How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Goalfly Silicone Baking Mat — biggest strength: three quarter-sheet mats (11.8 x 8.5 in) made of silicone with a fiberglass core, working from -40°F to 447°F, so they handle oven, air fryer and toaster-oven duty alike.
• Goalfly Silicone Baking Mat — biggest trade-off: it's a flat surface only, so it won't grip, lift or turn a bagel; and the brand notes slight discolouration at high heat over time.
• carrotez Mini Silicone Toaster — biggest strength: a 7-inch BPA-free silicone tong with an anti-slip, non-scratch grip, heat-resistant from -40°C to 240°C and dishwasher-safe.
• carrotez Mini Silicone Toaster — biggest trade-off: it's one small tool, not a cooking surface, so it does nothing about sticking or cleanup on its own.
• Pick Goalfly if your goal is baking air fryer bagels from scratch without grease or parchment waste.
• Pick carrotez if your goal is safely lifting and serving hot bagels, snacks or delicate food without scratching your pans.
The Goalfly set is a baking surface first and a kitchen utility second. You get three quarter-sheet mats in red, blue and grey, each 11.8 by 8.5 inches, built from silicone with a fiberglass center that spreads heat evenly and silicone-coated edges that seal the fiberglass in. That construction is exactly what makes it useful for air fryer bagels: the flat, smooth surface stops dough from sticking, so you can skip the butter and oil, and the mat still releases cleanly once the bagels are done.
The temperature window is the part I'd underline. A range of -40°F to 447°F covers ovens, toaster ovens, microwaves, air fryers and dishwashers, which means one mat can follow your bagels from proofing tray to baking surface without a swap. The thickened material also lets it double as a placemat, pot holder, rolling mat or heat-insulation pad, and having three in the pack means one can be in the dishwasher while another is in use. Each mat weighs about 7 ounces, so it's substantial enough to lie flat rather than curl at the corners.
Who should skip it? Anyone who wants a tool to grab, flip or serve food. The mat gives you a surface, not a hand. It also isn't a replacement for a baking pan — it fits a quarter sheet pan, so if you don't own one, factor that in. And if you bake at the very top of the range repeatedly, expect the slight discolouration the brand itself mentions; it doesn't affect performance, but it's honest to know ahead of time.
carrotez Mini Silicone Toaster: Who It's For
Seven inches is the deliberate part. It's short enough for precise control over small items — bagels, pastries, dessert fruit, salad portions, pasta — and long enough to keep your fingers clear of heat. The grip is designed to hold without squeezing hard, so a hot bagel doesn't slide out mid-lift. Heat resistance runs from -40°C to 240°C, and it's dishwasher-safe, so cleanup is a non-issue. It's a single item in the pack, and it weighs next to nothing.
Who should buy it? Someone whose air fryer bagel routine is mostly reheat-and-serve: pulling a bagel out of the basket, plating it, tossing a salad alongside. It's also a good fit if your cookware is nonstick and you're tired of scratching it. Who should skip it? Anyone expecting it to solve sticking, cleanup or even browning. It's a handling tool, full stop. If your only problem is that bagels stick to the basket, this won't fix that.
• Best for baking air fryer bagels from raw dough → Goalfly Silicone Baking Mat. The non-stick silicone surface and even fiberglass-core heating are built for dough.
• Best for lifting and serving hot bagels → carrotez Mini Silicone Toaster. The anti-slip grip is the whole point of the tool.
• Best for replacing parchment paper → Goalfly Silicone Baking Mat. Reusable, dishwasher-safe, and three mats keep you from running out.
• Best for protecting nonstick cookware → carrotez Mini Silicone Toaster. Non-scratch silicone tips won't mark your pans or toaster.
• Best for heat range flexibility → Goalfly Silicone Baking Mat. -40°F to 447°F spans oven, air fryer, microwave and freezer.
• Best for quiet, tidy cooking → carrotez Mini Silicone Toaster. It's explicitly noise-free and won't wake the house.
• Best for multi-use value → Goalfly Silicone Baking Mat. Three mats that also work as placemats, pot holders and rolling mats.
• Best for small kitchens and single servings → carrotez Mini Silicone Toaster. One compact 7-inch tool that stores anywhere.
• Best if you want both jobs covered → buy both. A surface and a grabber aren't competitors; they're a pair.
My Verdict
how to air fry bagels
Shape or slice your bagel, place it on a non-stick silicone surface like the Goalfly mat if your basket tends to grab, then air fry until the crust sets and the top browns. Use a silicone tong like the carrotez Mini to lift it out without scratching the basket. The mat's -40°F to 447°F range covers standard air fryer temperatures comfortably.
how to make air fryer bagels
Make your dough, shape the bagels, and bake them directly on a silicone mat rather than greasing the basket — the Goalfly mat's smooth surface means you can skip added butter and oil. Because the mat's fiberglass core spreads heat evenly, the bagels brown more consistently than on bare metal. Keep the mat flat against a quarter sheet pan or basket base so it doesn't curl.
how long do i air fry bagels for
It depends on whether you're reheating a finished bagel or baking raw dough — reheating is a short few minutes per side, while raw dough needs longer at a moderate temperature until it's cooked through and browned. Watch the crust rather than trusting a fixed number, since basket size and bagel thickness vary. A non-stick mat helps here because you can check and lift without the dough tearing.
how do i air fry pizza bagels
Top your bagel halves, set them on a silicone mat so the cheese and sauce don't weld to the basket, and air fry until the cheese melts and the edges crisp. The Goalfly mat's smooth surface releases sticky melted cheese far more easily than bare metal, and it's dishwasher-safe afterward. Use the carrotez Mini tongs to lift the halves out cleanly without burning your fingers.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Hkvoxim Heat Resistant Mat vs PINTAUR Square Silicone Air, uxcell 18pcs vs Mirenlife Reusable Silicone Baking, Fox Run Muffin Pan vs BESPORTBLE Silicone Resistant Baking