How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a precise, model-specific fit for a long list of JBL Tune and JR headphones, choose Erioscar 1; if you need fresh pads for a Jabra Evolve2 30 office headset and want an install tool in the box, choose Generic Replacement Ear Pads. These two aren't really rivals in the usual sense — they serve different headsets entirely — so the real question is which one matches the headphones already sitting on your desk.
• Erioscar 1 — biggest strength: a declared 70 mm diameter with memory foam and soft protein leather, sized to sit "optimally adapted to the original ear pads" across a wide spread of JBL models.
• Erioscar 1 — biggest trade-off: the compatibility list is strict. It will not fit the Tune 600BTNC, and it's a JBL-only part.
• Generic Replacement Ear Pads — biggest strength: high-density slow-rebound memory foam plus a plastic removal tool, so you can swap pads without hunting for a spudger.
• Generic Replacement Ear Pads — biggest trade-off: it's built for the Jabra Evolve2 30 family only, and the listing itself warns it does not fit the Evolve 30.
• Who each is for: Erioscar 1 for JBL Tune/JR owners refreshing worn pads; Generic Replacement Ear Pads for Jabra Evolve2 30 users doing the same.
Erioscar 1 is a single-purpose part, and that's its appeal. It's a pair of replacement ear pads — left and right — made from a memory foam core wrapped in soft protein leather, with a 70 mm diameter the brand describes as optimally adapted to the original pads. In plain terms, that means the shape and mounting are meant to mirror what came on your JBL headphones, so the swap should feel like restoring the headset rather than modifying it.
The compatibility list is the part worth reading twice. It covers the JBL Tune600, T500BT, T450, T450BT, JR300BT, T510BT, T520BT and JR310BT. The brand also flags, in no uncertain terms, that it is not suitable for the Tune 600BTNC — and that one letter string is exactly the sort of thing people skim past. If your model isn't on that list, this isn't your pad. If it is, this is about as direct a match as you'll find.
Generic Replacement Ear Pads: Who It's For
This one is aimed at a completely different desk. It's a pair of ear cushions for the Jabra Evolve2 30 in its 30MS, 30UC and 30SE variants — an office headset used for calls and meetings far more than for music. The brand is upfront that you should confirm your model before buying, and the title carries an explicit warning: it does not fit the Evolve 30. The two names look almost identical. They are not the same headset.
The materials are where this pad makes its case. It uses high-density slow-rebound memory foam with premium soft protein leather, and the pitch is specific: the foam gradually shapes to your ear instead of springing back, so pressure builds more slowly across a long shift. The brand claims no swelling and no pain even during extended wear, and describes it as soft from the very first time you put it on — no break-in period. Whether your ears agree is personal, but the design intent is clear and it's the right intent for a headset worn eight hours a day.
Two practical details stand out. First, a plastic removal tool is included, which matters more than it sounds: prying old pads off a headset without the right lever is how people scratch plastic. Second, the brand states the covers match the original, so the fit should mirror what came in the box. The listing also mentions a one-year manufacturer warranty and a support channel that responds within 24 hours. In my opinion, this is the pick for anyone on an Evolve2 30 whose pads have gone shiny and flat. Skip it if you're on the Evolve 30, or on anything outside that Jabra family.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for JBL Tune and JR owners → Erioscar 1. It lists eight matching headset models by name.
• Best for easy installation → Generic Replacement Ear Pads. A removal tool comes in the box, and the brand says the job takes a few minutes.
• Best for a straightforward align-and-connect swap → Erioscar 1. No tools are mentioned; you line the pads up with the mounts and press them on.
• Best for a defined fit figure → Erioscar 1. The 70 mm diameter is stated outright, which makes it easy to sanity-check against your old pads.
• Best for long-call comfort → Generic Replacement Ear Pads. Slow-rebound foam is the more deliberate choice for hours of headset wear.
• Best for replacing cracked or missing pads → Erioscar 1. The brand frames it squarely as a fix for broken, worn or missing cushions.
• Best for keeping an aging headset out of the bin → either one, matched to your model. Both are refreshes, not upgrades.
I'd buy the one that matches my headphones, because these two never actually compete — they're the same idea aimed at two different brands. If I owned a JBL Tune600, T500BT, T450, T450BT, JR300BT, T510BT, T520BT or JR310BT, I'd take Erioscar 1 for the stated 70 mm fit and the plain align-and-connect install. If I sat in Jabra Evolve2 30 all day, I'd take the Generic Replacement Ear Pads for the slow-rebound foam and the included removal tool. My one firm rule either way: check your exact model number first, including the BTNC and non-BTNC distinction, before you order anything.
No. The brand states explicitly that they are not suitable for the Tune 600BTNC. They fit the Tune600, T500BT, T450, T450BT, JR300BT, T510BT, T520BT and JR310BT.
Will the Generic Replacement Ear Pads fit a Jabra Evolve 30?
No — and this is the easy mistake to make. They're designed for the Evolve2 30 in its 30MS, 30UC and 30SE versions. The listing warns they do not fit the Evolve 30.
Value here isn't about the number on the page — it's about whether the pad fits your headset, since a mismatched pad is worth nothing. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever model matches yours, then compare that against the cost of replacing the headphones outright.
Only for the Jabra pads, which include a plastic removal tool to lift the old cushions and seat the new ones in a few minutes. The Erioscar pads are described as an align-and-connect job with no tools mentioned.
Both sets are built around a memory foam core and a leather cover, and both brands talk about fit and isolation. A cushion that seals properly against your ear is doing real acoustic work, so a worn, flattened pad replaced with a fresh one is a genuine improvement — but it's a restoration, not an upgrade.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: YunYiYi Replacement Earpad vs L LTGEM Replacement Ear Pads, AKHQC Replacement Ear Pads vs Akkiv Replacement earpads Compatible, YOCOWOCO Replacement Ear Pads vs Voarmaks Flats Ear Pads