How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• FryEasy's biggest strength: a custom-cut 10x10 inch square paper liner made specifically for the Ninja Double Stack SL401, SL201 and Crispi 4 QT tray — 50 of them in the pack, so cleanup becomes "lift and toss."
• FryEasy's biggest trade-off: it's disposable paper only. No rack, no pan, no reusable mat, and it's useless in any air fryer outside those Ninja models.
• GWY's biggest strength: a 4-in-1 set — large grill rack, large baking pan, four reusable baking mats and 100 sheets of parchment — built exclusively for the Emeril Lagasse Dual Zone 360 French Door 25 QT oven, with heat resistance up to 480°F.
• GWY's biggest trade-off: it's a bigger commitment in storage space, it's tied to one specific 25 QT oven, and the parchment has its own safety rules (never preheat with paper alone, keep it under food, stay at or below 450°F).
• Pick FryEasy if you own a Ninja Double Stack and your only real enemy is greasy cleanup after wings.
• Pick GWY if you own the Emeril Lagasse 25 QT French Door oven and you want one box that covers air frying, baking and grilling.
FryEasy's entire pitch is fit and convenience. These are square paper liners, 10x10 inches, custom-made for the Ninja Double Stack XL models SL401 and SL201 plus the Ninja Crispi 4 QT tray. The material is paper, they're non-toxic and BPA-free, and they form a barrier between your food and the heating elements. You get 50 sheets in the pack (listed as 50 items / 50 sheet count), which is a lot of cooking sessions before you think about reordering.
The way it actually works is simple: you preheat the air fryer without the liner inside, then add the liner and enough food to weigh it down. That last part is the one thing people get wrong — a light paper liner in an empty basket will flap around, so you need food holding it in place. Once you follow that, the liner catches the grease and crumbs, and cleanup becomes pulling out a sheet instead of scrubbing a basket.
Who should buy it? Anyone with a Ninja Double Stack SL401, SL451 or SL201 who cooks messy things regularly. Chicken wings are the obvious case — they throw off a lot of fat, and a liner means you're not soaking and scraping afterward. Same story with breaded fish, bacon, marinated drumsticks. It's also a good fit if you dislike the texture of a scratched-up non-stick basket and want a sacrificial layer between your food and the coating.
GWY Air Fryer Accessories: Who It's For
GWY goes the opposite direction: instead of disposables, you get hardware. The set is built exclusively for the Emeril Lagasse Dual Zone 360 French Door Air Fryer Oven 25 QT, and it includes one large grill rack (14.1" x 11.8"), one large baking pan (14" x 12"), four reusable non-stick baking mats (12" x 13.8"), and 100 sheets of disposable parchment paper. The rack, pan and mats are steel and fiberglass construction with a non-stick coating, food-grade and BPA-free, rated to withstand up to 480°F without warping.
That's a real range of jobs. The grill rack is the piece that matters most for wings, fries and steaks — it lifts food so hot air circulates underneath instead of letting it sit in its own drippings. The baking pan handles cakes, casseroles, roasted vegetables and meat. The reusable mats are for delicate stuff like fish and cookies. The parchment is the throwaway layer that keeps the oven interior clean.
Two usage notes are worth repeating because they're safety points, not marketing: never run the parchment alone during preheat (always put it under food), and don't exceed 450°F with the accessories if you want them to last. Also, GWY itself says to confirm your appliance is the 25 QT model before buying. The pan is 14 inches wide — it is not going to fit a compact basket air fryer, and it isn't meant to. Total set weight is 3.39 pounds, so storage is a shelf or a drawer, not a shoebox.
Who should buy it? Owners of that specific Emeril Lagasse 25 QT French Door oven who want to stop buying one-off accessories. It's one purchase that covers air frying, baking, grilling and roasting, and the non-stick surfaces wipe clean or go in the dishwasher. If you cook wings on the rack and vegetables in the pan in the same session, this set earns its shelf space.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for grease control after chicken wings → FryEasy Air Fryer Liners. Paper catches the fat; you throw it away.
• Best for crispy wings with airflow underneath → GWY Air Fryer Accessories. The grill rack lifts food so hot air moves all around it.
• Best for zero-scrub cleanup → FryEasy. Pull the liner out and the basket is essentially clean.
• Best for baking and roasting, not just air frying → GWY. The 14" x 12" pan and four baking mats open up cakes, casseroles and cookies.
• Best for people who hate repurchasing consumables → GWY. The rack, pan and mats are reusable; only the parchment is disposable.
• Best for storage-limited kitchens → FryEasy. A flat stack of 50 paper squares takes almost no room.
• Best for high-heat tolerance → GWY. Rack, pan and mats are rated to 480°F, with a 450°F ceiling recommended for longevity.
• Best match for a Ninja Double Stack SL401/SL201 → FryEasy. Custom cut for those baskets and the Crispi 4 QT tray.
• Best match for an Emeril Lagasse 25 QT French Door oven → GWY. Designed for that exact cavity.
In my opinion, these aren't competitors — they're answers to different questions, and the right buy depends entirely on what's on your counter. If you own a Ninja Double Stack and your pain point is scraping wing grease out of a basket every night, I'd buy the FryEasy Air Fryer Liners. Fifty sheets, correct fit, done. If you own the Emeril Lagasse 25 QT French Door oven and you want to cook more than one kind of thing, I'd buy the GWY set — the rack alone changes how well wings and fries crisp, and the pan and mats mean you're not buying again next month. Match the product to your appliance first; everything else follows.
how to air fryer chicken wings
Pat the wings dry, season them, and arrange them in a single layer with space between each piece. If you're using FryEasy liners, preheat the air fryer without the liner first, then add the liner and enough wings to hold it down. If you're using GWY, set the wings on the grill rack so air circulates underneath. Either way, flip them partway through cooking.
how to air fryer chicken wings crispy
Airflow and dryness are what get you there. The GWY large grill rack is the better tool here because it lifts the wings off the surface so hot air hits both sides. With FryEasy, keep the wings in one layer rather than piled up, and don't crowd the liner — steam trapped between pieces is what makes them soggy.
how to air fryer chicken wings in the oven
If you mean using an air fryer oven like the Emeril Lagasse 25 QT French Door model, the GWY set is built for exactly that cavity. Use the grill rack for the wings and the baking pan underneath to catch drippings, which keeps the oven interior far cleaner. Keep the parchment under the food, never alone during preheat, and stay at or below 450°F.
how to air fry chicken wings from frozen
Frozen wings work, but they need longer and they release more moisture, so expect a drier first pass. Spread them out so they aren't touching — on a GWY grill rack or on a FryEasy liner with food weighing the paper down. Pour off any pooled liquid partway through, then raise the heat for the last few minutes to crisp the skin.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Garolue Silicone Heat Resistant vs FryEasy Air Fryer Liners, POPQEEN Air Fryer Liners vs SVNWZGM Air Fryer Accessories, Pssopp Fryer Accessories vs Aramox Food Grade 304: Air Fryer