How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want to fix or upgrade the fit of earbuds you already own, choose Earphones Plus 6; if you need to actually block out noise so you can sleep, study or travel in peace, choose iMute Ear Plugs.
These two products sit in the same aisle but do completely different jobs. One is a replacement-part kit for in-ear earphones. The other is a standalone hearing protector. Comparing them head to head only makes sense once you know which job you're hiring for — so let's break down exactly where each one wins and where it falls short.
• Earphones Plus 6 — biggest strength: Six pairs of 14mm silicone replacement ear tips built to restore fit and comfort on in-ear earphones with 4mm–5.5mm connector stems.
• Earphones Plus 6 — biggest trade-off: It makes no sound at all on its own. It's a spare-parts kit, useless without a compatible pair of earbuds, and the 14mm outside diameter won't suit every ear canal.
• iMute Ear Plugs — biggest strength: A stated 33dB noise reduction rating plus four sets of eartip sizes and a carry case, so you can tune the fit and take it anywhere.
• iMute Ear Plugs — biggest trade-off: It blocks sound rather than playing it. If you want music or calls, these aren't for you.
• Buy Earphones Plus 6 if you already love a pair of wired or in-ear earphones and the tips are worn, lost or simply too small.
• Buy iMute Ear Plugs if you want quiet — for sleep, snoring, commuting, focus or loud events — and nothing else.
Earphones Plus 6 is a pack of six pairs of black silicone ear tips with a 14mm outside diameter. That's the whole product. There's no driver, no cable, no battery — just cushions. The point is that ear tips are the part of an earbud that fails first: they harden, tear, fall off on a train, or get chewed by a pet. When that happens, most people assume the earphones are finished. They usually aren't. This kit exists to bring them back.
The critical detail is compatibility. These tips fit ear tip connector stems measuring 4mm to 5.5mm (5/32" to 7/32"). That's a real range — it covers a lot of common in-ear models — but it is not universal. If your stem falls outside it, you're looking at the wrong SKU. Earphones Plus even points buyers toward a larger-hole and smaller-hole version of the same kit, and invites you to ask in the customer Q&A with your exact brand and model if you can't work it out. Read that as a signal: measure before you buy. A ruler against the nozzle of your earbud takes ten seconds and saves a return.
The "Extra Large" in the title refers to that 14mm outside diameter, which is on the generous side. That's good news if stock tips feel cramped, if your ear canals are wide, or if you find yourself constantly pushing earbuds back in. A bigger silicone tip seats deeper and holds a seal better for some ears. The flip side is equally true: if you have narrow canals, a 14mm tip can feel bulky or refuse to sit flush.
So who should buy it? Anyone with a compatible pair of in-ear earphones whose tips are worn, missing or too small — plus anyone who wants a stack of spares so a single lost tip doesn't sideline their favourite buds. Who should skip it? Anyone shopping for something that makes or blocks sound. This is a maintenance purchase, not an audio one. And if you're unsure of your stem size, measure first or ask before ordering.
iMute Ear Plugs are a different animal entirely. These are reusable silicone earplugs with a stated 33dB noise reduction rating, sold with four sets of soft eartip sizes and a compact molded carry case. The pitch is straightforward: block the noise, keep the comfort.
That four-size system matters more than it sounds. Earplug performance collapses if the seal is poor — a plug that doesn't fill your canal lets sound leak straight past it. Having four eartip options means you can experiment until you find the size that actually seals, rather than accepting whatever single size the box shipped with. It's also the reason these work for a wide range of ear shapes, and why the brand positions them for side sleepers and long wear.
The silicone construction is the other half of the story. It's described as hypoallergenic, reusable, durable and easy to clean — which is exactly what you want from something you'll put in your ears night after night. Foam plugs are single-use and get grimy fast; a washable silicone plug you can rinse and reuse is a better long-term habit for daily sleepers.
Use cases are broad and specific at the same time: snoring partners, traffic noise, study sessions, open-plan offices, flights, concerts, loud events, commutes. The included case means they live in a bag pocket or bedside drawer without picking up lint, which is a small thing that makes a big difference to whether you actually keep using them.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for restoring earbuds you already own → Earphones Plus 6. Six pairs of 14mm silicone tips for stems between 4mm and 5.5mm.
• Best for blocking noise → iMute Ear Plugs. A stated 33dB noise reduction rating with four eartip sizes to dial in the seal.
• Best for sleep and side sleeping → iMute Ear Plugs. Soft silicone and multiple sizes are built around extended, overnight wear.
• Best for fit variety → iMute Ear Plugs. Four eartip sizes versus one 14mm diameter across all six pairs in the Earphones Plus kit.
• Best for travel and storage → iMute Ear Plugs. The molded carry case keeps them clean and organised in a bag.
• Best for keeping a favourite pair of earphones alive → Earphones Plus 6. This is a spares kit, and it's the cheaper-feeling fix than replacing working hardware.
• Best for anyone unsure of their stem size → neither, yet. Measure your earbud nozzle first; if it's outside 4mm–5.5mm, Earphones Plus 6 is the wrong SKU.
• Best if you want to hear music or take calls → Earphones Plus 6 (paired with your own earbuds). iMute Ear Plugs are for silence only.
If I had to pick one, I'd pick iMute Ear Plugs — but only because they're a complete, self-contained product that does its job the moment you open the case. Earphones Plus 6 is genuinely useful, and if your problem is worn-out tips on earphones you love, it's the smarter, more surgical fix. But it's a component. It does nothing without a compatible pair of buds and a stem that measures between 4mm and 5.5mm. In my opinion, the iMute set is the safer buy for most people, because noise reduction, four sizes and a case cover more real-world situations. Buy Earphones Plus 6 only if you've already confirmed compatibility.
FAQ
That's one of their stated use cases. The soft silicone and four eartip sizes are designed for a snug, personalised fit and extended wear, which is what side sleepers need. Getting the right size among the four is the key step.
Only if your ear tip connector stem measures 4mm to 5.5mm (5/32" to 7/32"). Measure the nozzle before ordering. If it's outside that range, Earphones Plus offers larger- and smaller-hole versions, and you can ask in the customer Q&A with your exact model.
Prices change constantly, so check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page. On value: iMute gives you a complete reusable product with a case and four tip sizes, while Earphones Plus 6 is a six-pair spares kit — worth it only if you have compatible earphones to fit them to.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.