How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want to revive a pair of Sennheiser studio or aviation headsets with fresh memory-foam leatherette cushions for a fraction of the cost of new headphones, choose GEEKRIA Leatherette Replacement Ear; if you need replacement pads for a Plantronics BackBeat Pro 2 or Voyager 8200 UC and want high-density noise-isolating foam in a brown finish, choose Miruchertter Voyager 8200.
• GEEKRIA Leatherette Replacement Ear — biggest strength: A wide, specific fit list covering Sennheiser PXC350, HD380, HD380 PRO, PC350, PC350 SE, PXE350, HME95 and HMEC250, built from memory foam wrapped in black leatherette.
• GEEKRIA Leatherette Replacement Ear — biggest trade-off: It is a fitment-driven part, so you have to match your exact headphone model (or measure your cups) before ordering, and it only comes in black.
• Miruchertter Voyager 8200 — biggest strength: High-density noise-isolating memory foam with a quick, tool-free install path for BackBeat Pro 2 and Voyager 8200 UC owners.
• Miruchertter Voyager 8200 — biggest trade-off: The compatibility list is narrow — it is aimed at two Plantronics models, not a broad set of brands — and the color is brown only.
• Who GEEKRIA is for: Sennheiser wired-headset owners (studio, call-center, aviation-style HME/HMEC users) replacing flattened pads.
• Who Miruchertter is for: Plantronics BackBeat Pro 2 / Voyager 8200 UC owners who want their noise isolation and comfort back.
GEEKRIA built this as a repair part, not a lifestyle accessory. The pads use memory foam covered in leatherette, and the whole point is to bring a worn-out headset back to a usable, comfortable state instead of retiring it. The listed compatibility is unusually detailed for a pad set: Sennheiser PXC350, HD380 and HD380 PRO, PC350 and PC350 SE, PXE350, HME95 and HMEC250. That mix tells you the target buyer — somebody running an older Sennheiser wired headset for monitoring, gaming voice chat, or professional/aviation-style communication, where the frame and drivers still work fine but the cushions have gone flat, cracked or shiny.
Skip it if your headphones are not on that Sennheiser list and you are not willing to measure. If your cups are a different shape or diameter, the fit will not be right no matter how good the foam is. Also skip it if you want a color other than black — there is only one finish.
Miruchertter Voyager 8200: Who It's For
This pad set is purpose-built for two Plantronics headsets: the BackBeat Pro 2 and the Voyager 8200 UC. Miruchertter uses high-density memory foam, which is the same material that made those headphones comfortable in the first place, and the brand explicitly frames it around noise isolation — a denser, memory-foam cushion seals better around the ear, which supports the passive isolation the BackBeat Pro 2 and Voyager 8200 UC rely on alongside their active noise cancellation. If your originals have gone soft and leaky, fresh foam is what restores that seal.
The install story is the other selling point. Miruchertter describes a quick, tool-free replacement that takes only a few minutes, which is realistic for this style of pad — you are usually working with a stretch-and-seat lip rather than screws or glue. The pads are also described as returning to their original shape when not in use, which is the practical definition of memory foam doing its job over months of daily wear.
The obvious limits: brown is the only color, and compatibility stops at those two Plantronics models. If you own anything else, this is not your part. Miruchertter also states a one-year warranty and offers a 24-month worry-free warranty with lifetime technical support in the same listing, so if something goes wrong you have a route to a replacement or refund. Buy it if you have a BackBeat Pro 2 or Voyager 8200 UC and want your comfort and isolation back. Skip it if you need black pads or you own a different headset.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for Sennheiser owners (HD380, PC350, PXC350, PXE350, HME95, HMEC250) → GEEKRIA Leatherette Replacement Ear. The compatibility list is the whole decision here.
• Best for Plantronics BackBeat Pro 2 / Voyager 8200 UC → Miruchertter Voyager 8200. It is designed specifically around those two models.
• Best for noise isolation → Miruchertter Voyager 8200. Its high-density memory foam is explicitly positioned around sealing and isolation.
• Best for a color that disappears into a black headset → GEEKRIA Leatherette Replacement Ear. Only black is offered.
• Best if you want to match a brown or tan headband → Miruchertter Voyager 8200. Brown is the only finish available.
• Best for quick, low-fuss installation → Miruchertter Voyager 8200. The listing calls out a few-minute, hassle-free swap.
• Best for headset types beyond consumer Bluetooth → GEEKRIA Leatherette Replacement Ear. The HME95 and HMEC250 coverage points to professional and aviation-style use.
In my opinion, this is not a "which one is better" choice — it is a fitment choice, and the fitment data makes it easy. If you own a Sennheiser HD380, PC350, PXC350, PXE350, HME95 or HMEC250, I would buy the GEEKRIA Leatherette Replacement Ear pads; the model list is specific, the memory-foam-and-leatherette construction matches the originals, and you get two pads and a one-year warranty. If you own a BackBeat Pro 2 or Voyager 8200 UC, I would buy the Miruchertter Voyager 8200 — it is built for those two headsets and its noise-isolating memory foam is aimed squarely at restoring the seal. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit, and measure or confirm your model first.
They are listed as compatible with Sennheiser PXC350, HD380, HD380 PRO, PC350, PC350 SE, PXE350, HME95 and HMEC250. GEEKRIA also says they may fit other brands if the dimensions match, so measure your cups against the 4.33 x 3.35 x 0.87 inch size if your model is not listed.
Yes. Miruchertter states compatibility with both the Plantronics BackBeat Pro 2 and the Voyager 8200 UC. They are not advertised for other Plantronics models, so confirm your headset before ordering.
The Miruchertter Voyager 8200 pads are the ones explicitly built around noise isolation, using high-density memory foam to improve the seal around your ears. The GEEKRIA pads are described as memory foam and leatherette with durability and fit as the focus, not isolation.
Both are memory foam based and both carry a one-year manufacturer warranty. Miruchertter notes its pads return to shape after use, which is what keeps comfort consistent over time. Real-world life depends on how often you wear the headset and how much you sweat, so treat the warranty as the floor, not the ceiling.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Tranesca Leather Replacement earpad/Ear vs GLOBLELAND Sunset Valley Ce, Krone Kalpasmos Replacement Ear Pads vs YDYBZB White Ear Pads, JOYSOG Headphones Replacement Ear vs Waziaqoc 2