YouTube

A critical analysis of YouTube as a learning product

By: Natalie Oldfield

This analysis will surround videos in the classroom, more specifically, YouTube videos. YouTube is far from a new technology, but as classrooms are moving to the online space due to the current pandemic, educators are looking for ways to offer students variety in the online classroom and are utilizing YouTube more than ever. There is more than one way to integrate YouTube videos in the classroom. The two most frequent is the consuming or watching of YouTube videos and the other is the creation of YouTube videos. Both have great benefits; however, this analysis focuses on utilizing YouTube videos as an instructional aid, for supplementary material, and in planning. Why are educators looking to YouTube? “Studies show positive gains in student outcomes as a result of the integration of video technology in instruction” (Jones & Kristen Cuthrell, 2011). This analysis will dig deeper into just how YouTube can improve student comprehension and success in the classroom, the benefits and shortfalls of the tool, and how an educator can overcome these challenges.

But first, let’s look at what YouTube is and their journey to becoming the biggest force in online video.


YouTube's Mission

Our mission is to give everyone a voice and show them the world.


YouTube has over 2 billion monthly users who watch hundreds of hundreds of millions of hours of content every single day. But many people don't know how YouTube got its start (Leskin, 2020).

Late 2004

From left to right: YouTube cofounders Steve Chen, Chad Hurley, and Jawed Karim

Three early employees of e-payment startup PayPal — Chad Hurley, Steve Chen, and Jawed Karim — start working on an idea for a website for users to upload video-dating profiles. They work out of Hurley's garage in Menlo Park, California (Leskin, 2020).



2005

February: Hurley registers the trademark, logo, and domain for YouTube.

April: The dating site idea never gets off the ground, so the founders decide to transform into a free video-hosting platform.

May: Its beta version opens to the public for the first time.

December: YouTube launches out of beta and is getting 8 million views a day (Leskin, 2020).


2006-present

October 2006: After a back-and-forth battle between Yahoo and Google, Google acquires YouTube for $1.65 billion. Under Google, YouTube went from being a repository of amateur video to a powerhouse of original content that attracts more than 2 billion monthly users (Leskin, 2020).


The Value of Video In Education

"The video medium has acknowledged instructional benefits. It has the ability to depict realistic and immersive motion sequences, to capture and preserve real-world events and places, and to change the size and speed of recorded natural phenomena that cannot be seen with the naked eye. These capabilities can be regarded as ‘essential representational attributes’ of the video medium that confer it a great potential for pedagogy" (Espino et al., 2020). Many studies have been done surrounding the effectiveness of video in comparison to other types of media. Espino et al. have found that animated graphics are superior to simple static graphics in knowledge development. Furthermore, there is strong evidence that shows that learning is improved when simultaneous presentation of pictures and speech is presented (2020). "Many studies suggest that video as an instructional resource contributes to enhancing learning, whether directly or indirectly, through increased student satisfaction or engagement. In addition, online digital video is a useful resource to respond to the diverse needs of students" (Espino et al., 2020).

The role the teacher plays is important when it comes to integrating video in the classroom. It is the teacher who not only decides when to integrate the video resource, but also how it is to be integrated - both important considerations. The spectrum in regards to use is vast. Teachers may choose to use a few videos as supplementary material (common for the conventional course design), or the teacher can choose to implement a design that utilizes video as a primary source of information (Espino et al., 2020). "Video also arouses the senses in ways that other media cannot. Berk argued that video has the ability to grab students’ attention, create anticipation among students, and increase memorized content among other potential outcomes" (as seen in Espino et at., 2020).

YouTube Benefits and Challenges

Benefits

  1. Options and variety is probably one of the top benefits of YouTube. There are over one billion videos on just about anything. Teachers are no longer the sole source of information in the classroom. “The wide availability of streaming videos makes them especially attractive for educational uses” (Espino et al., 2020).

  2. In the classroom, YouTube is becoming an educational tool to enhance learning in innovative ways. YouTube can be used as a tool to inform and display and as a forum for critical analysis and commentary (Jones & Cuthrell, 2011).

  3. Integration of YouTube have also enabled teachers to appropriately differentiate instruction to meet the needs of diverse learners. Visual-spatial learners benefit greatly from visual tools in the classroom (Jones & Cuthrell, 2011).

  4. YouTube videos are easy to embed in Learning Management Systems. There is no need to leave the learning space to view the videos.

  5. The YouTube app (which often comes standard with mobile devices) is a reliable tool that allows users to carry the billions of videos with them every where they go. Videos are easily viewed on mobile devices.

  6. Free of charge.

Challenges

  1. Reliability: A pitfall of YouTube is the possibility that a video may not be available at any given time. Since YouTube is an open site, videos are added and deleted from the site on a daily basis. YouTube is thereby unreliable in terms of retrieving a video and airing it on a whim (Jones & Cuthrell, 2011).

  2. Copyright and fair use law is still unclear as to YouTube content and fair use. As it stands, the copyrighted material available on YouTube is either there with the blessing of the copyright holder or there because the copyright holder has not requested its removal (Jones & Cuthrell, 2011).

  3. Many videos are lacking transcripts or accurate closed captioning for those that rely on it.

  4. Requires internet connection and a viewing medium. Can be a challenge for those facing socioeconomic challenges.

  5. The current lack of peer review may mean that content is lacking or inaccurate (Jones & Cuthrell, 2011).


How Can Educators Use YouTube?

YouTube videos can be used directly as a part of instruction, to introduce new concepts, disseminate information during primary instruction, or close lessons by recapping important points. Most lessons that incorporate video directly into the lesson use the video as an attention-grabbing mechanism or as a part of direct instruction (Jones & Cuthrell, 2011).

YouTube Learning

YouTube Learning advertises the channel as being a destination designed to offer teens and adults quality learning content. Here you will find playlists that spark your curiosity and content ranging in subjects from physics to filmmaking. So, whether you’re studying for a test, want to learn a new skill, or are just curious about the world around you, YouTube.com/Learning has something for you!

YouTube Learning compiles credible videos from various channels on YouTube to create a playlist for users who are interested in learning about a particular topic.

Here is an example of a playlist on Community Groups:

A sample Google for Education video

Google for Education

Google for Education is about learning for everyone, anywhere. They offer product news and updates, resources, and ideas. They believe that every student and every educator, in every classroom, deserves the tools and skills that set them up for success in building the future they want for themselves. They advertise being committed to supporting students, partnering with educators, building products and making impactful investments that help expand access to education through technology.

It does appear, however, that a majority of the videos would be most useful for educators as opposed to students.

Self-creation

Creating a YouTube channel for your classroom is a great option. Educators can either record their own videos and placing them in their channel or compile quality videos and create a playlist that can be accessed through the class channel. “Video self-production is scarce, though respondents declare a positive attitude, with time constraints and technical qualification as main reported obstacles”(Espino et al., 2020). In higher education, instructor-generated videos have been suggested as a way to strengthen the faculty and student connection. There is evidence that instructor presence in an online course contributes positively to student experience, engagement and attitude (Espino et al., 2020).

Overcoming Challenges

Many of the challenges mentioned above can be overcome by critically selecting appropriate videos for the classroom that are credible, accurate, reasonable, and have clear educational value. (Jones & Cuthrell, 2011). Teachers must be cautioned against using the technology simply because it is there. They are encouraged to take a close look at the source of the video. Is there a reasonable amount of quality control? "Anyone can display almost any non-copyrighted material on YouTube. Educators must consider how comprehensive and complete the information in a video is before presenting it to a class" (Jones & Cuthrell, 2011). YouTube has a plethora of information, much useful, but also quite a bit that has no educational value whatsoever. It's important for educators to do their due diligence and sort through the resources and seek out "material has the ability to enhance learning by stimulating multiple senses and anchoring material to the prior knowledge of students" (Jones & Cuthrell, 2011).

Conclusion

"An important part of education is student's learning. Good quality education is based mainly on how well student attain the knowledge. One way to achieve that is to simplify the content and make it as intuitive as possible" (Chtouki et al., 2012). YouTube assists in allowing teachers to do this. Additionally, studies show that students both understand and can recall complex concepts much better when they have been exposed to a visual explanation video (Chtouki et al., 2012). When properly vetted, YouTube is a great resource for both teachers and students. One would be hard pressed to find any subject matter missed on YouTube. The options and topics are incredibly vast. This user-friendly and accessible mobile tool offers students an opportunity to engage with the material and can serve as a springboard for classroom activities. This free web-based service has proven to be an effective tool to enhance student learning and engagement (Chtouki et al., 2012).

References

  1. Chtouki, Yousra & Harroud, Hamid & Khalidi, Mohammed & Bennani, Samir. (2012). The impact of YouTube videos on the student's learning. 2012 International Conference on Information Technology Based Higher Education and Training, ITHET 2012. 1-4. 10.1109/ITHET.2012.6246045.

  2. Farag, M., Bolton, D., & Lawrentschuk, N. (2020). Use of YouTube as a Resource for Surgical Education—Clarity or Confusion. European Urology Focus, 6(3), 445-449. doi:10.1016/j.euf.2019.09.017

  3. José Miguel Santos Espino, María Dolores Afonso Suárez & Juan José González-Henríquez (2020) Video for teaching: classroom use, instructor self-production and teachers’ preferences in presentation format, Technology, Pedagogy and Education, 29:2, 147-162, DOI: 10.1080/1475939X.2020.1726805

  4. Leskin, P. (2020, May 30). YouTube is 15 years old. Here's a timeline of how YouTube was founded, its rise to video behemoth, and its biggest controversies along way. Retrieved from https://www.businessinsider.com/history-of-youtube-in-photos-2015-10

  5. Troy Jones & Kristen Cuthrell (2011) YouTube: Educational Potentials and Pitfalls, Computers in the Schools, 28:1, 75-85, DOI: 10.1080/07380569.2011.553149