How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Ericair's biggest strength: a perforated, non-stick grill pan sized for an 8 QT Chefman air fryer, with a center handle and silicone bumpers that protect your air fryer's coating.
• Ericair's biggest trade-off: it only fits one specific class of air fryer basket, so you must measure before buying — and the small footprint limits batch size.
• GWYSY's biggest strength: a large 14.3'' x 12'' food-grade steel tray rated to 450°F that won't warp, built for the Gourmia GTF3588 French door oven.
• GWYSY's biggest trade-off: it's a big flat pan with no handle and no silicone edge protection, so it's awkward in a small air fryer and it's the wrong tool if space is tight.
• Choose Ericair if you cook for one or two in an 8 QT air fryer and want vegetables, fries and wings out fast.
• Choose GWYSY if you own the Gourmia 37QT French door oven and cook larger volumes — sheet-pan style vegetables, multiple portions, family meals.
The Ericair pan is a direct replacement part, not a universal accessory. It measures 10 x 9.88 inches and is designed for the Chefman 8 QT air fryer, specifically models in the RJ38-SQSS-8T-D family. If that's your machine, this is the pan that slots in where the original crisper tray sat. If it isn't, stop here — no amount of good design fixes a size mismatch.
Where it shines is airflow. The tray is perforated so hot air circulates under and around the food instead of just blasting the top. That matters most for vegetables. Dense pieces like broccoli florets, carrot coins, cauliflower and Brussels sprouts cook unevenly when they sit flat on a solid surface — the underside steams while the top browns. A perforated pan gives you browning on more surfaces and a better texture overall. It's also the reason this pan handles wings, fries, fish and small pizzas well.
Who should buy it: owners of an 8 QT Chefman air fryer who cook vegetables, wings and fries regularly and want a spare or upgraded tray. Who should skip it: anyone with a different brand or size of air fryer, and anyone who needs to cook for a crowd — a single 10 x 9.88-inch pan won't do a big batch. One caution from the maker: skip abrasive cloths and metal scouring balls, which will wreck the coating.
GWYSY Toaster Oven Baking: Who It's For
The GWYSY tray is a different animal entirely. It's 14.3'' x 12'' x 0.8'', made of food-grade steel, and designed for the Gourmia GTF3588 French Door 12 Cooking Presets 37QT Air Fryer Oven. That's a countertop oven, not a basket-style air fryer, and the pan is sized to match it.
The headline spec is heat tolerance: it's rated to withstand up to 450°F without warping or deforming. That's the number that matters for oven-style cooking, because you're often running higher heat for roasting and crisping. The material is described as food grade, non-toxic and tasteless, meets FDA standards and contains no BPA. It's dishwasher safe, which is a real quality-of-life feature on a pan this size — hand-washing a 14-inch tray is nobody's idea of fun.
Functionally, this is a sheet pan with an air-fryer label. It handles chicken wings, fries, vegetables, grilling and baking. Because it's flat and wide, it's excellent for spreading vegetables in a single layer so they roast rather than steam. That single-layer trick is the whole game with air-fried vegetables, and this pan gives you the surface area to actually do it. The trade-offs are honest ones: there's no handle, so you'll want oven mitts or a good grip, and there are no silicone bumpers, so you should set it down gently inside the oven to avoid scratching. It's also simply too big for a compact air fryer basket.
Who should buy it: owners of the Gourmia GTF3588 who want a large replacement tray for vegetables, wings and full-sheet roasting. Who should skip it: anyone with a basket-style air fryer or a smaller toaster oven — measure your interior first, as the maker recommends.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for large single-layer batches → GWYSY. A 14.3'' x 12'' surface lets you spread vegetables out without crowding.
• Best for higher-heat roasting → GWYSY. Rated up to 450°F with no warping.
• Best for protecting your appliance's interior → Ericair. The silicone bumper strips exist specifically to prevent scratching.
• Best for easy handling → Ericair. The center handle is a genuine convenience; the GWYSY has none.
• Best for dishwasher convenience → a tie. Both are dishwasher safe.
• Best for compact kitchens → Ericair. It's roughly 10 x 9.88 inches and weighs 7.8 ounces; the GWYSY is a much larger tray.
• Best for family-sized cooking → GWYSY. More surface area means more food per run.
In my opinion, the right pick comes down to one question: what appliance do you own? If it's an 8 QT Chefman air fryer, I'd buy the Ericair. The perforated design, center handle and silicone bumpers make it the more thoughtful piece of hardware for everyday air-fryer vegetables, and it's the pan I'd reach for on a weeknight. If you own the Gourmia 37QT French door oven, I'd buy the GWYSY — nothing else here gives you that much cooking surface with 450°F heat resistance. Buy for the machine you have, not the one you wish you had. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit, and measure your appliance first.
how to air fry vegetables
Cut them into similar-sized pieces, toss lightly with a little oil and seasoning, and spread them in a single layer so hot air reaches every side. With the Ericair pan, the perforations let air circulate underneath; with the GWYSY tray, the wide surface lets you avoid overcrowding. Cook until the edges brown, shaking or turning once.
how to air fry vegetables without oil
You can skip the oil entirely — the perforated design on the Ericair pan and the flat airflow-friendly surface of the GWYSY tray both rely on circulating hot air rather than fat for crisping. Expect a drier, more roasted texture and less browning. A light spritz helps color, but it isn't required for cooking.
how to air fry vegetables in the oven
Use an oven-style air fryer like the Gourmia GTF3588 with the GWYSY tray, which is rated to 450°F and sized to fit. Spread vegetables in one layer, leave space between pieces, and use the oven's air fry or convection setting. The flat pan gives you more room than a basket, so larger batches cook evenly.
will this fit my air fryer
Check your model first. The Ericair pan is built for the Chefman 8 QT air fryer and measures 10 x 9.88 inches; the GWYSY tray is built for the Gourmia GTF3588 37QT and measures 14.3'' x 12''. Measure your appliance's interior before ordering — both makers say so explicitly.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GWYXC Air Fryer Grill vs GWYSY Toaster Oven Replacement, GCQFZ Air Fryer Drip vs GWYSY Toaster Oven accessories, GWY Air Fryer Basket vs GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement