How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• ETHZZLE 2pcs — biggest strength: Fine stainless steel mesh that physically blocks oil splatter and filters smoke while still letting air and heat through. Biggest trade-off: You get two screens and nothing else, and they're small at roughly 5.9 inches across, so fit matters.
• Phefop 8PCS — biggest strength: Eight fiber filters in one pack that absorb and neutralize cooking odors rather than just blocking grease. Biggest trade-off: They're consumable — designed for a specific 6-quart fryer with a top filter housing, and they wear out.
• ETHZZLE 2pcs is for you if your problem is a greasy mess, splatter on the counter, or smoke drifting around the kitchen.
• Phefop 8PCS is for you if your problem is the smell that hangs around after the fryer is off — fish, onions, bacon, that sort of thing.
• Neither is a universal upgrade. One is a durable cover you keep; the other is a supply of disposables you replace.
The ETHZZLE 2pcs is a splatter screen built from stainless steel with a fine mesh center and a heat-resistant rim. Its whole job is mechanical: put it over your air fryer (or a frying pan — the sheet lists both uses) and the mesh catches oil droplets and smoke particles before they reach your counter, your walls, or the inside of the appliance. Because it's stainless steel, it's rigid and it doesn't degrade from heat the way a fabric cover would. The fine mesh also allows airflow, so it doesn't smother the cooking process the way a solid lid would.
Two screens in the box is the practical part. You can keep one on the fryer and one on a pan, or keep one clean while the other soaks. Cleaning is straightforward: stainless mesh rinses, wipes, or goes in the sink without much fuss, and the design is meant to attach and detach easily.
Who should skip it? If your complaint is smell rather than mess, a stainless screen won't do much — mesh blocks droplets, it doesn't absorb odor molecules. And check the size before you commit: at roughly 5.9 x 5.9 inches with a 0.08-inch thickness, it's a compact cover, not a full-size lid for a big appliance. If your fryer's top opening is much wider than that, a small screen may sit awkwardly. Note that ETHZZLE doesn't state a specific model compatibility list — it's described as universal — so measure your own unit rather than assuming.
Phefop 8PCS: Who It's For
The Phefop 8PCS is a different category of product entirely: replacement air filters, not a cover. These are fiber filter pads that go into the filter housing on top of a compatible fryer. The sheet is specific here — they're designed for a 6-quart fryer with ClearCook and OdorErase, which tells you this is a consumable that slots into an existing odor-management system. Each pad weighs about 0.6 ounces and measures roughly 6.3 x 2.0 inches, and you get eight of them.
The function is odor elimination. Fiber media traps grease and smoke particles and absorbs the smells that would otherwise circulate through your kitchen and linger in the room after cooking. That's a genuinely different benefit from splatter protection: it addresses the "my whole house smells like fried food two hours later" problem. The sheet notes the filters work during and after cooking, and that they're meant to be swapped out as they wear — which is why a pack of eight matters. It's a supply, not a single purchase.
Installation is deliberately simple: unplug the unit, lift the filter housing off the top, pull the old filter, drop in a new one. No tools, no disassembly. That's a five-second job, which is exactly what you want from something you'll replace regularly.
Who should buy it? Owners of the specific 6-quart fryer this fits who are tired of cooking odors, or who are running low on the filters that came with the appliance. If you already use your fryer's top-mounted filter housing, this is a straightforward restock. Anyone cooking fish, onions, or anything pungent regularly will get the most out of them.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for stopping oil splatter → ETHZZLE 2pcs. Physical mesh barrier, stainless construction, sits over the cooking surface.
• Best for eliminating cooking smells → Phefop 8PCS. Fiber media designed to absorb odors, not just block droplets.
• Best for a buy-once accessory → ETHZZLE 2pcs. Stainless steel doesn't get used up; you keep both screens.
• Best for an ongoing supply → Phefop 8PCS. Eight pads means you're stocked for repeated replacements.
• Best for skillet and pan use → ETHZZLE 2pcs. The sheet references frying pan and pot lid use, not just air fryers.
• Best if you own a 6-quart ClearCook/OdorErase fryer → Phefop 8PCS. That's the stated fit; anything else is a gamble.
• Best for a small kitchen where smoke is the issue → ETHZZLE 2pcs. Fewer airborne droplets means less haze.
• Best for open-plan living where odors travel → Phefop 8PCS. Odor control matters more when the kitchen shares air with the rest of the home.
In my opinion, I'd buy the ETHZZLE 2pcs first. It's the more broadly useful accessory: reusable, durable stainless steel, no compatibility rabbit hole beyond checking the size, and it addresses the mess that most air fryer owners actually complain about. The Phefop 8PCS is the better buy only if you specifically own the 6-quart ClearCook/OdorErase fryer and odor — not grease — is your pain point. If that's you, eight filters is a sensible stock-up. If you're unsure, start with the screen and check the current price on Amazon before deciding.
They're not really comparable — one is a reusable stainless screen, the other a pack of eight disposable fiber filters. Value depends on whether you want a one-time durable accessory or an ongoing supply. Check the current price on Amazon for each before deciding.
Only if it's the 6-quart model with ClearCook and OdorErase and a top filter housing. The sheet states that compatibility directly, so measure and confirm your model before ordering.
Not really. Its fine mesh filters oil and smoke particles and blocks splatter, which reduces airborne grease — but it isn't an odor-absorbing filter. For smell, the Phefop route is the design meant for that job.
They serve different functions and don't replace one another. You could reasonably use a splatter screen for mess control and replacement filters for odor control if your fryer supports the filter housing — but each stands on its own.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: NOENNULL 8PCS vs EKRHORBY 2Pcs, Befunu 3Pack vs ETHZZLE 125ml, AODPWEN 2 vs PEJATTN 2PCS