How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a drop-in replacement crisper plate that turns a compatible Ninja basket into a grill-and-roast surface, choose GWBSXM Air fryer Accessories; if you need reusable silicone liners that catch grease and lift out clean, choose Emeril Reusable Silicone Air. These are two very different answers to the same problem — one is a hard, handled cooking surface, the other is a soft, flexible liner — and picking the wrong type is the most common reason people end up disappointed with an air fryer accessory. For the "best air fryer under $100" shopper, the accessory you choose usually matters more than the fryer itself, because it decides how often you actually use the thing.
• GWBSXM Air fryer Accessories — biggest trade-off: it is a fit-dependent part. If your basket is not in the 8.20 × 8.20 inch family, it simply is not your accessory, and there is only one plate in the box.
• Emeril Reusable Silicone Air — biggest strength: two flexible 9 × 7 × 3 inch silicone liners with raised ridges that hold food off the base, let grease drain, and go straight into the dishwasher.
• Emeril Reusable Silicone Air — biggest trade-off: liners are not a grill surface. They are shallow trays with walls, so they suit oven-style air fryers and their trays far better than a compact round basket.
• Who each pick is for: GWBSXM for Ninja AF100/AF101/AF150/AF161 owners who want a replacement crisper plate with a handle. Emeril for Emeril Lagasse Air Fryer Oven and French Door Air Fryer Oven owners who want to stop buying disposable parchment.
This is a replacement part first and an accessory second. The GWBSXM grill plate is a round 8.2 × 8.2 inch steel disc with an enameled non-stick coating applied in two sprayed layers, and it is built for Ninja AF100, AF101, AF150 and AF161 baskets, plus any air fryer whose crisper plate sits in that same 8.20 × 8.20 inch footprint. The brand also notes compatibility with Ninja Foodi pressure cookers that use the same size plate. If you already own one of those machines and your original crisper plate has scratched, warped or gone missing, this is the direct swap — no adaptation, no trimming, no guessing.
Who should buy it: Ninja AF-series owners who want a genuine second plate, people who grill or roast in the basket and want a raised surface with drainage, and anyone who has measured their existing crisper plate and found it matches 8.2 inches. Who should skip it: anyone with a different basket size, anyone who wants liners rather than a plate, and anyone shopping for a multi-piece accessory kit — this listing is one grill plate plus small extras, not a bundle of skewers, racks and molds. Measure before ordering; the brand says so plainly, and it is the single most common way this purchase goes wrong.
Emeril Reusable Silicone Air: Who It's For
This is a different philosophy entirely. The Emeril liners are soft, reusable silicone trays — 9 × 7 × 3 inches, 11.6 ounces, sold as a two-pack in black — designed for Emeril Lagasse Air Fryer Oven and French Door Air Fryer Oven models, and stated to fit many air fryer oven trays and baskets. They are food-grade silicone, non-stick, and dishwasher safe. The point of them is to replace disposable parchment: you cook, you lift the liner out, you wash it, you use it again. Over a month of regular cooking that is a lot of parchment you are not buying, and a lot of greasy tray-scrubbing you are not doing.
The feature I find most interesting is the raised ridge design. Ridges do two jobs at once — they lift food slightly so hot air circulates underneath for more even results, and they give rendered fat somewhere to go instead of pooling around the food. In an oven-style air fryer, where the heating element is above and the tray is wide and flat, that combination matters more than it would in a deep basket. The three-inch walls also mean the liner contains mess inside its own footprint, which is exactly what you want on a large rectangular oven tray.
Who should buy it: Emeril Lagasse Air Fryer Oven and French Door Air Fryer Oven owners, anyone tired of disposable liners, and households cooking wet or saucy foods where a liner saves real cleanup time. Who should skip it: people with a compact round-basket fryer, since a 9 × 7 inch rectangular liner is the wrong geometry for a small circular basket, and anyone expecting a grill plate — silicone will not give you hard sear marks or a rigid lifting surface. Two liners in the pack means one can be in the dishwasher while the other cooks, which is the practical reason a two-pack makes sense here.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for stopping disposable parchment purchases → Emeril Reusable Silicone Air. Two reusable silicone liners replace single-use liners session after session.
• Best for a rigid, handled cooking surface → GWBSXM Air fryer Accessories. The built-in handle and steel body are the whole point; there is nothing floppy about it.
• Best for grease drainage and airflow under food → Emeril Reusable Silicone Air. The raised ridges lift food and let fat collect below rather than around it.
• Best for oven-style air fryers → Emeril Reusable Silicone Air. The 9 × 7 × 3 inch liner is designed around Emeril Lagasse Air Fryer Oven and French Door Air Fryer Oven trays.
• Best for compact basket fryers → GWBSXM Air fryer Accessories. An 8.2 inch round plate is built for round baskets, not wide oven trays.
• Best for a two-liner rotation → Emeril Reusable Silicone Air. The pack includes two liners, so one can wash while the other works.
• Best for a coating that tolerates metal utensils poorly but cleans easily → GWBSXM Air fryer Accessories. The enameled non-stick is dishwasher safe but must be kept away from abrasive pads and metal balls.
• Best for buyers who have not measured their appliance → neither, yet. Both products live or die on fit; GWBSXM needs an 8.2 inch round plate space, Emeril needs an oven-style tray.
In my opinion, I would buy the GWBSXM Air fryer Accessories if I owned a Ninja AF100, AF101, AF150 or AF161 and my crisper plate needed replacing — it is the more specific, more structural fix, and the handle and dishwasher-safe non-stick coating are the details that make it useful every day rather than occasionally. I would buy the Emeril Reusable Silicone Air if I owned an Emeril Lagasse Air Fryer Oven or French Door model and my real frustration was cleanup and disposable liners. If you are still choosing a fryer and hunting for the best air fryer under $100, decide which of those two problems is yours first, then check the current price on Amazon for the accessory that matches. Fit beats features here every time.
what is the best air fryer under $100
That is a question about the appliance, not the accessory, and I cannot answer it from these two data sheets — neither product here is an air fryer. What I can tell you is that the accessory matters as much as the fryer: a GWBSXM plate only fits 8.2 inch round baskets, and Emeril liners are built for Emeril Lagasse Air Fryer Oven and French Door models. Pick the accessory that matches your appliance's geometry and you will use the fryer far more often.
It is designed for Ninja AF100, AF101, AF150 and AF161, and for other air fryers that use an 8.20 × 8.20 inch crisper plate. It is also listed as compatible with Ninja Foodi pressure cookers using that size. If your basket is a different size, it will not fit — the brand explicitly asks you to measure before ordering.
They are designed for Emeril Lagasse Air Fryer Oven and French Door Air Fryer Oven models, and the brand states they fit many air fryer oven trays and baskets. At 9 × 7 × 3 inches they are rectangular, so they suit oven-style trays better than a small round basket. If you have a compact basket fryer, the GWBSXM plate is the more sensible shape.
Both are. The GWBSXM grill plate is dishwasher safe thanks to its enameled non-stick coating, though the brand warns against abrasive cloths and metal scouring balls. The Emeril silicone liners are dishwasher safe as well — the brand's instruction is simply to place them in the dishwasher after cooking. For the GWBSXM plate, hand-washing gently will protect the coating longer.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Tyson Rotisserie Seasoned Chicken vs Emeril Reusable Silicone Air, ZIP STANDING Reusable Silicone Air vs Komzon Silicone Air Fryer, LA LECHLEY 2 vs redamey Silicone Air Fryer: Reusable Air