How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a grill-style crisper plate that turns a Ninja DualZone XL basket into a proper searing and crisping surface, choose GCQ Air Fryer Grill; if you need a replacement bottom crumb tray that keeps a Ninja Foodi air fry oven clean, choose Dinlon Air Fry Crumb.
• GCQ Air Fryer Grill — biggest trade-off: it is model-specific. The 8 x 6.3-inch footprint is built for those DualZone XL baskets and will not fit other air fryers, so you have to measure before ordering.
• Dinlon Air Fry Crumb — biggest strength: it protects the floor of a Ninja Foodi air fry oven, catching crumbs, grease and drips before they bake onto the bottom and start smoking.
• Dinlon Air Fry Crumb — biggest trade-off: it is a maintenance accessory, not a cooking surface. It will not crisp, sear or grill anything, and it only fits the SP/FT-series oven models listed.
• Who each pick is for: choose GCQ if you own a Ninja DualZone XL and want better browning and easier cleanup in the baskets. Choose Dinlon if you own a Ninja Foodi air fry oven and your original crumb tray is missing, damaged or permanently caked in grease.
The GCQ Air Fryer Grill is a pair of replacement crisper plates made from food-grade steel. The listing states no BPA, non-toxic and tasteless, and says the material meets FDA standards. In practice, that matters because this plate sits directly under your food at high heat, cycle after cycle — you want a material that will not leach anything into a chicken wing or a slice of fish.
The interesting part is the airflow design. Instead of a flat perforated sheet, the tray is shaped to move hot air around and under the food. That is the whole point of a crisper plate in a basket-style air fryer: the bottom of the food gets as much moving hot air as the top, so you get browning on both sides rather than a soggy underside. The brand lists barbecue, steak, vegetables, fish, french fries, pizza, beef, chicken wings, onion rings and dehydrated fruit as use cases — basically anything where you want a grilled or roasted texture instead of a steamed one.
Sizing is where you have to be careful. The plate measures 8 x 6.3 inches and is explicitly designed for the Ninja Foodi DZ401 and DZ550 10-quart DualZone air fryers. It is not a universal accessory. The brand itself tells you to measure your existing grill plate before ordering, and I would take that seriously — a plate that is slightly too small rattles around, and one that is slightly too big simply will not seat.
Cleaning is straightforward. The surface has a non-stick coating and is dishwasher safe, which solves the most annoying part of air frying — scrubbing baked-on grease out of a mesh basket. One caveat from the brand: do not use a rough abrasive cloth or metal scouring balls, because they will destroy the coating. Soft sponge or dishwasher only.
Buy it if you own a Ninja Foodi DZ401 or DZ550 and want a proper grilling surface plus easier cleanup. Skip it if you have any other air fryer model, or if you are looking for a crumb tray rather than a cooking plate.
Dinlon Air Fry Crumb: Who It's For
The Dinlon Air Fry Crumb is a completely different kind of accessory. It is the tray that sits at the very bottom of a Ninja Foodi air fry oven — the countertop toaster-oven-style machines, not the basket models — and catches everything that falls off your food during cooking.
Its compatibility list is long and specific: FT102A, FT102CCO, FT102CO, SP080, SP100, SP101, SP101A, SP101BK, SP101C, SP101CM, SP101CO, SP101NP, SP101Q, SP101QBK, SP101QCM, SP101QNV, SP101QRD, SP201, SP301 and SP102. If you own one of those ovens, this tray drops in and sits securely. If you own anything else, it is the wrong part — and given how many near-identical model numbers Ninja uses, checking your exact number on the back of the machine is worth two minutes of your time.
The job it does is unglamorous but genuinely useful. Grease and crumbs that reach the bottom of an air fry oven get baked on by the same circulating heat that cooks your food. Over time that builds into a hard, dark layer that smells and eventually smokes every time you preheat. A crumb tray intercepts all of it before it gets there, which the brand says reduces smoke and makes the oven easier to maintain.
Two design details stand out. First, the rolled edge. It sounds trivial until you have tried to pull a hot, greasy tray out of a tight oven slot with bare hands — a smooth rolled rim is noticeably safer and more comfortable to grip than a raw stamped edge, and it resists scratching. Second, the package includes four reusable black fiberglass liners with a food-grade Teflon coating. Those liners sit on the tray, catch the worst of the mess, and can be wiped or rinsed instead of you scrubbing the tray itself every single day.
The tray has a smooth surface specifically to reduce stuck-on grease, and cleanup is a wipe or a rinse rather than a soak. It weighs 1.3 pounds and comes as a single replacement tray with the four liners included. That combination — replacement tray plus liners — is really the point: it is a set for people whose original tray is lost, cracked or so badly stained that cleaning it is no longer worth the effort.
Buy it if you own one of the listed Ninja Foodi air fry oven models and want less smoke, less scrubbing and a longer-lived oven. Skip it if you own a basket-style air fryer, or if you are shopping for something to actually cook on.
• Best for actually grilling and crisping food → GCQ Air Fryer Grill. It is a cooking surface with an airflow design built to brown food evenly.
• Best for keeping the appliance clean → Dinlon Air Fry Crumb. It is a catch tray, engineered to stop residue reaching the oven floor.
• Best for Ninja DualZone XL basket owners → GCQ Air Fryer Grill. The 8 x 6.3-inch plates are made for the DZ401 and DZ550 10-quart models.
• Best for Ninja Foodi air fry oven owners → Dinlon Air Fry Crumb. The SP and FT series compatibility list is wide, but it is oven-specific.
• Best for easy cleanup → a tie, by different routes. GCQ is dishwasher safe with a non-stick coating; Dinlon wipes clean and ships with four reusable liners.
• Best for handling safety → Dinlon Air Fry Crumb. The rolled edge is designed to prevent scratches and cuts when you pull the tray in and out.
• Best for getting two of everything → GCQ Air Fryer Grill. Two plates and eight rubber bumpers, which suits a two-basket machine.
• Best for replacing a worn-out original part → Dinlon Air Fry Crumb. That is precisely what it is made for.
My Verdict
In my opinion, these two are not really competitors — they solve opposite problems, and the right answer depends entirely on which Ninja you own. If I had a Ninja Foodi DZ401 or DZ550 DualZone XL, I would buy the GCQ Air Fryer Grill. Two plates for two baskets, a real airflow design for better browning, and dishwasher-safe cleanup is a genuinely useful upgrade to how the machine cooks. If I had a Ninja Foodi air fry oven, I would buy the Dinlon Air Fry Crumb — but only after confirming my model number is on that list. Buying the wrong one of these is not a matter of preference; it simply will not fit.
The brand states it is designed for those two 10-quart DualZone XL models and is not suitable for other models. Measure your existing plate before ordering.
Yes — SP101 and many related variants, including SP080, SP100, SP102, SP201, SP301 and the FT102 series, are on the compatibility list. Check your exact model number first.
No. The GCQ plate is for cooking in basket-style DualZone air fryers; the Dinlon tray is for catching mess in air fry ovens. They fit different machines and do different jobs.
That depends on what you are replacing. If your oven's original crumb tray is damaged, the Dinlon set restores function you have already lost. If your baskets never brown the underside of food well, the GCQ plates change how the machine performs. Check the current price on Amazon for each and weigh it against which problem you actually have.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GCQ Air Fryer Grill vs TCSNOE 125PCs: Air Fryer Grill Pan, GXF Air Fryer Grill vs GCQ Air Fryer Grill: Air Fryer Grill, GCQ Air Fryer Tray vs GWYXC Air Fryer Grill: Air Fryer Rack