How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Garneck Silicone Basket Liner — biggest strength: Two reusable round silicone pots at 7.48 x 7.48 x 2.2 inches each, with a ridged bottom designed to guide airflow and a non-stick surface that wipes or rinses clean.
• Garneck Silicone Basket Liner — biggest trade-off: It's the smaller and lighter of the two at 3.84 ounces per unit, with no handles listed, so lifting a hot, full liner out of the basket takes a little more care.
• Alipis Air Fryer Liner — biggest strength: Slightly wider and deeper at 7.87 x 7.87 x 2.28 inches, and it's the only one of the two that lists built-in handles for grabbing the pot straight out of the basket.
• Alipis Air Fryer Liner — biggest trade-off: At 7.4 ounces per unit it's noticeably heavier, and the larger footprint means it needs a wider basket to sit flat rather than curl up the sides.
• Who each pick is for: Garneck for smaller round air fryers and anyone who wants a light, fuss-free liner they can swap between two pots; Alipis for wider baskets and anyone who prioritizes handles and a beefier build.
The Garneck Silicone Basket Liner is a two-pack of round silicone pots, each measuring 7.48 x 7.48 x 2.2 inches and weighing 3.84 ounces. That's a compact, light format. In my opinion, that's the whole point of this set: it's designed to drop into a standard round air fryer basket, cook chicken wings, burgers, fish, shrimp or a breakfast portion, and then come out without a wrestling match.
What it does best is the everyday basics. The silicone is non-stick, so food releases instead of clinging, and the description notes it can be brushed clean or put in the dishwasher. Because the liner sits between your food and the basket, it also cuts down on the oil and butter you'd otherwise need to keep things from sticking. The bottom of the pot has a raised pattern meant to guide airflow underneath the food so heat distributes more evenly — a small design detail that matters more than it sounds, because a flat silicone mat can block airflow and leave the underside of your food pale and soft.
It's also worth noting the versatility. Garneck lists this liner as usable in round air fryers plus microwaves, ovens and stovetops, so it can double as a small baking or roasting mat for desserts, barbecue sides or a quick reheat. The silicone is described as not easy to deform, which is the trait you want if you're going to be washing it repeatedly rather than treating it as disposable.
Alipis Air Fryer Liner: Who It's For
The Alipis Air Fryer Liner is also a two-pack of round silicone pots, but the numbers tell a different story: 7.87 x 7.87 x 2.28 inches and 7.4 ounces per unit. That's roughly four-tenths of an inch wider, a hair deeper, and close to double the weight of the Garneck. The weight difference is the tell — this is the sturdier, more substantial liner of the two, and the purple colorway makes it easy to spot at the bottom of a basket.
The headline feature is the handles. Alipis lists them right in the product title, and that's a genuine functional difference. Lifting a hot silicone pot full of chicken legs out of a hot basket is the awkward part of using any liner, and molded handles solve it directly. If you've ever pinched a hot liner with tongs and watched it fold and spill, you'll understand why this matters.
Beyond that, the Alipis covers the same ground as the Garneck: non-stick surface, dishwasher and brush friendly, a bottom design that guides airflow for even heat, and no cracking or leaking oil when you pull it out. Alipis specifically calls out bread, chips, snacks, chicken wings and legs, plus breads, buns, dumplings and dim sum — a slightly more pastry-and-snack-leaning list than Garneck's, though both handle the same categories of food. It's also listed as suitable for microwaves, ovens and stovetops alongside round air fryers.
Who should buy it: anyone with a wider round basket, anyone who wants to lift the liner out by hand instead of with tongs, and anyone who prefers a heavier, more rigid pot. Who should skip it: if your air fryer basket is small, the larger footprint may not sit flat. And if you want the lightest possible liner, the Alipis is the heavier choice by a clear margin.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for wider round air fryer baskets → Alipis Air Fryer Liner. At 7.87 inches across and 2.28 inches deep, it needs and uses more room.
• Best for easy removal of hot food → Alipis Air Fryer Liner. It's the only one of the two with handles listed.
• Best for a light, low-bulk liner → Garneck Silicone Basket Liner. 3.84 ounces per pot versus 7.4 ounces.
• Best for a sturdier, more rigid feel → Alipis Air Fryer Liner. The heavier build is the practical difference here.
• Best for keeping two liners in rotation → either. Both are sold as two-packs of round silicone pots, so you always have a spare while one is drying.
• Best for non-stick, dishwasher-friendly cleanup → either. Both list a non-stick surface, brush or dishwasher cleaning, and an airflow-guiding base.
• Best for an all-round pick if you're unsure of your basket size → Garneck Silicone Basket Liner. The smaller diameter is more forgiving in a tight basket, since an oversized liner won't sit flat.
If I were buying for myself, I'd take the Alipis Air Fryer Liner. The handles are the deciding factor for me — they turn the messiest part of using a silicone liner into a non-issue, and the heavier build suggests it holds its shape better over time. I'd only switch to the Garneck if my basket were on the smaller side, since a liner that's too wide for the basket defeats the purpose. In short: go Alipis for the handles and the sturdier feel, go Garneck for a compact, lightweight fit.
FAQ
Both are round silicone pots. Garneck measures 7.48 x 7.48 x 2.2 inches; Alipis measures 7.87 x 7.87 x 2.28 inches. Measure the flat bottom of your basket before ordering — if the liner is wider than the basket floor, it will curl up at the edges and sit unevenly.
Handles and weight. The Alipis has handles and weighs 7.4 ounces per pot; the Garneck has no handles listed and weighs 3.84 ounces per pot. Everything else — non-stick surface, dishwasher-friendly cleaning, airflow-guiding bottom — is broadly the same.
Both come as two-packs, so the value question comes down to fit rather than count. If the larger Alipis fits your basket, its handles and heavier build give you more for the same two-pot setup. If your basket is small, the Garneck is the one that will actually sit flat and get used. Check the current price on Amazon before deciding.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: QCdeSoulBLV Square Airfryer Silicone vs Meyrwoy Airfryer Silicone Line, LeifyLife 2 vs KUILONGT 7.7: Air Fryer Silicone Liner, air fryer silicone basket