How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a big box of single-use liners that fit dual-basket air fryers and toaster-oven trays alike, choose Eslotre Air Fryer Disposable; if you need four thick reusable mats you can wipe down and use again for months in a Cuisinart-style toaster oven air fryer, choose SIUDANGKA 4.
• Eslotre Air Fryer Disposable — biggest trade-off: They are disposable by design, and the included warning says you must not preheat with an empty liner or cook too little food, or the light paper can lift into the heating element.
• SIUDANGKA 4 — biggest strength: Four 12 x 12 inch reusable fiberglass-and-coating mats rated to 450°F, dishwasher-safe and multi-purpose as a drip pan, baking mat, grill mat or pan liner.
• SIUDANGKA 4 — biggest trade-off: Only four sheets in the pack, and they are square 12-inch mats, so they are not pre-shaped to a specific basket and you must keep them off the heating elements.
• Who each pick is for: Eslotre is for anyone who hates cleanup and cooks often in a rectangular or dual-basket fryer; SIUDANGKA 4 is for Cuisinart toaster-oven air fryer owners who would rather scrub and reuse than restock.
Eslotre sells convenience, and it sells a lot of it. The pack is 125 sheets of food-grade parchment, each already formed into a shallow rectangular bowl measuring 8.6 x 5.5 inches with a raised edge of about 1.7 inches. That shape matters more than it sounds. Anyone who has fought a flat roll of parchment into a square basket knows the drill — fold, crease, trim, and then watch the corners curl back up. Here you just drop the liner in and start cooking.
The size is clearly aimed at two-basket machines and rectangular-basket combos. Eslotre lists compatibility with 2-basket models such as the DZ201 and DZ401 Foodi, Instant Pot Vortex Plus, PowerXL Vortex, Chefman TurboFry Touch, Bella Pro Series, CROWNFUL and Westinghouse dual-basket units, plus grill-and-air-fryer combos with rectangular baskets such as the IG601, IG651 and FG511. The material is waterproof, oil-proof and non-stick, heat resistant to 428°F, and the company says it does not affect the taste of food. I have no reason to doubt the spec sheet on any of that — those are standard numbers for good parchment.
The buyer here is someone who cooks in one of those baskets several times a week and values time over everything else. Throw the liner out, and the basket is close to unused. No soaking, no scrubbing the corners, no grease trap at the bottom. Because the count is 125, this is also the pick for a household that cooks for two or three people and goes through a liner most days.
Who should skip it? Anyone who dislikes consumables, and anyone who wants to line a round or unusually shaped basket. The 8.6 x 5.5 inch rectangle is a specific fit, not a universal one. Read the safety note carefully too: do not run the fryer with an empty liner during preheat, and do not use it with too little food. The paper is light, hot air can lift it, and if it contacts the heating pipe it can char. That is not a defect — it is how thin parchment behaves — but it means you need to weigh your food down and stay present for the first minute of cooking.
SIUDANGKA 4 goes the opposite direction. You get four sheets, each 12 x 12 inches, made from fiberglass fabric with a food-safe non-stick coating that is BPA-free and PFOA-free. They are black, and the pack contains four leaves. That is the whole product, and for the right user it is enough for a long time.
The intended home is a Cuisinart air fryer toaster oven, specifically the TOA-70NAS, and the mats are also stated to fit the Emeril Lagasse French Door 360 air fryer. The model number on the listing, TOA 60/65/70, tells you this is a toaster-oven accessory first and a basket accessory second. You lay a mat on the bottom floor, and it catches drips, crumbs and grease before they bake onto the interior. When you are done, it goes in the dishwasher and comes back out ready to use.
Two things make these mats more versatile than a plain oven liner. First, they are rated to 450°F, which is higher than the parchment's 428°F, so they tolerate a broader range of oven and air-fry settings. Second, SIUDANGKA lists them as multi-function: BBQ grill mat, baking mat, oven liner and pan liner, plus a drip pan for protecting the oven floor. Four mats of that size cover a lot of jobs around a kitchen.
The trade-offs are real, though. You only get four, so if you cook three meals a day you will be washing them often — the trade-off for reusability is labor, not money. Because they are 12-inch squares rather than a molded basket shape, they will not hug the walls of a deep dual-basket fryer the way a bowl-shaped liner does; they sit flat. And the safety reminder is explicit: when used as a crumb tray, place it only on the bottom floor, keep it away from the lower heating elements, and never exceed 450°F. Teflon-style coatings degrade when pushed past their rating, so respect that ceiling.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for near-zero cleanup effort → Eslotre Air Fryer Disposable. You throw it away; there is nothing to wash.
• Best for long-term reuse → SIUDANGKA 4. Four mats, dishwasher-safe, multi-purpose, and rated 22°F higher.
• Best for dual-basket and rectangular-basket fryers → Eslotre Air Fryer Disposable. Its 8.6 x 5.5 inch bowl shape is built for exactly those baskets.
• Best for Cuisinart toaster-oven air fryers → SIUDANGKA 4. It is sized and shaped for that oven floor, including the TOA-70NAS.
• Best for high-volume cooking → Eslotre Air Fryer Disposable. 125 sheets means you are not doing dishes after every single meal.
• Best for camping, BBQ and grilling → SIUDANGKA 4. The mats work as grill mats and drip pans, which disposable parchment does not.
• Best for people who hate consumables → SIUDANGKA 4. Buy once, wash, repeat.
• Best for people who hate washing anything → Eslotre Air Fryer Disposable. That is the entire point of the product.
In my opinion, most people shopping this comparison should buy the Eslotre Air Fryer Disposable liners — the 125-count box, the pre-formed rectangular bowl, and the 1.7-inch raised edge solve the exact annoyance that sends people looking for air fryer liners in the first place: scrubbing a greasy basket after dinner. I would pick SIUDANGKA 4 only if you own a Cuisinart toaster-oven air fryer, want to protect the oven floor, and genuinely prefer washing four mats over restocking paper. Whichever way you lean, confirm the current price on Amazon before you commit, since both products sit in different budget categories depending on how you count cost per use.
FAQ
It depends on how you cook. Eslotre gives you 125 single-use sheets, so the cost per cook is low but you keep buying. SIUDANGKA 4 gives you four reusable mats you wash and reuse, so the upfront cost is spread over many meals. Heavy daily cooks tend to prefer the reusable route; occasional cooks tend to prefer disposable.
Yes, within their limits. Eslotre parchment is rated to 428°F. SIUDANGKA 4 mats are rated to 450°F. Both have clear warnings: never preheat with an empty parchment liner or cook too little food in it, and never let the reusable mat touch or sit too close to the lower heating elements.
The listing describes them as multi-function liners for air fryers, ovens, grills and pans, so yes — but because they are 12-inch squares, they suit wide, flat cooking surfaces far better than a deep, narrow basket. For a basket, the Eslotre liner is the better-shaped fit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.